3 ms·
So, here's a reasonably rational response to a hotbutton claim like that: I think most numerate folks would look at that data and view a "race/IQ correlation"
by ajross 7y ago
So, here's a reasonably rational response to a hotbutton claim like that: I think most numerate folks would look at that data and view a "race/IQ correlation" as at least a reasonable hypothesis.
But come on, it's weak. The relationship that chart shows clear as day is wealth. Wealth is super correlated. The top of the chart are exlusively industrialized democracies. The bottom are exclusively impoverished (and mostly unstable) backwaters.
And within those cohorts, sure, you can kinda/sorta say that east asians sit above europeans, maybe. Or maybe not. Four points of IQ are nothing -- it's like three decades of development per the Flynn effect, or maybe one decade of really focused investment in education.
There are counteless other good hypotheses for a weak signal, and this isn't an area amenable to direct experiment, so realistically we're never really going to know.
And the same stuff is true of the linked article. It's poking holes in specific statements by finding rigorous numbers that "disprove" it, but only very weakly. Basically, the point to the article isn't that "IQ is solid science", it's that Taleb's paper was too aggressive in its conclusion. Which is sort of a yawner, and not really a good excuse to bring race into the discussion.
But yeah. It's possible that darkies are dumber or that the gooks are smarter. It's possible. What drives those of us on the left absolutely bonkers isn't the possibility that you might be right, it's the fact that you look at messy data like this and immediately go to the least tolerable conclusion as if that's what you want to be true. And... yeah, yuck.
(Edit: and right on cue three quick responses about "but that doesn't prove race isn't correlated, here's another hypothesis for why race might be correlated!", which sounds to me suspiciously like "I really want race to be correlated with IQ!" The truth is we just don't know, we might never, even if it is it's weak, and I for one would rather live in a world where people don't want this to be true than the one I'm stuck in. )
- sunseb 7y agoGood point, but someone could say that IQ is correlated to Wealth (and not the other way around)?
- ajross 7y agoSomeone could, and the support would be equally ambiguous and we'll all die never really knowing the answer. So... not to be too much of a hippie here, but maybe we could all try to just stick to actual science here and not start flinging around pontification about one of the most deeply offensive and divisive topics of modern society on the basis of what amounts to tarot reading? Just a thought. What's that quote from the Big Lebowski again?
- mc32 7y agoI want to agree with you but China is not “super industrialized”. They’ve only caught up in the last two decades and have a vast countryside which is still way underdeveloped, some at the subsistence level. So wealth might have something to do with it, but it’s also only loosely associated.
- ajross 7y agoSo one outlier (not even that much of an outlier!) proves a racial correlation? This is what I'm talking about. It seems to a lot of "us" that a lot of "you" are going to cling to these racial opinions no matter what, constantly poking holes at any argument so that your own worldview doesn't have to change. And that's what horrifies us. Is that really a worldview you want to have?
- mc32 7y agoI’m not saying it’s racial at all. All I am saying is that wealth is also only loosely correlated.
- ajross 7y agoFair enough, wealth is only loosely correlated too. But just look at the chart: it's vastly more correlated than race, which was the variable that the poster above jumped to, for reasons that (again, seems to folks like me) probably aren't related to worry about statistical fidelity.
- yorwba 7y agoIQ varies significantly across China: http://www.city-data.com/forum/attachments/world/148304d1429210862-china-iq-map-provinces-8-10-qq-20150417024936.jpg http://www.city-data.com/forum/attachments/world/148304d1429... (A map someone compiled based on https://m.doc88.com/p-5803924483878.html https://m.doc88.com/p-5803924483878.html , a study on the effect of iodine on children's IQ) Compare with the distribution of GDP per capita: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Chinese_administrative_divisions_by_GDP_per_capita https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Chinese_administrative...
- fastball 7y agoSure, wealth is correlated as well. But perhaps wealth comes from intelligence? That seems reasonable, does it not? Wealth creation, at its most fundamental, is all about doing things more efficiently than they were done in the past. Who would be best equipped to tackle invention if not people with good problem-solving skills, as measured by IQ? Honestly, this could be put to rest fairly "easily" (obviously this wouldn't be that easy and is never going to happen) if you took 1000 expectant mother's who have just become pregnant from Equatorial Guinea and transplanted them to various wealthy countries. Then measure the children's IQ as they grow up and compare them to the rest of the local population. I have a feeling the difference in IQ would be negligible, and that the vast divide can be attributed almost wholly to nutrition/etc in early development, but you can't maintain that this is the case until you've actually tested the hypothesis, which as far as I'm aware has not been done. I'm not entirely sure how the Flynn effect is relevant, unless the claim is that certain countries (African ones mostly) are not being retested at all, but European countries are. Is that the idea?
- ceejayoz 7y agoThe Flynn effect is relevant because it demonstrates an ongoing change in "intelligence" measurements on a timeframe unlikely to be attributable to genetic changes. It points to other factors significantly affecting the measurement - possibly nutrition, changes in how we educate kids, etc.
- ajross 7y agoExactly. Though to be fair what most people (even right-leaning libertarians who tend to flog the race/IQ thing the most) mean when they think of "race" isn't really well correlated with genetics either. In the US the people we talk about (and again, suspiciously, tend to be the focus of this IQ stuff) as "african-american" or "hispanic" are members of predominantely creole populations with staggeringly broad genetic backgrounds. Which you'd think would get them thrown out as obvious confounding outliers, but yet...
- fastball 7y ago
- brabel 7y ago> Wealth is super correlated. The top of the chart are exlusively industrialized democracies. The bottom are exclusively impoverished (and mostly unstable) backwaters. Exactly... one may conclude from this one of two things: * countries become wealthy for unrelated reasons, allowing its populace to get wealthier and achieve a higher IQ. * people with higher IQ can generate more wealth, hence countries with higher average IQ become wealthier. I think that the first hypothesis may be true in certain cases, e.g. oil-rich places... but it seems more likely to me that the second hypothesis is correct, after all I would expect a group of more intelligent people to achieve more than a group of less intelligent people, or is that a polemic claim?
- skybrian 7y agoIt's ignoring history. When a country starts out poor and becomes rich, or suffers a setback, this is better explained by other events in their history. Things like wars.
- mcguire 7y agoAbsolutely. It's why Finland, Germany, and Britain have always been the center of human cultural development. And why Asia certainly did not spend any time in the "Third World" category and positively never fell victim to European colonialism.
- papln 7y ago> I would expect a group of more intelligent people to achieve more than a group of less intelligent people, or is that a polemic claim? Imagine if a bunch of "more intelligent" people invent a nuclear bomb and blow themselves up (might yet happen), or discover the amazing properties of lead and poison their brains across an entire civilization (already happened). then the less intelligent people might achieve more, eh? Let's dive right into a big racial/IQ claim: Jews have above average IQ. Assuming that, that makes them more successful as a group, perhaps? On the other hand, starting from say 1930, Jews were absolutely horrific at average achievement, thanks to the Nazi Holocaust. If the Jews were less intelligent, perhaps they would have blended into society better (after all, Jews don't look especially different, except for Jews that kept their mating pools limited) and been less noticeable by the Nazis.