4 ms·
> So I really don't understand where all the schadenfreude comes from, in the article. A big commercial project failed and took with it a whole branch of comput
by gumby 7y ago
> So I really don't understand where all the schadenfreude comes from, in the article. A big commercial project failed and took with it a whole branch of computer science. Who, exactly, benefited from this?
It wasn't a big commercial system; it was a big government system (you probably can't imagine the degree of shock and awe that greeted MITI people or even the mention of the minstry in the US). This was when Japan was going to destroy America and goodamnit, Something Must Be Done.
Of course as happens with such projects it all comes tumbling down, but usually with a whimper. Apollo is another good example: they hit their goal and then what? 5Gen was the more common case: just wasted away.
The schadenfreude comes not just from the central planning hubris but from the American freak-out response to what was really hype and a squib. The author says the same thing is happening today, with the hype-o-meter on 11, again in the AI field, and again with an "asian menace" on the horizon, this time China.
5Gen just rode a hype machine though; it didn't take the field out -- we could all see that coming anyway.
- foobiekr 7y agoI think people today have a very hard time understanding what things were like during the Japan bubble from about 1987 to 1990. Coming out of the 1970s Japan ended up dominating certain parts of the electronics - and especially personal electronics, like radios or portable cassette players. They had terribly failed in _information technology_ however, but most people didn't know that, what they saw was walkmen, MITI coordinating wiping out American DRAM and television producers using dumping (among other things) and so on. Another important event was that the US dollar was very high in the mid-1980s (Reagan deliberately de-valuing the dollar was frequent discussion on the morning news). A side effect of this was the transfer of investment to other shores, and Japan being the primary beneficiary. BOJ dropped interest rates a great deal and a speculative asset and property bubble was launched. This culminated in the purchase of many, many high-profile assets in the United States by the Japanese keiretsu and banks. The Japanese were in a mania, and a lot of investors world-wide were as well, and the Americans, in particular, were experiencing a kind of crisis of faith in US-style capitalism. Like most bubbles (try explaining the dotcom), it is very hard to make someone understand what happened. You can recount the facts but not the emotional context.
- selimthegrim 7y agoJames Burke had a climate special (After the Warming) in about 1989-90 where his ideal future was the Japanese running things in a world government. Seems to have captured the zeitgeist and the present (creepy to hear the bit in the beginning though about "full-scale evacuation of New Orleans"). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RfE8wBReIxw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RfE8wBReIxw
- foobiekr 7y agoWow. This is crazy.
- selimthegrim 7y agoHis optimism is touching. The bit about carbon trading struck me. Lately I've been questioning the dogma of one man, one vote. What if the only way to democratically resolve climate change is to inversely weight your vote by the amount of carbon you emit?
- jacobush 7y agoIn about a second flat the rich will find a way to make the poor take on a lot of CO2 responsibility.
- akhilcacharya 7y agoI’m amazed that I’ve never seen this. I think this deserves an HN post of its own. Absolutely fascinating to see so much basically correct (climate refugee crisis, massive efficiency gains, enacted carbon tax, free falling PV prices, my efficient smart home setup) with so much off target (widespread telecommuting! 9 billion population! A world Japanese world government!) That seems preposterous now.
- scottlocklin 7y agoI dunno, didn't look like it got anything right to me. 6 degrees of warming and two feet of ocean, though we're only a billion and change away from 9 billion. Since when do we have a climate refugee crisis? People go to the tropics on vacation; it's fine there.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago>> It wasn't a big commercial system; it was a big government system (you probably can't imagine the degree of shock and awe that greeted MITI people or even the mention of the minstry in the US). Sloppy turn of phrase on my part. I do understand the reaction of the US, and not only. I did my CS degree in 2007 and I made heavy use of my university's library that had a solid selection of Prolog textbooks, which I devoured. At some point I noticed that a few of those textbooks (the more industry-oriented) had prefaces that stated Prolog was a very important language to know because it was poised for world domination thanks to the FGCP. Curious, I dug a bit further and found that book- the one from that American journalist woman and the man from the semiconductors business. If memory serves, it portended doom unless the US spent a few billions overtaking the Japanese. Later, I found out what happened after- but I got a pretty good idea of how people in industry in the US saw the whole thing, and it has helped me understand why logic programming was relegated to a mere niche in CS following the abandonment of the FGCP. The similarities with the present hype cycle are not lost on me, either. However, this is what happens when industry takes over science. We lose the science. There is nothing here to celebrate, or laugh at. Like I say above, missing an opportunity to discover new knowledge because some idiots want to make a quick buck is a tragedy.
- kragen 7y agoI wonder if the hangover from this is behind Will Byrd’s difficulties in getting tenure despite his truly groundbreaking work with miniKANREN. Maybe people just identify KANREN with Prolog and dismiss it? (I know it's bad form to complain about downvotes, but this one is really puzzling me. Does someone think Will Byrd doesn't deserve tenure? How could anyone think that?)
- nitrogen 7y agoIs there a good summary somewhere of what miniKANREN is and of the difficulties finding academic support for those of us who work in industry and don't know as much about the tenure system? (FWIW I tried to help correct the downvotes. I personally believe very very few comments should be in the gray.)