2 ms·
But while the implementation of an aeroplane is quite different from that of a bird (especially the propulsion side), they don't operate on different principles
by taneq 7y ago
But while the implementation of an aeroplane is quite different from that of a bird (especially the propulsion side), they don't operate on different principles at all. Birds generate lift and control their flight in the same way aeroplanes do, through aerofoil wings and movable control surfaces.
Likewise, even though the implementation of AGI will almost certainly use logic gates on silicon, the principles behind it will probably be fairly close to those behind biological intelligence (unless, despite all our work on the topic, it turns out that there's an easier way to do AGI than the biological way).
- solveit 7y agoMm but I think you can save the analogy by switching birds to insects, which use very different aerodynamic principles because fluid dynamics depends greatly on scale. I think it's plausible that something similar could happen for AGI. Perhaps the best way to get AGI depends greatly on whether you have 200 petaflops of exact, sequential operations or a hundred billion neurons that are slow, analog, but massively parallel.
- taneq 7y agoGood point. It seems reasonable that the limited intelligence shown by, say, honeybees works dramatically differently than mammalian intelligence, despite sometimes having surprisingly similar outputs at times.