3 ms·
Zoning laws enacted after a property purchase can infringe on property rights. Zoning laws that exist prior to a purchase merely form the foundation upon which
by sokoloff 7y ago
Zoning laws enacted after a property purchase can infringe on property rights. Zoning laws that exist prior to a purchase merely form the foundation upon which you should expect to exercise the property rights in your purchase. (Just as you are prevented from operating a junkyard on your property, your neighbor is also prevented from operating a junkyard on theirs, protecting your property rights [assuming you don't want to live next to a junkyard].)
If you want unencumbered use of your property, buy out in an unincorporated area with no zoning laws. When you do, don't be surprised when your neighbor decides to start a pig farm...
- bluGill 7y agoThe junkyard on my neighbor's property doesn't hurt me - as long as my neighbor is careful to prevent oil leaks and other sources of pollution. It might be ugly, but ugly is a first amendment right.
- sokoloff 7y agoIf you buy a nice little SFR for $X and the day after closing, your neighbor opens up a new junkyard, do you think your house is still worth $X on the market? That is part of why people buy in areas with zoning and, more extreme example, why people buy in areas with HOA regulations.
- bluGill 7y agoYes it will be. I've compared houses with junkyards next to them to houses without and it made no difference. Junkyards next to your house implies a rural area, where your neighbors will have horses and tractors. Your house isn't that close to theirs in the first place. Either that or the junkyard has been there for years - the neighborhood is probably bad, but the junkyard isn't the cause it is the effect.
- rayiner 7y ago"Not living next to a junk yard" is protecting a property right in any way property rights are recognized. There are such things as nuisances, but they generally require concrete harms of a type recognized at common law. (Stuff like health and safety, not aesthetics.) Zoning is not a part of property rights. Zoning was something invented in the early 20th century, because property law wasn't sufficient to enact the kind of racist controls people wanted.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> Zoning laws enacted after a property purchase can infringe on property rights. Zoning laws that exist prior to a purchase merely form the foundation upon which you should expect to exercise the property rights in your purchase. The first problem with this is that most existing zoning rules don't actually meet your premise. They were imposed on whoever owned the property when they were enacted, regardless of their consent. The second problem is that even for things like HOAs where all the properties were owned by one entity that originally consented to the restrictions, what you then get is essentially a local government-style entity where only land owners get a vote. This is clearly not a particularly egalitarian style of governance.