6 ms·
Yeah, I'm honestly not sure how to interpret this. Either you assume that IQ is 100% not genetic, or you have to admit that race seems to be correlated.
by fastball 7y ago
Yeah, I'm honestly not sure how to interpret this.
Either you assume that IQ is 100% not genetic, or you have to admit that race seems to be correlated.
- js8 7y agoI think the study is controversial because there is huge bias in the way people are educated in these different countries. No human capability is likely to be 100% genetic.
- fastball 7y agoI mean, some capabilities are going to be nearly 100% genetic -- see Kenyans and running. But my concern is that if there is a genetic component to intelligence at all, that is a problem. 40 IQ points less on average is no joke.
- squirrelicus 7y agoIt's not just a problem, it's an incredibly tragic reality that we're not socially equipped to dispassionately discuss how we should respond to it
- danenania 7y agoIt’s only a problem due to obsession with the very narrow component of intelligence that IQ tests measure. If we didn’t place such an undeserved and inordinate emphasis on this single trait, it wouldn’t be an issue. High IQ may or may not correlate with success in our civilization, but considering that our civilization is highly dysfunctional and has positioned itself on the verge of numerous forms of self-destruction, how much does that really matter? There are clearly many more components than IQ-style intelligence that contribute to a good life and a stable society. Anyone who thinks that either a person’s or an ethnic group’s performance on an IQ test says anything about that person’s or group’s value to the world is an idiot regardless of what their IQ might be.
- fastball 7y agoThings that are not important at an individual level can absolutely be important at a societal level.
- squirrelicus 7y agoI agree with all the things you said. I have one commentary: The fundamental problem with racists and group identitarians in general is that the things you know about a group don't tell you anything about the individual. The promise of the West is supposed to be (and i argue still is, despite Twitter) that we judge individuals by the content of their own character and not by their group memberships.
- papln 7y agoI've noticed that people who invest a lot of their ego into defending the primacy of IQ tend to low on non-IQ measures of talent/potential (such as "EQ" or physical abilities), even bending into logical contortions about how people who are high achievers despite supposedly low IQ (such as the MBA and Jock stereotypes that some engineers throw around) are somehow "cheating" at life.
- ForHackernews 7y ago> 40 IQ points less on average is no joke. Which is why it's almost certainly junk science. 40 points on a scale normalized around 100 is an absurdly large disparity to try and hang on genetics. Are there any heritable traits that show that kind of variation between human populations? Height is a pretty obvious one that ranges dramatically worldwide, but the gap is more like 13%, not 40%! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_average_human_height_worldwide https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_average_human_height_w...
- paganel 7y agoI was among those who believed until not that long ago that there was something genetic about the Kenyan and Ethiopian racers, but a few years ago I started reading about more and more cases of Kenyan long-distance runners having been caught doping. And then two white American female runners won Olympic gold and silver in 2016 at the 3000m steeplechase (I think it was at the Olympics), a race dominated until then by Kenyan female runners. The second American runner even beat her personal best by 30 seconds or so, anyway, a crazy number, which only proves that she was doped out of her mind. Most probably her colleague who came in first place was also doped. Which goes to say that no matter which genetic advantage you might have at birth there’s nothing that the socio-economic factors cannot surpass. In this particular case the socio-economic factors were very much in favor of an American runner being allowed to win an Olympic Games race while being doped, and that happened because the US is a huge market for all the athletics/related producers and almost all of the Olympic Games sponsors.
- papln 7y agoYou example being about women runners weakens the argument. Top women are much slower than top men runners, so there are a lot of relatively obvious anatomical/physiological adjustment that could improve performanec beyond the current known best. This is an ongoing issue regarding the classification of transgendered and intersex athletes. With male runners, doping would stilll be a factor, but there is less headroom for manipulation. You can't dope someone into arbitrarily high performance, and if you could, other physical characteristics wouldn't matter at all, which is clearly not the the case becasue we don't constantly see short, fat dopers popping up in elite contests.
- paganel 7y ago> You example being about women runners weakens the argument. Don’t know if it’s anywhere on the Internet but I remember an East German trainer saying something along the lines of: “It’s much easier to make a man out of a woman than it is to make a Superman out of a man”, all this in relation to East-Germany’s official doping policy. So I’d rather trust a professional in this matter (the East-Germans were truly the masters of doping) when saying that it is indeed easier to artificially increase the performances of female athletes compared to male athletes. Not to end it all on a pessimistic note, there are also “happy” cases of naturally gifted athletes being at the right time and at the right place in terms of external socio-economic factors. The latest such example is the recent Tour de France winner, 22-year old Bernal, who won the Tour on its highest stage which I think reached 2700 meters, while he himself was born and grew up at 2800 meters of altitude. But he also won the Tour because he is a member of the infamous British team Ineos (the former Sky), which also gave the winner of last year’s Tour, Geraint Thomas, a guy born and bread in seaside Cardiff and who until last year’s victory had never had a Top 10 finish in any of the big 3 tours. He’s 32 now, if I’m not mistaken, cyclists much greater than him (like Pantani or Ulrich) were basically lynched by the public opinion for doing less egregious stuff (they at least were talented at climbing).
