3 ms·
The two things (brexit and sector problems) compound. Without Brexit, a sector crisis might have resulted in one company closing a UK plant and another closing
by toyg 7y ago
The two things (brexit and sector problems) compound.
Without Brexit, a sector crisis might have resulted in one company closing a UK plant and another closing a plant elsewhere, weighting specific pros and cons case-by-case.
With Brexit, they both close a UK plant, because it’s now a no-brainer. The UK after Brexit will have high labor costs AND high tariffs on goods’ movement. There is almost no reason to manufacture here.
Brexit is a massive hole in the UK appeal for manufacturing that targets the EU market. This is a hard fact. Everything else is wishful thinking.
- krona 7y agoGiven the exchange rate over the past 25 years, it's quite remarkable that the UK has any manufacturing base whatsoever.
- toyg 7y agoIndeed, it almost doesn’t. Before Brexit, the sector was constantly crying for help; the car industry itself almost disappeared in the ‘80s, before the government explicitly targeted it. When Jeremy Corbyn was elected leader of the opposition Labour party, pre-Brexit referendum, one of his main rallying cries was about rebuilding a real manufacturing sector; there is almost no word of that anymore, unsurprisingly - now it’s all about maintaining current levels of economic activity, which we’ll be lucky to do.
- pjc50 7y agoThe UK's remaining manufacturing is high value-add, and much of it is also on a smaller scale than mass car production. The UK satellite industry does very well, for example. We need to appreciate what our real strengths and weaknesses are, and huge armies of semi-skilled workers assembling things are not going to be one of them.
- benj111 7y ago"The UK after Brexit will have high labor costs" If/when the £ goes down the toilet (even more) labour will be cheap.
- toyg 7y agoLabor costs are not just wages. It would take a social carnage to lower them to levels competitive with Asia.
- benj111 7y agoNo but the UK does have certain other advantages over low cost producers, that's why it still manages to manufacture stuff. Its the costs relative to the EU and US etc that matter
- toyg 7y agoTo measure those advantages, one only has to look at the UK post-WWII/pre-common-market. Hint: it doesn't look good.
- benj111 7y agoI don't think its quite the same. We have moved up the value chain since then. I'm not saying Brexit will be pretty, but I think we'll be running back to the EU well before we end up competing with China on price.
- repolfx 7y agoThe UK manufactures more stuff than ever before in its history. Do you realise that? The "decline" of British manufacturing is only a relative decline - other parts of the world grew their manufacturing base faster.
- rezeroed 7y agoThis is bigger than the UK.