10 ms·
Amazon, Walmart, Ikea targeted in University of California light bulb lawsuits
- digikata 7y ago"According to the university’s lawyers at Nixon Peabody, the litigation is the first-of-its-kind 'direct patent enforcement' campaign against an entire industry." Didn't the CSIRO from Australia do something similar with respect to their wifi patents?
- el_don_almighty 7y agogood, somebody should sue these people for making bulbs that give people headaches!!!
- earthcreed 7y agoYou can also read the actual press release from UCSB, instead of reuters' regurgitation of it. https://filamentpatent.ucsb.edu/ https://filamentpatent.ucsb.edu/
- sfifs 7y agoWhy would a PR release be any more reliable than a news article? At least mainstream news articles try to maintain the appearance of being unbiased :-)
- earthcreed 7y agoThe news story is just the PR release restated. There is no reporting going on. They even repeated the arguably false statement that this is "the first of its kind", leaving off the one part of the statement that might make it true "by a university". That was the point of my comment, and I included the link so you could look at both.
- dheera 7y ago"the litigation is the first-of-its-kind \"direct patent enforcement\" campaign against an entire industry" Not the first time. Forgent sued a bunch of companies over the use of JPEG [0]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JPEG https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JPEG
- ineedasername 7y agoAnd they're not really suing the appropriate industry. Retailers are not infringing the patent. This seems troll-ish. When Apple sued Samsung, they sued Samsung. They didn't sue Verizon, AT&T, etc., that were selling the products.
- throwaway3627 7y agoIt's a different situation. Samsung is a big company, whereas the lightbulb vendors are fly-by-night resellers/contract manufacturers that don't care about patents. The patent holder goes after the biggest fish because Target is less likely to disappear than JKLM Filament Light Bulb Importing Ltd.
- ineedasername 7y agoIt seems the statute disagrees with me, but it seems wrong to sue the retailer. Sort of like safe-harbor provisions for copyright violations. I don't think it's practical to expect retailers to vet the functionality of an item against active patents and then audit the wholesaler's patent license portfolio for compliance. More practical would be a takedown system where the patent holder could notify the retailer of infringement, and the wholesaler would have the opportunity to respond, again like how things are handled with copyright. (Not that the process there is without flaws)
- egdod 7y ago> Retailers are not infringing the patent We normally think about manufacturers being the main infringement target, but the statute also refers to anyone who “makes, uses, offers to sell, or sells” (among other things).
- dahdum 7y agoI'd love to see a patent lawyers view of this case. On the face it looks insane to expect retailers to individually weigh patent claims and somehow force suppliers into licensing agreements with third parties.
- michaelt 7y agoIn a traditional business, if a retailer imports an item for sale, who else would be responsible for making sure it complied with US law?
- IG_Semmelweiss 7y agoAs another ooster has said. The law is pretty clear. Anyone selling is responsible. What matters is the supplier agreement between retailers and suppliers. As another poster has said, that should heavily favor the retailers. Very interesting case because the fly by night operators that are amazon suppliers will be forced out, leaving a few that will de facto have to comply with US IP laws, even though de jure, they would be inmune
- earthcreed 7y agoYou don't need a patent lawyer, just read 35 U.S. Code § 271. " . . . whoever without authority makes, uses, offers to sell, or sells any patented invention, within the United States or imports into the United States any patented invention during the term of the the patent therefor, infringes the patents. Amazon, Walmart, etc. aren't likely the ultimate targets of the suit. The suits are designed to bring in the producers under the indemnity portion of their contract with the retailer. Its a jurisdictional hook and way to effectively multiply the amount of pressure on the actual infringer, by threatening to cut off their access to the retailer (which could be accomplished in the ITC) and leverage possible contractual damages they face from the retailer. The ultimate goal is to pressure Everlight, Eaton, and whoever else is making the light bulbs to pay for a license, and using Amazon and Walmart to force them to do so.
- Shivetya 7y ago
- nkurz 7y agoThe linked article omits one of the more interesting details, which is that the suit is being funded by a Longford Capital, a private investment company that specializes in funding commercial lawsuits. Usually, third parties are silent about their participation in such suits, but in this case Longford has publicly announced their backing: https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20190730005899/en/Longford-Capital-Funds-Patent-Enforcement-Campaign-University https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20190730005899/en/Lon... Separately, if you haven't tried filament LED bulbs, you should. They are a wonderfully simple design: stack lots of small LED's in string so that they can be run at full wall voltage. The lack of a voltage converter means that there are fewer parts to fail, and the long string of LED's makes heat dissipation a lot easier. I find them better than all the alternatives.
