3 ms·
> Or the user can just tell it to update later on when they aren’t using it. This is how devices stay vulnerable. > With the benefit that all necessary compon
by lern_too_spel 7y ago
> Or the user can just tell it to update later on when they aren’t using it.
This is how devices stay vulnerable.
> With the benefit that all necessary components are updated together
The whole app is already updated atomically. There is no benefit here.
> and that Apple can push out any updates world wide without waiting on the carriers
The same as a Pixel or Android One device. The only difference is that app security updates are artificially slower on iOS due to poor design, and for apps like browsers, this is a fatal flaw.
- scarface74 7y agoThis is how devices stay vulnerable. As opposed to most Android phones that never get system updates? As opposed to Apple releasing an update two weeks ago for all iOS devices back to 2011? The whole app is already updated atomically. There is no benefit here. The Safari app is also used as an out of process web view for other apps as is the messenger app... The same as a Pixel or Android One device. The only difference is that app security updates are artificially slower on iOS due to poor design, and for apps like browsers, this is a fatal flaw. It’s estimated that Google may sell 1-2 million phones a year and Android One phones are not much more ubiquitous. Even then Google only promises updates for two years.
- lern_too_spel 7y ago> As opposed to most Android phones that never get system updates? Don't buy them. Problem solved. Do you avoid Linux entirely because there exist Linux-based routers that are never updated? No, you buy Linux-based routers that are updated. In this case, the choice is between properly updated Android phones, poorly updated userspace iOS phones, and poorly updated base system Android phones. The obvious choice is a phone from the first group. > The Safari app is also used as an out of process web view for other apps as is the messenger app... As is Chrome on Android. Since Android is designed in a way that apps can gracefully recover from arbitrary processes being killed, this does not matter. Chrome gets updated, the process restarts, and the page the user was viewing in the web view reappears. If the app wasn't in the foreground, the user won't even notice.
- scarface74 7y agoSo their are approximately 2.5 billion Android devices in the world and less than 2% are sold by Google and they are the only ones getting updated and you don’t think that’s a problem? But yet every single Windows PC sold by any vendor can still get updates directly from Microsoft. In this case, the choice is between properly updated Android phones, poorly updated userspace iOS phones, and poorly updated base system Android phones. The obvious choice is a phone from the first group. You are really claiming that Android has a better update strategy than iOS and is more secure? Which Android phones from 2011 are still getting updates? 2013? 2015? Heck 2017?
- lern_too_spel 7y ago> you don’t think that’s a problem? It's a problem, just like the routers that aren't getting updated. It's not my problem. > You are really claiming that Android has a better update strategy than iOS and is more secure? Yes. I've already explained why, and you haven't refuted it. > Which Android phones from 2011 are still getting updates? I don't use eight year old phones, so this doesn't matter to me. If you use old phones, you could argue that iOS is marginally more secure than the Android options; but that argument is irrelevant to the purchase decisions of 99% of the people here who do upgrade devices regularly for whom there are Android options that are much more secure than iOS phones.
- scarface74 7y agoIf you use old phones, you could argue that iOS is marginally more secure than the Android options; but that argument is irrelevant to the purchase decisions of 99% of the people here who do upgrade devices regularly for whom there are Android options that are much more secure than iOS phones. The average replacement time for cell phones in the US is 32 months. https://www.npd.com/wps/portal/npd/us/news/press-releases/2018/the-average-upgrade-cycle-of-a-smartphone-in-the-u-s--is-32-months---according-to-npd-connected-intelligence/ https://www.npd.com/wps/portal/npd/us/news/press-releases/20... 8 months longer than Google has promised updates. https://www.digitaltrends.com/mobile/what-is-android-one/ https://www.digitaltrends.com/mobile/what-is-android-one/ And that’s only with Android One phones. Most Android phones never get updates or are rolled out slowly waiting on the OEM and carrier.