- timerol 7y ago> nearly 100% genetic -- see Kenyans and running Kenyans/Ethiopians have held the world record in the marathon since 2003. An Ethiopian also held it for a few months in 1998, and most of a year in 1964. Were Kenyans not genetically dominant until 20 years ago? Or are there other factors that caused the rise of a large number of elite runners from a particular area of the world? Running is one area where it is mindbogglingly obvious that there are significant genetic factors involved, yet there are clear and significant changes in running ability by country of origin for reasons that have nothing to do with genetics. 40 IQ points less on average is no joke, but also doesn't point the finger at genetics any more than it does at culture or primary education.
- papln 7y agohttps://www.runnersworld.com/news/a20814362/50-years-ago-kenya-established-its-distance-running-dominance/ https://www.runnersworld.com/news/a20814362/50-years-ago-ken... "50 Years Ago, Kenya Established Its Distance Running Dominance The African country became a medal-winning power at the British Empire and Commonwealth Games in August 1966, and hasn’t looked back." Obviously (1) getting invited to the event and (2) learning the rules of a particular event are major selection factors when drawing conclusions from event results.
- foldr 7y agoThe dominance of Kenyan athletes in these events is probably mostly due to altitude rather than genes. There's certainly no direct evidence of any significant genetic component, whereas we know that growing up at higher altitudes confers certain advantages.
- EForEndeavour 7y agoIt's both. High-altitude populations do show genetic adaptations. There is in fact plenty of evidence of genetic adaptation to altitude. If you grew up at high altitude and are not of Kenyan/Ethiopian descent, you'd be pretty well-adapted, but not as well on average. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-altitude_adaptation_in_humans#Ethiopians_2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-altitude_adaptation_in_hu...
- mcguire 7y ago"40 IQ points less on average is no joke." This is such a brilliant quote that I have to bring it in again: "Another item that ought to prompt the thoughtful reader to question the very large discrepancy in intelligence that the authors assert to exist between various human sub-populations is the extraordinarily low average IQs assigned to many African nations. For example, the authors claim that the mean IQ in Equitorial Guinea is only 59, well shy of the threshold score of 70 below which the testee is classified as mentally retarded. Anyone who has spent significant time with an American or a European whose IQ is that low (as I did for a year while assisting in a special education program) can attest that such an individual is not capable of independently managing his own life, and will require constant caretaking to get on in the world." [Edit: https://mises.org/library/does-iq-determine-wealth-nations https://mises.org/library/does-iq-determine-wealth-nations And it's the Mises Institute.] Giving "IQ points" any meaning at all, 40 of them is an obvious difference. As in, big enough that this shouldn't be an issue.
- papln 7y agoI don't for a second belief that the mean IQ in Equitorial Guinea is only 59, but it's certainly possible to have a society where half the people have a reasonably functional level of intelligence, but due to some debilitating recessive genetic disorder have a huge population of disabled individual who are cared for by the unaffected part of the population and who even supported in their moral right to mate and produce children -- perhaps even exploited as manual laborers.
- tfha 7y agoAre you completely sure there isn't some culture reason they are so good at running? There are so many variables at play beyond our modern understanding. It's just a topic we really don't have a good grasp of, as is the case with most of medicine. We understand a lot of strategies, but our understandings of root causes is still very poor.
- squirrelicus 7y agoThat's part of the problem. IQ does predict educational achievement, but education has very little effect on IQ. For example, early intervention education has a temporary effect on children that disappears as they age. In other words, IQ does not measure how educated one is.
- matthewdgreen 7y agoAnd yet directly practicing for an IQ test can improve test scores significantly. And simultaneously, some large-scale IQ measurement papers seem to use "proxies" -- things like standardized tests that are the sort of thing that educational curricula tend to include practice for. So I'm not sure how completely I can accept this claim.
- Chathamization 7y agoAlso, a county closing all schools for several years lead to significant drops in IQ scores[1]. [1] https://www.jstor.org/stable/2294274?seq=1#page_scan_tab_contents https://www.jstor.org/stable/2294274?seq=1#page_scan_tab_con...
