5 ms·
From a profitability standpoint, I am just not seeing how Amazon retail has any chance at the long term success that the market does. Even as they have taken ov
by scarface74 7y ago
From a profitability standpoint, I am just not seeing how Amazon retail has any chance at the long term success that the market does. Even as they have taken over different verticals, they still had to keep prices down and margins slim. They have no pricing power and have huge fixed cost.
Of course, AWS is a different story.
- falcor84 7y ago>...huge fixed cost What fixed costs are you referring to? It seems to me that almost their entire cost structure is variable and quite low, compared to competitors.
- scarface74 7y agoRetail - warehouses and warehouse workers and automation.
- mensetmanusman 7y agoThose costs are lowering with automation, green energy/power, and autonomous transportation.
- scarface74 7y agoAutonomous transportation - the same story that Uber and Lyft are saying as the savior for their businesses that will help them finally turn a profit.
- hef19898 7y agoCompared to brick and mortar retail, yes. Compared to things like Dropship or the massive use of 3rd party logistics owned warehouses are a high fix cost item.
- petra 7y agoLet's see: 1. Private labels enjoy about 10% extra margin. Amazon is currently scaling private labels and exclusive products(same thing), like mad. 2. Low margin doesn't mean a business is bad, just hard. Walmart is an amazing business, with low margins. 3. Let's say amazon creates a system that can supply everything, to your home, in a few hours, at the lowest price. And customers will really like that. How many other companies can build that ? maybe 1-2 in the US. So now you have a duopoly. 4. Amazon controls demand. In the internet age, that's the most important thing. Could they manufacture their own products ? be responsible to purchase inputs for their manufacturers ? Build something like AWS for manufacturing ? Who knows. 5. Amazon is growing rapidly in B2B. Not sure, but i believe products there have much higher margins.
- scarface74 7y agoLet's see: 1. Private labels enjoy about 10% extra margin. Amazon is currently scaling private labels and exclusive products(same thing), like mad. And any major corporation can use the same supply chain to make the same private label goods. All commodity products are a race to the bottom. 2. Low margin doesn't mean a business is bad, just hard. Walmart is an amazing business, with low margins. Not a bad business, but low margin businesses don’t command the multiple that Amazon has. 3. Let's say amazon creates a system that can supply everything, to your home, in a few hours, at the lowest price. And customers will really like that. Yes and then you increase the marginal cost for shipping.... How many other companies can build that ? maybe 1-2 in the US. So now you have a duopoly. You don’t need many companies to erase margins if they are competing on price. 4. Amazon controls demand. In the internet age, that's the most important thing. Amazon doesn’t control demand. But Amazon retail has the highest marginal costs of any of the tech companies including Apple. Netflix, Google, and Microsoft (software not hardware and cloud) have much lower marginal costs. Software has basically zero marginal costs. Could they manufacture their own products ? be responsible to purchase inputs for their manufacturers ? Build something like AWS for manufacturing ? Who knows. Apple is considered the best in supply change management in the world. They have huge bargaining power because they sell a lot of a few goods. Amazon would be selling a relative few of a lots of stuff. 5. Amazon is growing rapidly in B2B. Not sure, but i believe products there have much higher margins. Businesses have an entire procurement department to make sure they are getting the lowest prices. Those margins should be even lower.