4 ms·
I wish game consoles were open, but I don't care as much because they're single purpose. A PS4 is not designed to be your primary computer. An iPhone, by contr
by Wowfunhappy 7y ago
I wish game consoles were open, but I don't care as much because they're single purpose. A PS4 is not designed to be your primary computer.
An iPhone, by contrast, will be many people's primary or even they're only computer. What does it mean for our society if a single company has control over what that computer can display?
I see this issue as broader than just competition—I think it's analogous to free speech.
- wheelerwj 7y ago> What does it mean for our society if a single company has control over what that computer can display? this is literally every major OS right now.... Mac, iOS, Android, Chromium, Windows.... > I think it's analogous to free speech. what? no it isn't. these are proprietary, private sector companies who fiduciary responsibilities to their shareholders, not government entities.
- felipelemos 7y agoIt's a bit of stretching saying that Windows and even macOS, and I'm obviously not counting Linux in that, have the same walled garden than iPhone.
- Wowfunhappy 7y ago> this is literally every major OS right now.... Mac, iOS, Android, Chromium, Windows.... No it's not! I can run whatever software I want on Windows, Mac, Android and Chromium. > these are proprietary, private sector companies who fiduciary responsibilities to their shareholders, not government entities. I am not accusing Apple of literally breaking the first amendment. I do, however, think their actions have consequences for our society and democracy. Imagine if side-loading books onto a Kindle was impossible, and Amazon implemented an App Store-style review process for everything sold on the Kindle store. Would you consider that a threat to free speech? Well, consider what happened when someone made an iOS game about Apple factory workers in Foxconn: Apple killed it [1]. Now, it is absolutely Apple's prerogative to determine what is allowed on their storefront, just as any retailer can decide what to stock on its shelves. However, by completely blocking any form of side-loading, Apple is making decisions about what type of content their users are allowed to see on their devices. That's a problem if the iPhone is someone's primary computer, and perhaps their only computer. [1] https://kotaku.com/there-was-an-iphone-game-about-foxconn-until-apple-kill-5839820 https://kotaku.com/there-was-an-iphone-game-about-foxconn-un...
- ekc 7y ago> No it's not! I can run whatever software I want on Windows, Mac, Android and Chromium. Just as you can on Safari!
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoSure, and it's great that they provide that option, but it also severely limits the capabilities of what an app can do. I also don't think it's a coincidence that Apple has been dragging its feet on support for progressive web apps.
- chongli 7y agoJust as you can on Safari! Web applications can't do peer to peer networking, period. Nor can they interact with arbitrary hardware devices you decide to connect.
- icebraining 7y agoThe First Amendment of the US Constitution is restricted to the government. Free Speech is a wider concept than that.
- crankylinuxuser 7y agoWhy do we chain ourselves to such a limiting construct? Companies; S,C, LLC. They did not exist, and by request they were willed into 'personhood' at the signing of a government pen. They were not required to approve the incorporation request. So, I ask this: Why do we not enforce incorporated entities to also abide by the Bill of Rights as being extensions of the government? They certainly weren't born, and there's no corporate death penalty. So it tells me they're an extension of government, as they were willed into being with their explicit consent.
- solitus 7y agoI agree, these companies have a heavy influence on governments through lobbyists and campaign financing.
- rolltiide 7y ago> Why do we not enforce incorporated entities to also abide by the Bill of Rights as being extensions of the government? because they are extensions of the private citizens that own them your extension is accomplished when government entities under the US Constitution are significant funders or owners of these entities
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoI don't want private companies to be beholden to the same standard of free speech as the government! Barns & Noble should be able to decide what types of books to put on their selves. Hacker News's moderators should be able to make decisions about what types of content lead to intellectual curiosity. And while I strongly believe all software platforms should allow sideloading, I also think Apple's curated, "safe" App Store is a great (optional) service for consumers who want it.
- scarface74 7y agoSo the console isn’t a general purpose computer but the iPhone is? By whose definition?
- banachtarski 7y agoYou typical developer on iOS is targeting a broad spectrum of hardware (even within the iOS line, the software is able to run on various iphone skus dating back possibly 7-9 years). Console? When I ship a PS4 build, it is THE PS4 BUILD. It has optimizations designed to maximize the memory buses that ship with the PS4 and the PS4 only.
- scarface74 7y agoUnless you have to optimize for the PS4 and PS4 Pro. But, what does ease of development have to do with one being more of a computer than the other?
- banachtarski 7y agoI'm telling you the difference between a console (or embedded platform) versus a general computing device. There is a blurry line to be sure, but the smartphone and a gaming console are clearly on opposite sides of the line. Consoles have dedicated hardware for antialiasing, texture streaming, etc.
- scarface74 7y agoAnd iPhones have dedicated hardware for cellular, video decoding, decryption, a dedicated GPU, motion detection, face detection, etc....
- banachtarski 7y agoAre you implementing code for them? Virtually every computing device available (your desktop included) is an SoC.
- lukifer 7y agoThere is a moral/philosophical connection to free speech and the app store pseudo-monopolies (code as speech), but it also happens to be very concrete in Apple's case: you literally cannot tell customers through your app what other alternatives might be used to pay you. (And before someone comments about how this doesn't conflict with the 1st Amendment, you are obviously correct; but free speech is as much a societal value as a legal construct, and is not limited to the Bill of Rights as its sole champion.)
- craftyguy 7y ago> but free speech is as much a societal value as a legal construct, and is not limited to the Bill of Rights as its sole champion.) Where, in the US, is the requirement that everyone has to let anyone say anything enshrined? AFAIK, it's not, and is (very) often confused with the Bill of Rights version.
- lukifer 7y agoIt's enshrined in you and me. :) Law is not the only mechanism for upholding cultural values and norms. One important distinction is that free expression is not limited to the "right to say anything"; it also includes the right to listen to the expression of others. See, for example, the rich history of librarians resisting turning over records of who reads what books, which could result in a chilling effect where people are scared to read controversial material.
- hype7 7y agoYou view this as a bad thing. As a consumer, I view it as a good thing. I’m not sure if folks remember what “apps on mobile” were like before Apple came along, but it was the goddamn Wild West. The fact that it’s walled in, that I’m not going to get pwned, that my parents won’t (and won’t be tempted to by the promise of an extra $0.99 saving) is to my mind, a good thing. If all this competition that the article talked about was such a good thing, apps would be cheaper on Android, and I, as a consumer, would switch. Fact is, the fact that Tinder et al are now bypassing Google’s mechanisms isn’t a good thing to me at all. It’s more the reason to stay on iOS. The article writer is pissed he can’t get access to me without paying Apple’s toll, but what he doesn’t understand is that I am like it like that.
- jotm 7y agoIt makes more sense to think of iPhones/iPads as consoles. They're just as closed down and controlled. Some people are fine with console gaming, many are fine with limited computing on their phones. If you're not, there's a lot of Android phones, varying from open to extremely open, for general purpose computing.