3 ms·
>> It wasn't a big commercial system; it was a big government system (you probably can't imagine the degree of shock and awe that greeted MITI people or even th
by YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago
>> It wasn't a big commercial system; it was a big government system (you probably can't imagine the degree of shock and awe that greeted MITI people or even the mention of the minstry in the US).
Sloppy turn of phrase on my part.
I do understand the reaction of the US, and not only. I did my CS degree in 2007 and I made heavy use of my university's library that had a solid selection of Prolog textbooks, which I devoured. At some point I noticed that a few of those textbooks (the more industry-oriented) had prefaces that stated Prolog was a very important language to know because it was poised for world domination thanks to the FGCP. Curious, I dug a bit further and found that book- the one from that American journalist woman and the man from the semiconductors business. If memory serves, it portended doom unless the US spent a few billions overtaking the Japanese. Later, I found out what happened after- but I got a pretty good idea of how people in industry in the US saw the whole thing, and it has helped me understand why logic programming was relegated to a mere niche in CS following the abandonment of the FGCP.
The similarities with the present hype cycle are not lost on me, either. However, this is what happens when industry takes over science. We lose the science. There is nothing here to celebrate, or laugh at. Like I say above, missing an opportunity to discover new knowledge because some idiots want to make a quick buck is a tragedy.
- kragen 7y agoI wonder if the hangover from this is behind Will Byrd’s difficulties in getting tenure despite his truly groundbreaking work with miniKANREN. Maybe people just identify KANREN with Prolog and dismiss it? (I know it's bad form to complain about downvotes, but this one is really puzzling me. Does someone think Will Byrd doesn't deserve tenure? How could anyone think that?)
- nitrogen 7y agoIs there a good summary somewhere of what miniKANREN is and of the difficulties finding academic support for those of us who work in industry and don't know as much about the tenure system? (FWIW I tried to help correct the downvotes. I personally believe very very few comments should be in the gray.)
- kragen 7y agoAs for what miniKanren is, there are a couple of books (one being Byrd's dissertation) and a lot of papers. I think maybe the best summary I've read is actually the interview transcript at https://www.infoq.com/interviews/byrd-relational-programming-minikanren/ https://www.infoq.com/interviews/byrd-relational-programming.... But also, there's a summary on http://minikanren.org/ http://minikanren.org/, with links to the papers and talks, and an older summary on https://kanren.sf.net/ https://kanren.sf.net/. Most of these are a bit hard to understand the significance of if you aren't already familiar with logic programming. The talk on https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OyfBQmvr2Hc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OyfBQmvr2Hc is a popular description of one of the most astonishing results; I haven't watched it but people tell me it's good. As for understanding academia, yeah, I don't know.
- gumby 7y agoMost such questions come down to the fact that Academic politics is inscrutable.