4 ms·
> Here’s the thing: If you’re a developer for iOS or macOS and want to charge customers money, the Apple-provided payment tools, which demand a 30% cut, are the
by Wowfunhappy 7y ago
> Here’s the thing: If you’re a developer for iOS or macOS and want to charge customers money, the Apple-provided payment tools, which demand a 30% cut, are the only ones you’re allowed to use. It’s not even a discussion.
Why does macOS keep getting offhandedly roped into these discussions? Not only is the Mac App Store not a requirement, it's rarely used.
Maybe Apple intends to change that some day, but that's speculation, not reality. And frankly, from where I sit, people have been predicting the demise of macOS sideloading for nearly a decade now, and they're still waiting.
- natch 7y ago>Why does macOS keep getting offhandedly roped in... Because the people who write these screeds are ignorant. Apple has good reasons for doing things the way it does, and instead of acknowledging and addressing those reasons, the authors usually project onto Apple some made up evil, greedy intentions that don’t exist except in the mind of the writer. In this deluded world it must be the case that Apple does the same with macOS... they don’t even bother to check. Haters gonna hate.
- nothis 7y ago>Maybe Apple intends to change that some day, but that's speculation, not reality. I'd say it's pretty obvious that this is a desired outcome on Apple's part. You can either wait until it's too late or bring it up before it's happening.
- scarface74 7y agoSo if it is the “desired outcome” why is it taking them over a decade? The Mac App Store was introduced in 10.6 - 7 releases ago.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoI obviously agree with you, but tiny nitpick—the App Store was not introduced in 10.6, it was added in a 10.6 point release. So your "7 releases ago" statement isn't quite accurate, although it depends on how you count.
- nerdjon 7y agoI don't think they ever will do that with Mac, and will be a key reason the platforms remain separate. They have to realize how popular Mac is for developers, going down this path would completely remove that market for them.
- throwawaycert 7y agoThe scenario you propose would eliminate the ability to develop apps for iOS. Are you suggesting Apple is actively trying to kill the iOS app store?
- Crinus 7y agoWhy would eliminate the ability to develop apps for the iOS? You could be able to download a development environment "app" from the Mac App Store just like now. You'd be a bit more confined inside the environment itself, but there is nothing that would prevent developing applications with Apple's own tools while disallowing installing anything outside of MAS.
- throwawaycert 7y agoAny ability to execute arbitrary code is the ability to bypass the MAS. What's more, it's nice and efficient - iOS apps in development are compiled right to x86 machine code for the "simulator" that is little more than a thin VM. 100% of the projections I've seen about MacOS becoming a walled garden have been from people that don't actually have any real familiarity with Apple's ecosystem as developers.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoThere are all sorts of restrictions Apple could place on software compiled "unofficially" with Xcode. For example, they could automatically sign it with testing certs that automatically expire after 7 days. macOS is a more open platform because Apple has decided to leave it that way, not because the property is literally essential for development.
- throwawaycert 7y agoThey already require periodic resigning of self-signed side-loaded apps on iOS, it doesn't stop even relatively casual users. (That's actually the funniest part about all this, now that I think about it. While everyone is wailing and gnashing their teeth about some speculative possibility that macOS ends up locked down like iOS, Apple has been making iOS more open.)
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoBased on what? Have Apple executives said anything on the matter? Even vague warnings? You're relying on your own interpretations of their intentions. Over the years, Mac's defaults have changed to protect inexperienced users via restrictions like Gatekeeper and SIP. Apple has never attempted to make any of these systems mandatory. All it takes is a few terminal commands to gain complete kernel-level access to my system.
- Crinus 7y ago> Have Apple executives said anything on the matter? Even vague warnings? Because companies never lie or say that "we're not going to do XYZ" until next week/month/year where they go "XYZ is the new awesome". Expecting companies to be honest is like placing a cat near a canary and expecting them to be BFFs, especially when the topic is something that people have negative concerns about. It is MUCH better to be explicit and loud about what you do not want to see before it happens, than try to reverse a situation after it has already happened. You lose nothing by doing the former, even if there were never plans to do what you fear might happen.
- edmundsauto 7y agoI tend to look at things from the lens of social capital. If I'm always yelling about something, it desensitizes them when something bad actually happens. The "boy who cried wolf" is the downside, and being explicit and loud about something that hasn't even happened and (to most people's eyes) isn't in the works... It marginalizes you. A lot.
- jmull 7y ago> I'd say it's pretty obvious that this is a desired outcome on Apple's part. I don’t see that. Why do you think it will happen?
- TheRealPomax 7y agoProbably because part of the ios appeal is the insanely smooth interoperation between your mac laptop, your appple watch, and your iphone. If you already have a mac because, say, your work got you one (which in the tech industry is ludicrously common) then getting an iphone if you're shopping for a new device makes a whole lot of sense.
- y_molodtsov 7y agoAnd? Tons of apps on MacOS aren’t in the AppStore.
- TheRealPomax 7y agoSo what? The question was why macos gets mentioned, this is why. There is deep interoperation between ios and macos that Apple themselves relies on to sell users a better total experience than can be achieved in isolation.