3 ms·
> The average replacement time for cell phones in the US is 32 months. That is not my replacement cycle nor the replacement cycle for most of the readers of th
by lern_too_spel 7y ago
> The average replacement time for cell phones in the US is 32 months.
That is not my replacement cycle nor the replacement cycle for most of the readers of this forum. It has no bearing on my purchase decisions nor the purchase decisions of most of the readers of this forum. For people who upgrade regularly, which is a group that includes me and most of the people on this forum, Android One and Pixel devices are more secure than iOS devices, and you appear to agree.
> 8 months longer than Google has promised updates.
Android One phones get security updates at least three years after release.
- scarface74 7y agoThat is not my replacement cycle nor the replacement cycle for most of the readers of this forum. Well as long as it caters to you and the rest of the people on HN (have you done a survey?), I guess that’s all that matters - not the other 2 billion people in the world.... Android One and Pixel devices are more secure than iOS devices, and you appear to agree. Android One phones still have to wait on the manufacturer to update their phones. Yes, but they pinky promise they will. From the article I posted. I’ve never had to wait on a manufacturer to get updates from my Windows PCs. Heck I still get updates for my Mac Mini running Windows 7 and Apple definitely had nothing to do with it. Why is the Android architecture so piss poor that they can’t figure this out? This- an OS vendor licensing to OEMs and providing update - has been a solved problem for PCs for well over 30 years. From the earlier article I posted. While updates do still have to go through each phone’s manufacturer, there’s much less to check and update, so updates will generally arrive much faster. It won’t be a day one patch like you’d expect on the Google Pixel range Each Android One phone is guaranteed to get at least three years worth of security updates from its release date, and up to two years of major Android releases, too. Android One phones get security updates at least three years after release. The iPhone 5s (2013) received 5 years worth of OS updates. The 4s (2011) just received a bug fix earlier this month. The 6s (2015) is still a more performant phone than any midrange Android phone released this year and can hold its own against high end Android phones that are two years newer. It would be a pity to replace it if it were an Android phone just because Google couldn’t figure out how to update third party devices. My son is still using it.
- lern_too_spel 7y ago> I guess that’s all that matters - not the other 2 billion people in the world.... I already explained the choices. For us, the obvious choice is a properly updating Android device. Any user who chose an iPhone or non-updating Android phone made a poor security choice. Any user who has a longer than three year upgrade cycle has no good options unless they use a community-maintained Android build. > Android One phones still have to wait on the manufacturer to update their phones. Yes, but they pinky promise they will. They are guaranteed monthly security updates. If you have an example of one that hasn't had monthly security updates, that would be a breach of contract with at least the user and possibly with Google who certified the device as Android One. Windows updates aren't guaranteed to work with arbitrary device manufacturers' custom drivers. > [Irrelevant stuff about how long iOS devices are updated] The comment you replied to was a correction to your claim about how long Android One devices are updated. That is the maximum period a user can get a secure device for because we have already established that all alternatives have non-working security update systems. >The 6s (2015) is still a more performant phone than any midrange Android phone released this year and can hold its own against high end Android phones that are two years newer. You have conceded that iOS is worse for security, so now you want to argue about performance. Android has iOS beat there, too. Here is a midrange Android phone one generation older than the iPhone 6 beating it at the most common task for phone users — opening apps: https://youtu.be/hPhkPXVxISY https://youtu.be/hPhkPXVxISY Here is a midrange Android phone of the same generation as the iPhone 6s beating it in the same test: https://youtu.be/B5ZT9z9Bt4M https://youtu.be/B5ZT9z9Bt4M Of course if you want to get off topic, a more interesting discussion than performance is usability, and Android is multiple generations ahead of iOS for what you can do with it and has been since at least the Verizon Droid, which came with driving navigation and voice control.
- scarface74 7y agoYou have conceded that iOS is worse for security, so now you want to argue about performance. Android has iOS beat there, too. Here is a midrange Android phone one generation older than the iPhone 6 beating it at the most common task for phone users — opening apps: https://youtu.be/hPhkPXVxI* https://youtu.be/hPhkPXVxI* I’m not arguing performance for performance sake. I’m arguing that a four year phone is still performant compared to many newer Android phones and it is getting both* security updates and os upgrades 24 months and 12 months longer than the tiny percentage of Android phones that get either. It also doesn’t have to wait for a third party OEM to decide to push updates. I’m also criticizing Google for not knowing how to push updates to phones running its operating system without OEM intervention - something Microsoft figured out 30 years ago with PCs. But you don’t need to speculate how fast iOS users update their phones. There are plenty of sites showing how many iOS users have updated operating systems compared to Android users: https://www.forbes.com/sites/ianmorris/2018/04/13/android-is-still-failing-where-apples-ios-is-winning/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/ianmorris/2018/04/13/android-is... So do have a cite showing that a larger percentage of Android users are running an up to date OS?