- sevencolors 7y agoYeah, the bulbs are pretty awesome. My partner was complaining last year about how the LED bulbs are ugly to look at and really wanted an Edison like bulb but with LEDs. A quick google later and I was shocked to find that idea already existed.
- staticautomatic 7y agoLitigation finance is de rigueur these days. It's unusual that they've affirmatively stated they're funding it, but it's not unusual for there to be a funder and it's becoming more common for details to emerge in discovery about who the funder is and what the details of the funding arrangement are. It's possible that Longford issued a press release because they know or suspect it'll come out in discovery and want to get out ahead of the issue. https://abovethelaw.com/2019/07/3-thoughts-on-the-future-of-litigation-finance-part-i/ https://abovethelaw.com/2019/07/3-thoughts-on-the-future-of-...
- sitharus 7y agoThe only downside to the filament LED bulbs is the flicker. Much like old fluorescent tubes they flicker at twice the supply frequency due to the very small driver circuitry. That said I just saw a Big Clive video with a much better driver embedded in the bulb, so tech is getting there.
- elliekelly 7y agoHow long until Bezos wakes up and starts doing something to curate/monitor third-party retail products even a little? I know most of their customers don't care about patent infringement but this case is just a byproduct of Amazon's unwillingness to address the problem third-party sellers have become.
- IG_Semmelweiss 7y agoRight now the killer online is: "Buy from us, we dont sell cheap knockoffs" However no one can bring amazon to task, since all the other ones (walmart target etc) are also moving in the same direction...hopelessly trying to catch up with amazon
- gumby 7y agoI'm pretty sure UCB isn't producing and selling light bulbs, so as a classic NPE (non practicing entity) they are in the eyes of the law nothing but a patent troll. Not that that may help much.
- bdowling 7y ago> they are in the eyes of the law nothing but a patent troll. Patent troll is merely a term used by critics of the patent system for inventors or patent owners whose actions they disagree with. It is not term that is used anywhere in the law itself.
- delfinom 7y agoYes but the ability for a university to patent a technology is to fund future research off royalties. NPEs aren't automatically trolls but rather trolls are NPEs.
- autokad 7y agoI have concerns of universities and patents. I am leaning towards 'if you want to hold patents and be a non-profit, then all patents must be free use'. I could be convinced otherwise
- tomnipotent 7y ago> I could be convinced otherwise Besides the fact that innovation needs to be funded? These things don't happen in a bubble, and financial reward has historically proven to be the greatest driver of innovation.
- userbinator 7y agoI feel like filament LED bulbs were invented in China, or at least that's where I saw them (and LED lighting in general) used far more widely first. Relatedly, the bigclivedotcom YouTube channel has a huge collection of detailed analysis of various types of LED lighting.
- throwaway3627 7y agoWhat you feel doesn't matter to what is. Many were developed and made in China, but that doesn't mean they have the IP rights secured to sell in any or all markets where other patent holders registered the idea first.
- Thorrez 7y agoIf they were made in China before the patent was filed, I think that would be prior art, meaning the patent is invalid.
- inlined 7y agoUntil the US switched to a “first to file” country like China.
- Thorrez 7y agoAre you referring to the Leahy–Smith America Invents Act of 2011? It sounds like that still says prior art stops the ability to file. > Actions and prior art that bar patentability under the Act include public use, sales, publications, and other disclosures available to the public anywhere in the world as of the filing date, other than publications by the inventor within one year of filing (inventor's "publication-conditioned grace period"), whether or not a third party also files a patent application. The law also notably expanded prior art to include foreign offers for sale and public uses. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leahy-Smith_America_Invents_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leahy-Smith_America_Invents_Ac...
- cma 7y ago
- 01100011 7y agoThis sounds like a garbage patent. People have been stacking LEDs in series since they were invented. They put them on a single, transparent substrate. Big deal, seems obvious to me. Is there something special they developed, like a nifty manufacturing technique or previously unused materials?
- egdod 7y agoHow do you know it sounds like garbage if you haven’t even looked at it?
- yeutterg 7y agoRelated: Signify (formerly Philips Lighting) recently lost a judgment by the U.S. International Trade Commission on their patent licensing program [0]. Lighting companies that have fought patent infringement claims against Philips/Signify and similar entities have often won but at a high cost [1]. Many others are intimidated into licensing, or they go out of business. My understanding is that lot of it boils down to the patents being relatively vague or overly broad coupled with overly aggressive enforcement. [0] (NOTE: PDF) Signify Loses at the U.S. International Trade Commission in Setback to its LED Patent Enforcement Campaign https://edisonreport.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/07/ITCSigni444.pdf https://edisonreport.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/07/ITCSigni... [1] Great analysis of the toll Philips' licensing program has on the industry by WAC Lighting, which has fought infringement claims: W.A.C. Issues Strong Response to Philips ITC Complaint https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/wac-issues-strong-response-philips-itc-complaint-randy-reid https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/wac-issues-strong-response-ph...
