4 ms·
Wow. Banning something unhealthy. That didn’t work out so well for alcohol or drugs. The last thing I want is more government power.
by scarface74 7y ago
Wow. Banning something unhealthy. That didn’t work out so well for alcohol or drugs. The last thing I want is more government power.
- n0mad01 7y agohe also said "health ... associated ... should get priced in" - how about 6€ for a can of coke? people would drink it, but far less.
- SilasX 7y agoIt still has the same problems, in that people can bootleg it. Just at a smaller scale. Remember, they have low-grade turf wars in NYC over cigarette sales due to the really high taxes.
- scarface74 7y agoAnd that also goes to my other point. They have the police another tool to harass people and the police ended up choking a man to death for selling cigarettes illegally that he brought across state lines.
- randcraw 7y agoCigarettes have cost $6 a pack in the US for over a decade and nobody bootlegs these. Same for beer, at $6-12 for a 6-pack. Bootlegging is generally a short term response to diminished access. But soon after the controls arise, demand generally shifts elsewhere to less inconvenient alternatives. I can think of no examples of continuing bootlegging in the US, aside from piracy of media, which is another kettle of fish.
- scarface74 7y agoThis is the result of giving the police yet another tool to harass people for minor offenses. Whether Eric Garner was bootlegging cigarettes or not - do you think it was worth it? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Eric_Garner https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Eric_Garner
- anoncake 7y agoA government does not gain power by exercising it.
- scarface74 7y agoThe more laws you pass where the government can decide to punish people for their own choices that don’t hurt anyone else. The more tools you give them. There is long history of public officials not applying laws equally.
- anoncake 7y agoIf you live in a country where the government decides to punish people (as opposed to the courts), you do indeed have bigger problems than advertising.
- randcraw 7y agoA government has power only if it does exercise it. If all government employees sat around all day and did nothing, the government would be powerless. The more a government exercises power, the more power it takes away from others (like the people). It's only through action that power manifests (and the inaction of others to oppose the use and abuse of that power).
- anoncake 7y ago> A government has power only if it does exercise it. If all government employees sat around all day and did nothing, the government would be powerless. The more a government exercises power, the more power it takes away from others That's bullshit. A government can't take away power from others by exercising the power it doesn't have yet. > (like the people). A democratic state cannot take away power from the people, the people cannot take away power from itself. And non-democratic states don't have a legitimate government anyway.
- zbyte64 7y agoCan't help but think the only reason for that attitude (government power is bad) is that the government isn't representative of its people.
- scarface74 7y agoOr if you belong to a demographic who is routinely stopped for the color of your skin or you look like you “don’t belong”....
- karmelapple 7y agoRather than banning, how about having an age minimum, something that’s worked fairly well* for alcohol and cigarettes? *depending on your definition of working fairly well
- scarface74 7y agoBecause a law has worked really well to stop underage drinking, smoking, and weed. It’s the same consequences. Little Johnny with well connected parents and a judge who doesn’t want to ruin the life of someone “who could be his kid” gets off easy while they expel little Jerome who is just “going to turn out to be a thug anyway.”
- bonoboTP 7y agoThe good solution - already practiced in many European countries for alcohol and tobacco - is to punish the store if they sell to a minor, not the kid who buys it.
- scarface74 7y agoThe store is punished. The store usually doesn’t sell to the minor, a minor can get someone overage to get it from them - especially in college. It also hasn’t stopped kids from getting weed and cigarettes.