4 ms·
Recently in Ontario the Amber Alert system for forcibly alerting phones got booted up. It got me thinking about the use of technology for non-optional alerts.
by Waterluvian 7y ago
Recently in Ontario the Amber Alert system for forcibly alerting phones got booted up. It got me thinking about the use of technology for non-optional alerts.
What if phones were loaded with some basic geometry layers, so when your phone's GPS detects you're outside the polygon, it forcibly alerts you: YOU ARE OUTSIDE THE RANGE FOR EMERGENCY SERVICES. 911 AND EMERGENCY RESCUE NOT GUARANTEED."
I got thinking about this also because of how emergency services are often perceived as being some universal guarantee, taken for granted in the modern world. I wonder if people don't really grok that they're completely outside of the safety net they grew up in.
- prettySqueamish 7y agoHonestly, I’d avoid any kind of device that behaves this way. Not because I’d be suspicious about the invasive qualities of such technology, but more because I don’t like devices that try to do more for me than I might ask of them. I really hate devices that try to direct my decision making, when I never asked for an outside opinion about something. It feels like I’m being preached to. It’s less about detesting my own personal safety, and more because that’s not what I bought the phone for, and it isn’t what I’m paying for it to do. Just like “presidential alerts” and “AMBER alerts” that I never asked for. Sorry phone, but the truth is that even if I can’t disable a presidential alert, I can still refuse to pay it any mind, so maybe think twice about any attempt at forcing me to pay attention to something. At some point, I’ll just not even carry a phone. The phone is there for me to contact people at the time of my choosing. The phone is there for people whom I have invited to contact me. It does not exist for any other reason. No matter how much people want them to be pocket computers, no matter how many lives they want to save, no matter the bells and whistles pushed into service, the fact is that if I refuse to use the device in that moment of truth, the extra little specialization went nowhere. In all other cases, the people who might need such a thing the most are often the dumbest and most imperiled by their own stupidity. People who run out of gas, can’t change a tire, bounce checks, download and execute email attachments, click random links, forward chain letters, have hundreds of icons and all their important files right on the desktop, use 1234 as their password... you’ll try to put rubber baby buggy bumpers on every single last rough edge and hard corner, and they’ll still find a way to fuck it all up. Sometimes the problem is growing up in a safety net. Sometimes the problem is a sheltered life. Personally, I’d absolutely revile the concept of a nanny device. I bet you could implement a phone so that it knows when it can’t call for emergency help, even in a private, offline manner, by considering factors like dead reckoning, inertial navigation, and low energy anonymous peering that approximates true availability of basic essentials like land lines and whether a municipality is walkable, drivable and whether or not you own a car or could maybe flag down a good samaritan. But should you?
- OnlineCourage 7y agoI like how your proposed alert notification is in capitalized letters and post hoc. "DUE TO RECENT LEGISLATION RESTRICTIONS ON CELL TOWER PERMITS IN WILDLIFE AREAS, AT&T HAS DETECTED THAT YOU ARE NO LONGER WITHIN OUR PLATINUM CELL TOWER COVERAGE AREA. YOU ARE NOW IN THE IMPENDING DEATH NO EMERGENCY SERVICE ZONE, GOODBYE."
- Waterluvian 7y agoThat's how our amber alerts are presented. Alongside a forced max volume klaxxon. It's quite the spectacle when a whole room of people's phones go off at the same time.