6 ms·
Every time I read something like this, I roll my eyes - most of these proposals are dead on arrival. By the time this will be in effect, public transit will hav
by simonebrunozzi 7y ago
Every time I read something like this, I roll my eyes - most of these proposals are dead on arrival. By the time this will be in effect, public transit will have been transformed (if not removed) by private, automated transportation.
And then I always think it would be best to build a city from scratch. A great one. With good principles. Time-proofed. Collectively we should know how to do it, but it seems that it's incredibly hard to come up with the resources to do it properly. It's still only a dream.
- MegaButts 7y ago> Every time I read something like this, I roll my eyes - most of these proposals are dead on arrival. By the time this will be in effect, public transit will have been transformed (if not removed) by private, automated transportation. Every time I hear about self-driving cars being just around the corner I roll my eyes. Most of us will be dead before self-driving cars are in effect, and by then our infrastructure will have already moved on.
- simonebrunozzi 7y agofully level-5 cars? Maybe. Autonomous doesn't have to be fully level-5 to exist in cities. e.g. autonomous subways have been operating in Singapore since 2011, and been technically ready since 2003 [0]. You might argue, "that's public, not private transportation", and of course you're right. But are you sure nothing can be done to private cars to become fully autonomous, without requiring a level-5? e.g. many car models currently on the market are "fully autonomous" on highways, for example. Don't underestimate the innovation that can still happen there. "All new MRT lines built since the North East line in 2003 were equipped with CBTC from the outset, and have the capability to be completely driverless and automated, requiring no onboard staffing." p.s. I rode on the driverless line several times in 2011 and 2012. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_Rapid_Transit_(Singapore) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_Rapid_Transit_(Singapore)
- EliRivers 7y agoBy the time this will be in effect, public transit will have been transformed (if not removed) by private, automated transportation. Honestly can't tell; is this because you're massively pessimistic about how long it will take the proposals to come into effect, or because you're massively optimistic about the advent of private, automated transportation?
- vorpalhex 7y ago> And then I always think it would be best to build a city from scratch Waterfall projects don't work with cities any better than they work with code. While it's harder to be "agile" with cities, the idea of building a large project correctly in a go is misleading. There are many future-centric planned city projects which either died before they ever took off, or were completed and are total ghost towns.
- EliRivers 7y agoFor those interested, cf "Seeing Like a State" and other books by James Scott. Really good reads.
- patmorgan23 7y agoExample of real world failed city. https://youtu.be/gO3LUhFwx6k https://youtu.be/gO3LUhFwx6k
- luckydata 7y agoThis is a blanket statement that can be easily refuted. The overhaul of Barcelona for the Olympics comes to mind, and same story with Torino in Italy. Both cities benefited greatly from a large planned investment in infrastructure. Same thing with Madrid and the doubling of the metro system now that I think about it.
- zeendo 7y agoThis stance is infuriating. Stop letting the best the be enemy of the good. There are lots of ways that the imagined self-driving future can either be a terrible non-improvement or simply take an order of magnitude more time to come to fruition. We have clear and obvious ways to improve things now and we should be building support for that and taking those steps. Not sitting on our hands waiting for a purely technical solution to what's not even remotely just a technical problem.
- akanet 7y agoThis is one of those classic, massively overconfident HN comments. Nothing has proven worse for American cities than massive free public infrastructure devoted to private automobile transportation, and our only hope to make our cities more livable, affordable, and environmentally safer is to massively switch to public transit. The tax on space, time, and energy required to move a bunch of people around in individual little containers is far too high.
- simonebrunozzi 7y agoI should have been more clear. Let me try again. The road infrastructure is already there, and has been already subsidized. It is my opinion that private autonomous transportation will become more efficient and cheaper than public transportation and therefore will supplant it. I speak not as the world expert, but as someone who did a relatively deep analysis of transportation costs in US cities. The ballpark figure is what I call TCTM, or Total Cost of Transportation per Mile, which doesn't take into account the cost of road infrastructure, simply assuming that it is already there. TCTM for uber/lyft and similar services is going down, and you do not even need fully autonomous, level-5 driverless cars, to have a TCTM lower than that offered by public buses. Hope this is clearer.
- sokoloff 7y agoIs there a net tax on time? It's unambiguous that I can get from where I live to where I work at least 40 and often 70 minutes faster in my car than I can on public transportation. (Cambridge, MA to Waltham, MA.) My commute would take me longer if I changed jobs to work in Kendall Sq in Cambridge and took the T across town. (DW worked in Kendall; her T commute was 1/3 the distance of mine and took 1.5-2x the time.) I'll grant you the space and energy inefficiency of private cars, but the time factor seems wildly in favor of point-to-point random route transport.
- MegaButts 7y agoThe problem is Americans are normalized to terrible public transit. I was amazed how wonderful it was to get around using public transit the last time I was in Europe. It was so much better than the car I had rented for short-medium distance trips. I hear it's even better in Japan and other parts of Asia. The idea of having a dedicated lane with incredibly reliable timing is obviously better than the uncertainty of traffic.
- luckydata 7y agoEven if self driving vehicles are a reality in the next 20 years there's two inescapable realities we need to contend with: mass transportation will always be more ecologically sustainable than a fleet of self driving cars clogging the streets, and that most people don't want to be driving for an hour to go anywhere, even if a computer does the driving. Density will always be a good thing.
- radus 7y agoYou're probably not aware of the fact that San Diego is in the process of building a tram system that is very promising. If you drive along the route like I do, you can see progress every day - it's a huge project and I'm extremely happy to hear that they're pairing it with legislation that will increase it's positive benefits. I'll take a tram project that is being implemented ahead of schedule over the promise of automated cars which are always seemingly around the corner.
- rayiner 7y agoThis is the exact same mindset that resulted in our cities and suburbs in the 1960s. Except back then the disruptive new technology was widespread motor vehicle ownership.