3 ms·
> But other cities, like Plano, Tex. — where more than 4,000 residents have mobilized to overturn similar plans — have taken steps backward. I take issue with
by brobdingnagians 7y ago
> But other cities, like Plano, Tex. — where more than 4,000 residents have mobilized to overturn similar plans — have taken steps backward.
I take issue with this. I grew up in Plano, Texas. I loved it and I loved the people. This article is a negative comment about those people "taking steps backward", when they are really mobilizing themselves to take part in local politics and democratically help make the city how they want it to be. Is Plano perfect? No. But the people there do believe in being active in local government and in trying to make changes that the people in the community _want_. It's a special kind of place, and they care. They've done this again and again.
> As a zoning official, I’m usually the last person to advocate for federal intrusion into local decision-making. But the problems of housing inequality and segregation are too big for localities to tackle piecemeal.
That last excerpt is simply an emotional appeal "acknowledging" the author's supposed credentials of opposing big government---- while supporting it. But zoning laws are one of the most impactful things that a local government actually manages, and why shouldn't you be able to help shape your community, especially when we usually want people to participate _more_ in local politics, and zoning laws are one of the ways you can make a real difference in your community. But if you take away any really meaningful power that a local government has, why would anyone care at all to participate?
- ilikehurdles 7y agoI take the same issue whenever I see zoning issues about my locality (Denver) brought up by online communities who tend "YIMBY" but have little, if any, horse in the race of local politics. There this un-nuanced thousand-miles-removed view of zoning issues propagated in media and places like Reddit and HN, and then there's the opposing boots-on-the-ground version where those of us living in the community, who would have to live with the changes, fight against destructive zoning proposals and corrupted officials. Starting a sentence with "as a zoning official" has no value. Having personally met with a number of zoning officials, historic commission members, city planners, and council-members, their allegiances and political views vary from one to the next. Some ran on campaigns almost entirely funded by out-of-state-developer donations; while others, sure, are a reflection of elite country-club voters wanting to keep out the "riff-raff". There's a whole swath of viewpoints in between the extremes, and the only thing consistent among every national story about "NIMBY"ism is that it is far, far too disconnected from the communities to adequately capture any of those viewpoints.