- bertm 7y agoFound the complaint in PACER if anyone is interested in reading. https://www.scribd.com/document/420311557/Complaint-19-06570 https://www.scribd.com/document/420311557/Complaint-19-06570
- mjn 7y agoThese are the four patents being asserted, fwiw: 7,781,789, Transparent mirrorless light emitting diode: https://patents.google.com/patent/US7781789B2/en https://patents.google.com/patent/US7781789B2/en 9,240,529, Textured phosphor conversion layer light emitting diode: https://patents.google.com/patent/US9240529B2/en https://patents.google.com/patent/US9240529B2/en 9,859,464, Lighting emitting diode with light extracted from front and back sides of a lead frame: https://patents.google.com/patent/US9859464B2/en https://patents.google.com/patent/US9859464B2/en 10,217,916, Transparent light emitting diodes: https://patents.google.com/patent/US10217916B2/en https://patents.google.com/patent/US10217916B2/en Patent numbers found in the PDF of one of the complaints (the one against Walmart) linked elsewhere in this discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20571853 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20571853
- makomk 7y agoThose patents tell an interesting tale, and one not terribly flattering to the University of California. It looks like back in 2006 they invented and patented a variant of the old-fashioned clear domed LED which uses total internal reflection to redirect the light emitted from the rear of the LED out the front, rather than the reflective metal anvil they usually use. This is obviously not a filament LED. The only thing it has in common is that some filament LEDs put the dies on a transparent substrate, though for the purpose of emitting light out the backside of the filament rather than the front. However, they managed to get a set of claims in the '789 patent so broad that it covered all constructions that emit light out the backside of the LED. (The other three patents were filed after filament LEDs became widespread, claiming priority to earlier patents.)
- baybal2 7y agoI can't put something more concrete, but I do remember strong prior art case going back a decade. > 7,781,789 They claim inventing... a lens? A lens with transparent conductors is still a lens > 9,240,529 A claim of "shaped" optical element being used with a phosphor. Again, borderline cretinical wording > 9,859,464 Somewhat inventive per se, but wording basically wants to cover all cases of getting light from all sides of an LED, and not a particular implementation. "We claim a way to get light from all 6 sides of an LED, but we will not say what it is" > 10,217,916 ... basically a claim on inventing a sapphire LED, which they had nothing to do with. Again, a bare claim Pains to see those guys got Shuji Nakamura on board just to pump troll patents.
- anilakar 7y agoWhat's the patent being infringed? Surely "low-voltage components in series with their combined maximum rating above the mains voltage" by itself can't be patent-worthy, so there should be something more specific being infringed.
- michaelt 7y agohttps://patents.google.com/patent/US7781789/ https://patents.google.com/patent/US7781789/ "a light emitting diode (LED) that emits light out of the LED from multiple sides of the LED, wherein all layers of the LED are transparent for an emission wavelength except for an emitting layer." https://patents.google.com/patent/US9240529/ https://patents.google.com/patent/US9240529/ "an LED chip emitting light at a first wavelength, wherein the emitted light is extracted from both front and back sides of the LED chip; a lead frame to which the LED chip is attached, wherein the LED chip resides on or above a transparent plate in the lead frame that allows the emitted light to be extracted out of the LED chip through the transparent plate in the lead frame; and a phosphor for converting the light emitted by the LED chip at the first wavelength to a second wavelength." https://patents.google.com/patent/US9859464/ https://patents.google.com/patent/US9859464/ "A light emitting device, comprising: a lead frame including a transparent plate; and an LED chip, attached to the lead frame, for emitting light; wherein the LED chip resides on or above the transparent plate and at least some of the light emitted by the LED chip is transmitted through the transparent plate; and wherein at least a portion of the light emitted by the LED chip is extracted from a front side of the lead frame and another portion of the light emitted by the LED chip is extracted from a back side of the lead frame." https://patents.google.com/patent/US10217916/ https://patents.google.com/patent/US10217916/ "A light emitting device, comprising: a lead frame having a transparent plate therein; and a light emitting diode (LED) chip, mounted on the lead frame and placed on or above the transparent plate in the lead frame, emitting light through at least front and back sides of the LED chip; wherein the transparent plate in the lead frame allows the light emitted from the LED chip to be extracted out of the LED chip from the front or back sides of the LED chip and through the transparent plate in the lead frame."