3 ms·
I had a while ago calculated the actual download cost with S3's pricing on what each ~100MB Spotify update would cost if it was self hosted. Assuming each paid
by dangus 7y ago
I had a while ago calculated the actual download cost with S3's pricing on what each ~100MB Spotify update would cost if it was self hosted. Assuming each paid and free Spotify customer on the iOS platform updated the app was something to the tune of tens of thousands of dollars depending on how you estimate the marketshare of iOS for Spotify versus their other platforms.
What the App Store provides is not valueless, quite the opposite in fact. It's an entire system of distribution management.
Is it monopolistic? By definition, no, because Android is the #1 smartphone platform in the world.
Is it great that Apple has provided no alternative way of downloading software to the iPhone and iPad? No, that's not great either, but users knew that from day one (when the iPhone had no App Store at all).
In reality, iOS is no different than a game console like the PlayStation 4 or Xbox One, and yet we consider those closed marketplaces completely functional and normal.
If Apple was the only company making smartphones or if they even made a plurality of them, perhaps this would be a problem.
- mattnewton 7y ago> Is it monopolistic? By definition, no, because Android is the #1 smartphone platform in the world. This depends on how you describe the market. Is the market smartphone users or is it iOS apps? If you are in the market to buy an iOS app, you must go through apple, which would suggest it is a monopoly. IANAL but this has precedence - think of the “windows browser market” that Microsoft was raked over the coals about. The fact that you could buy a Mac or run Linux didn’t appease the courts IIRC. I find a lot of value in the iOS App Store and think it is just like a game console, but that doesn’t mean it can’t be viewed as a monopoly _for iOS apps_
- dangus 7y agoMicrosoft was raked over the coals because they actually possessed a pure monopoly. In 2002 Internet Explorer had a 96.6% browser marketshare. [1] In 1999 Microsoft Windows made up around 95% of desktop operating systems in use. [2] In terms of antitrust law, IANAL but, I think you'd have a harder time convincing a court that the App Store is a monopoly of any sort. I don't think you can just break down markets into sections like that and claim they have a monopoly on that section. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usage_share_of_web_browsers#OneStat.com_(April_2002_to_March_2009) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usage_share_of_web_browsers#On... [2] https://money.cnn.com/1999/01/19/technology/microsoft/ https://money.cnn.com/1999/01/19/technology/microsoft/
- LanceH 7y agoThe value is that Apple allows distribution. Distribution could be handled any number of ways for considerably less. It is only valuable (especially at 30%) because it is the only one allowed.
- dangus 7y agoOne might say the same thing about any retail store - that distribution of my product could be done considerably less than what that store is asking for. But the whole calculation is that the value of distributing somewhere is weighed against the opportunity cost of not distributing there. Apple's < 20% global marketshare isn't anywhere near enough to make the assertion that customers don't have alternatives.