8 ms·
I've lived on an American military base with a crime rate so low that the military police spent months determined to track down some guy who robbed the liquor s
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
I've lived on an American military base with a crime rate so low that the military police spent months determined to track down some guy who robbed the liquor store because it was the most exciting thing that had happened in ages.
There can be a real downside to police officers overzealously looking for someone to bust just to have something to do.
- jjeaff 7y agoYou'd think they could come up with something constructive. Have the officers do community service among the residents while on the clock and in uniform. You'll have even less crime that way.
- steve19 7y agoWhat makes you think there would be less crime when the crime rate is already very low? Spending less money on police and more on things such as social welfare will probably do more for crime than getting them to plant trees or whatever.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoOn a military base, it's not so bad. They genuinely need to police drunk driving because you have a lot of young people with decent incomes on their own for the first time. Most American military bases are pretty aggressive about policing traffic issues, and it's apparently all to the good. They do things like place some crumpled car as a billboard somewhere prominent to remind you daily what your car might look like if you drive drunk, then post a count that gets updated daily "Days since last deadly accident" or something like that. And on the base in question, we had on base housing. One of the duties of the police was to let you in your house if you locked yourself out accidentally. (I did once.) But this article starts with a stake out actively trying to tempt someone to steal something. It's essentially entrapment, or not far from it.
- tjohns 7y agoThat's not entrapment. At least in the US, entrapment has to pass two tests: 1. Was it a crime the suspect was unlikely or unwilling to commit otherwise? (The "subjective" test.) 2. Did the actions of officers cause a normally law-abiding person to commit a crime? (The "objective" test.) In other words, entrapment is when the police actively cause somebody to commit a crime they wouldn't have otherwise committed in similar circumstances. In the article, the police just left a case of beer inside a car. The police created a passive opportunity, but that's not enough for entrapment... the act of steeling that beer was entirely self meditated.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoIt's essentially entrapment, or not far from it. That sentence has two qualifiers. I still have two people telling me I'm wrong. In my youth, I would have agreed that a thing should just not be touched if it's not yours because maybe they will come back for it. Someday. I'm still inclined to generally err in that direction, but I'm less judgy than I used to be of people who would be inclined to feel that a perishable -- like beer -- left out in the open for days on end must be basically abandoned and up for grabs because people don't typically buy consumables like that and leave them sitting out for days on end. It's not normal behavior. It was intended to be temptation. Whether it meets the legal definition of entrapment or not, it makes for a town I don't really want to visit. There's no telling how far down this slippery slope they will go to keep themselves entertained and prove their paychecks aren't simply a waste of money. I raised two kids. I've thought quite a lot about such things. I think setting up a "test" of that sort to see who will fall for it isn't nice behavior and shouldn't be done, especially not if your real motive is merely because you are bored.
- DangitBobby 7y agoI don't understand how you think this way about ownership. If it's not yours and you don't enter into a transaction (the transaction can be implied in the case of give-aways) wherein the previous owner grants you ownership, then it stays not yours. Things in a car are pretty unambiguously not up-for-grabs to anyone who doesn't own the car.
- okmokmz 7y agoThat would be nice. Unfortunately having less crime is not a goal of many police departments, DAs, prosecutors, prison guards and employees, bail bondsman, and basically the entire American criminal "justice" system. The more people they have to harass, the more money they can generate for themselves and all the sketchy for profit companies involved
- closeparen 7y agoGenerating revenue through fees and fines is excellent politics: you satisfy the voters' demands for both low taxes and robust services at the same time. The people who end up paying aren't happy, but they're not going to vote.
- vharuck 7y agoThe most common example I see of missed opportunities to improve safety over increase revenue is with traffic cops. They often hide, wait for a person to speed by, then pull out and give them a ticket. 10 minutes at least from the time they're pulled over, and who knows how long lying in wait. And it gets one car to drive safely for a day to a month after the incident. Compare that to a situation I just saw on a major highway. One state trooper driving exactly the speed limit in the passing lane. For at least 20 miles, he kept a dozen cars at a safe speed. Not to mention preventing any other unsafe driving. Sure, it only lasted 20 minutes from my point of view, but if he just drove around for a few hours in plain sight, that's a lot of cars driving safely. Sadly, it doesn't generate revenue.
- logfromblammo 7y agoWhile there is significant overlap between driving lawfully and driving safely, they are not identical, so please do not use them interchangeably. When a cop is doing that pace car thing, the safest thing to do is just get off that road, at least for a few minutes, because all of those drivers will be paying more attention to their legality than to their safety. For 20 miles, that example cop kept a dozen cars bunched up together, afraid to pass. It is likely that a pace car cop will pull someone over eventually anyway, so don't even spin that wheel of chance. There are different theories of what "safe driving" is, and the one you subscribe to will affect your opinion of pace car policing.
- b_tterc_p 7y agoDid they get him
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI don't recall/don't know. We had a 7.1 earthquake at some point as our latest Exciting Thing, and I think focus probably changed after that. But for ten months, you would have thought they were looking for a mass murderer by the way they were blanketing the area with fliers looking for any leads in the case.
- hodgesrm 7y agoSame here. Bored cops are an occupational hazard of living on a military base. (Unless there's a war, of course.)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- closeparen 7y agoSuburban cop favorites: - Dogs in parks - Dogs off leash in dogs-allowed parks - Dog poop infractions - People in parks after dark - Teenage parties - Curfew enforcement - Horribly bungling the case when something real and tragic does happen
- RomanBob 7y agoShooting and killing a guy with a TV remote in hand because it looked like a gun and he 'felt threatened'.
- coldtea 7y ago>Curfew enforcement Suburban cops in Nazi Germany, Pinochet's Chile, or some such place?
- Broken_Hippo 7y agoWhen I was young - before 18 - kids wound up in juvenile all the time for being out after curfew, which was 11 during the week and 12 or 1am on weekends. you were supposed to be allowed out to work a job, but folks got harassed nonetheless. There was no other crime other than being young and out past a certain time. Now in Indiana, supposedly one is supposed to be allowed out with parental permission, but I don't know if it is like this in the rest of the country or if places have re-written their juvenile curfew laws to account for this sort of thing. In addition, folks on house arrest or parole often have curfews as well.
- andrewflnr 7y agoI'm ok with the dog poop one. Cleaning up after your dog is easy, and if you're so lazy that you can't do it you deserve to have someone in authority ruining your week.
- mensetmanusman 7y agoTrue, especially when children are involved. I do not know what to do when I find stuff in my yard that I know the toddlers/kids will play with if they find it. Thankfully the fly exist.
- HyperTalk2 7y agoThe Japanese have a unique peaceful disposition and will not descend into a savage testosterone-fueled power trip out of sheer boredom, and it's borderline racist to baselessly assert that they will.
- lawn 7y agoIt's quite dishonest of you to suggest they have a unique peaceful disposition after the crimes they committed during the second world war.
- hfhdie74i3i 7y agoThere is a conflation of a number of things here: 1) The OP to which you responded is confusing peacefulness with being civilised. Japanese are not particularly peaceful, but they are highly civilized. Much more so than western countries (in particular the USA seems to have rather low standards in terms of politeness and civilization), because the Japanese culture places much more value on such things than the various western countries. 2) You are conflating the disposition of the foreign policy of a country with the cultural accepted practices by the population of that country.
- zaphirplane 7y agoWas it the teenage kid of the colonel ?