3 ms·
The argument for their usefulness is simply the actual experiments preformed. Due to it’s size the military can easily collect a lot of useful information. >
by Retric 7y ago
The argument for their usefulness is simply the actual experiments preformed. Due to it’s size the military can easily collect a lot of useful information.
> If your measurement is predicting everything, it usually means you are measuring nothing.
The goal of IQ was to predict everything as it's a one dimensional scale. You can always find a better test for any given quality, and frankly should. However, that does not somehow invalidate it's wide ranging utility.
- runarberg 7y agoBy “wide ranging utility” you mean “detecting and diagnosing mental disabilities” right? If not: Using IQ for anything else is, at best, quite useless, and at worst, severely problematic as you found out when you heard about scientific racism (such as the eugenics movement).
- Retric 7y agoBy useful, I mean saving the US military hundreds of millions of dollars. It's not perfect, and I would argue it's not even very good, but it does work. Which among several reasons is why it's been outlawed for US companies.
- reasonaway 7y agoyou keep claiming that there is some threshold above which it does not predict anything even though this contradicts all available evidence. like taleb your beliefs are based on nothing more than unfounded speculation.
- runarberg 7y agoNo I don’t claim that (even though Taleb might have; didn’t read him thoroughly enough). I say that there is a (muddy) threshold where these tests become useless. They still hold predictive power, but what they do predict is useless.