4 ms·
You're looking for another, larger dinosaur to come along and eat ebay. Instead what is likely to happen is many smaller mammals like cragslist and http://www.e
by noonespecial 18y ago
You're looking for another, larger dinosaur to come along and eat ebay. Instead what is likely to happen is many smaller mammals like cragslist and http://www.etsy.com/ http://www.etsy.com/ will come along and slowly make it irrelevant.
They are certainly speeding the process along with their mistreatment of the most important kinds of sellers and allowing the rampant spam and fraud that has nearly taken over whole sections.
When ebay began the web was a very different place. The rise of social networking and basic online shopping awareness will allow smaller niche markets like etsy to flourish. A reputation system that is portable, secure and inter-operates easily would be a big plus in this direction but I think it will happen even without it being fully developed.
I can't wait for an online market of makers that can offer unique, one-off technology products. I'd gladly trade in my Ipod for a funky handmade OS Ogg player that did more of what I want and less of what Apple wants. Reputation built by how many cool things you've made, commissioned items.. Hey there's a startup in there somewhere!
- Kaizyn 18y agoYour suggested approach is flawed simply because it would require all the little companies to cooperate together on some sort of system.
- boredguy8 18y agoYou mean like open source or the free market?
- randallsquared 18y agoNo, like some combination of an OpenID-like system and a search for auctions and similar things across many sites. Such a thing would probably have to include eBay to be very useful at first.
- m0nty 18y agoI disagree. It's not about co-operating to build a monolithic system, it's about each niche-player dominating that niche. Etsy is a good example: I've sold several items (stained glass) there, but trying to do the same on eBay was a waste of time -- and the listing fee. I still use eBay (to buy) but more diversity and competition in the marketplace would be most welcome.
- kennyroo 18y agoFull disclosure: I'm a former eBay'er who spent 5 years at the company and had a good experience working there. I don't agree that eBay is evil. It's just a big company behaving like all big companies eventually do. Still, I've given much thought to why no Western companies (Asia is a different issue) have been effective at competing with the company over the years. I think there are three issues: 1) Trust and Safety is what eBay calls the never-ending cycle of identifying fraud, modeling it, and preventing it from happening in the future. It's a difficult, expensive, ever-evolving challenge that is far more complex than I realized before working at the company. Craigslist, which has recently seen a massive flood of spam on some of the more popular categories, is seeing how difficult it can be to keep a lid on this stuff. eBay is in a never-ending battle against criminals who are often very smart and highly motivated. New entrants in P2P payment systems have to deal with this problem to even get started. People think there is a lot of fraud on eBay, but they have no clue how much of it is killed before it sees the light of day. In many ways, eBay is like an immune system that can fight off infections it has seen before. It's the new stuff that gets through the system. Competitors won't have the benefit of eBay's decade-long immunity memory. 2) eBay spends millions on search marketing to maintain their position by keeping buyers coming to the site. eBay is, by most accounts, Google's largest ad buyer. It didn't used to be this way. There was a time when most users went directly to eBay.com to start their shopping, and that's still true of auction fanatics. But a large percentage of sales on eBay are now fixed price (or buy it now), and commodity shoppers increasingly start their shopping with a Google, Yahoo, or Live search. The cost of acquiring new fixed-price customers will be a major problem for anyone hoping to enter the general goods retail category. 3) It's still the best auction platform. The bottom line here is that no one has come up with anything fundamentally better than eBay's auctions. Personally, I think this is eBay's soft spot because the company is focused on fixed price goods and because they've owned this market for so long. The margin on auctions is very, very high, and someone could take them on. A better (more fun, cheaper) product would be a good place to start. I agree with those who suggest that niche players will chip away at eBay's dominance, much like niche retailers at the mall chipped away at department stores over the years. If I was going to build an eBay competitor (and I'm not), I'd choose a single category of easily-shippable, high-resale-value items (e.g. SLR camera lenses or whatever) and create a better C2C trading system that kicks butt on that specific category.