4 ms·
On Hacker News there are relatively many people arguing for nuclear fission, I wonder if they ever factor in societial factors like these. In an ideal society
by atoav 7y ago
On Hacker News there are relatively many people arguing for nuclear fission, I wonder if they ever factor in societial factors like these.
In an ideal society it still would be a challenge to deal with the unprocessable wastes of nuclear fission (some extremely poisonous and with half lifes well beyond thousand years). But we are far from ideal and the incentives to not just offload it onto future generations are simply not there.
- blueboo 7y agoPollution and contamination are merely future opportunities for innovation. Let’s make more, bigger opportunities!—or so the founders-in-waiting may advocate
- Ntrails 7y agoThe argument isn't that it is riskless cheap energy - but that it is far better than fossil fuels and necessary to complement other renewables in energy supply. There is no question that there are risks and they are non trivial - but they are mostly manageable through proper regulation!
- colordrops 7y agoIt can be argued that regulation is almost completely broken in the United States.
- ryan_j_naughton 7y ago>almost completely broken That seems like a gross exaggeration, almost to the degree of willful ignorance. The amount of premature death as well as increase in morbidity caused by the entire nuclear energy industry in the US is significantly lower than any other source of power. Simply the steel and concrete alone required for solar power pushes it's morality rate higher. While our current secretary of energy, Rick Perry, might have had no clue what the department of energy did when he wanted to abolish it as a presidential candidate. Nonetheless, it and other regulatory bodies are quite effective an ensuring we have safe nuclear facilities.
- colordrops 7y agoIf the regulation worked we probably wouldn't need nuclear reactors. If the trillions spent on oil subsidies due to regulatory capture (which incurs the cost of warfare) went to renewable energy, we'd likely be close to non-dependent on oil and nuclear.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoWe'd still want them though - progress of civilization is predicated on increasing availability of cheap energy, and nuclear reactors are great for this - using high-density fuel to generate electricity in a safe and non-polluting way.
- acqq 7y agoRegarding the expectation of progress, have you seen this? http://folk.uio.no/roberan/t/global_mitigation_curves.shtml http://folk.uio.no/roberan/t/global_mitigation_curves.shtml
- TeMPOraL 7y agoNo, I haven't. It's very informative, thanks! WRT. energy needs - pulling carbon out of the atmosphere will be energy-intensive; it's yet another reason why we need clean and cheap energy (and lots of it!). Nuclear shouldn't be taken off the table.
- acqq 7y agoSeeing the shape of the slope needed now and comparing it to the shape we have needed in e.g. 2000 and knowing the current political climate in the U.S. makes me very pessimistic that the 2 deg limit will be achieved, and knowing how dramatic e.g. 4 degrees or more are going to be, I doubt anybody can expect much “progress”. More some medieval developments. The current estimate is +3.2 deg in 2100, but it still assumes that the current actions progress: https://climateactiontracker.org/global/temperatures/ https://climateactiontracker.org/global/temperatures/
- qball 7y ago>I wonder if they ever factor in societial factors like these. Radioactive releases like this are endemic to every coal-burning power station, which while a problem for public health certainly isn't publicized like this is. Remember, carbon emissions will also destroy the planet if the current projections are anything to go by; I think the chance (certainly less likely with modern reactor designs) that a few local areas are rendered uninhabitable is a tradeoff society will need to be willing to make when the alternative is that the entire planet be rendered uninhabitable over a significantly longer timeframe. Any other answer just isn't taking climate change seriously enough. Reactors are ready (with the proper funding) for construction today; solar/wind designs capable of supplying the quantity of baseload power nuclear can do not currently exist and neither does power storage- and they aren't nearly as scalable as building another reactor is (mainly due to land and raw materials usage) when power demands jump because everyone needs an air conditioning to survive the summer and a local desalinization plant (or water pipeline) because the rivers and aquifers no longer provide enough water. Additionally, if an energy-intensive carbon capture technology becomes available, the only energy source capable of powering such a device at the scale required is nuclear. We've already offloaded our waste onto future generations. Might as well use the most effective technology we know how to create to stem the bleeding a bit.
- ben_w 7y agoI’m in favour of nuclear, but what you say of renewables is only half right. PV is currently around 0.5 terawatts and 2018’s relatively slow growth was 27%, and at these rates it is likely to solve most of our problems before any nuclear plant not yet commissioned gets finished. As for land usage, if the USA did this it would be smaller than the road network, rising to “about the same” if you want to replace all ICE cars with battery cars. CO2 capture, and desalination, don’t need to be run 24 hours per day, so there’s no reason to care if they don’t have energy storage to run at night. Likewise, AC is most important when, and just after, the sun is shining, so the storage need is low. Storage does have a long way to go before we’re out of trouble, but even if I wasn’t fairly optimistic about it, PV knocks out the worst carbon sources first, giving us more time to build — for example — your preferred nuclear reactors.
- 7y ago
- solveit 7y ago> I wonder if they ever factor in societial factors like these. This is either egregious intellectual laziness or a passive-aggressive attack, neither of which I'd like to see on HN. In any case, the answer is that we do, and fission is still orders of magnitude safer than coal.
- jobigoud 7y agoDo you though? The cost of potential accidents is not integrated in the price. When shit happens on a large scale the company doesn't have the funds to repair the local economic loss or century-scale maintenance effort.
- lm28469 7y ago0.0000x% chance of a major issue vs 100% chance of breathing various fumes and particles all your life. What's the societal factors of coal and ICE again ? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boiling_frog https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boiling_frog
- neuronic 7y ago> 0.0000x% chance of a major issue Which might be okay if it wasn't for certain states whose prime directive is to cover up mistakes and issues. Otherwise this article wouldn't exist and we'd be discussing ways to improve safety. Just look how they handled Chernobyl. It was pure luck that the majority of Europe wasn't contaminated as a result of disinformation, refusal to accept help in order to appear strong, and pure incompetence on all fronts. All followed by an unwillingness to fix the problem. Nuclear fission power in such hands is seriously dangerous. Even Belgium is holistically incapable of safely running a nuclear plant as highlighted by Tihange. I am completely with your sentiment but the true issue is real world handling. Idealistic scenarios don't help us.
- lm28469 7y agoEven Chernobyl is a drop in the ocean compared to the impact of fossil fuel though. aka: The worst case scenario of using nuclear energy is less harmful than the best case scenario of using fossil fuel. It's all about perceived threat vs actual threat. In the case of nuclear energy the perceived threats is blown out of proportion, in the case of fossil fuel it's just business as usual. I'm not saying nuclear doesn't have issues, but I'd argue that nuclear issues are manageable/solvable whereas fossil fuel issues are not.
- C1sc0cat 7y agoThere is also for a lot of people a refusal to try and solve the present problem (and not obsess about pious trendy fell good campaigns) So in a thousand years its a SEP - but we do need to slow or reduce global warming NOW
- howard941 7y agoI wanted to reply in a snarky way but your question raises a very troublesome and deep problem to which a solution if it doesn't come right way will certainly condemn our successors to basting in a hothouse earth with too little energy for a recognizable civilization. Have you thought about what could be offered up in the way of positive incentives for responsible behavior? Do they need to be positive incentives rather than overwhelming disincentives? Copyedited