- papln 7y agoIQ tests scores are on the same as IQ, which puts a hge asterisk on every test score. It's an unfortunate cloudiness of using maps for territories. This phenomenan is especially notable nowadays where wealthy parents canb buy a diagnosis to givetheir children extra time on IQ tests. And then of course ADHD drugs and other stimulants raise the question of what it means for a person to "have" an IQ, if that IQ (and/or test score) is influenced by doping. Stimulants and the brain question our notion of what is an "individual", much as the bacteria in our gut do. The idea of an "individual" is a very synthetic Western mathematical concept that does not have a strong basis in the science of the natural world. https://www.sciencealert.com/this-tree-stump-is-mysteriously-being-kept-alive-with-a-little-help-from-its-friends https://www.sciencealert.com/this-tree-stump-is-mysteriously... "Scientists Find Weird, Zombie-Like Tree Being Kept Alive by a Forest 'Superorganism'"
- skybrian 7y ago
- marliechiller 7y agotheres an interesting sam harris podcast featuring charles murray on this topic which is well worth the listen imo: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S6Rmbfi6YrE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S6Rmbfi6YrE
- mcguire 7y agoCharles Murray, author of * Human Accomplishment: The Pursuit of Excellence in the Arts and Sciences, 800 B.C. to 1950 * Losing Ground: American Social Policy, 1950–1980 * Real Education: Four Simple Truths for Bringing American Schools Back to Reality * Coming Apart: The State of White America, 1960–2010 Oh, and The Bell Jar, although that doesn't somehow imply that 1950 was the peak of White Culture.
- Barrin92 7y agothe correlation isn't the controversial part, the fact that IQ is one, or the dominant causal driver for different outcomes is. and also, there is not a single piece of evidence on this planet that IQ is 100% hereditary.
- fastball 7y agoI think you misread my comment w.r.t the 100% part.
- Skunkleton 7y ago> Either you assume that IQ is 100% not genetic, or you have to admit that race seems to be correlated. Or, bear with me here, you have to admit that IQ tests can only measure trained skills that correlate loosely to raw intelligence.
- fastball 7y agoThat is literally what I said -- "you must assume IQ is 100% not genetic or..." == "IQ is purely measuring trained skills". The issue is that I think there is very little evidence to suggest that IQ is only measuring trained skills. Otherwise people could get much, much better at IQ tests given practice, but this does not seem to be the case.
- Skunkleton 7y agoHave you taken a professionally administered IQ test? The types of questions asked can't be prepared for in the same way as you might prepare for the ACT. But if your first exposure to IQ-test-like questions is an IQ test, there is no way you will achieve your maximal score.
- fastball 7y agoI'm not a big fan of anecdotal evidence, but I'll bite. I have taken multiple (3) professionally administered IQ tests, and my highest score achieved was on the first of those, when I was eight years old. I don't think that means anything, but there you go.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- squirrelicus 7y agoIQ definitely does not measure anything learned. Malnutrition and genetics appear to be the dominating factors.
- BurningFrog 7y agoIf IQ isn't genetic, rabbits would have the same average IQ as humans. But that does not mean "races" have to have different inherent average IQs.
- fastball 7y agoBut a race is a particular genetic line. If intelligence is genetic, then it is entirely possible that one genetic line of humans has a lower intelligence than another line. Right?
- foldr 7y ago>But a race is a particular genetic line No, it is not. "Races" are identified by a range of superficial characteristics relating to appearance and by language and cultural background. The connection to genetics is very loose. The idea that black people in Africa all belong to a single "race" would seem quite absurd to most Africans, for example.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dsr_ 7y agoNope. "Race" in humans is a cultural construct, of interest primarily to people who want to feel superior to other humans ... and the people who study those people.
- moccachino 7y agoThis is just plain wrong on all levels. Sure, racists are interested in race and everything related to it because they feel they are superior, and conveniently disregard the things that don't support them being superior. But race is not a cultural construct, as evidenced by the fact that you can't culturally adapt your skin to change colors. It is entirely possible to note the differences between men and women without being sexist. It is also possible to be interested in and note the differences between different parts of the human population without being racist.
- root_axis 7y agoOf course there are racial correlations. The "races" are 5 gigantic buckets that abstract over an unimaginably complex variety of DNA. The reason why people get so worked up over this is because someone always chimes in with "based on these correlations we need to face the hard truth that black people are dumb and ashkenazis are geniuses, act accordingly".
- mcguire 7y agoWait! I thought Ashkenazis were dumb and Koreans were geniuses.
- ajross 7y agoSo, here's a reasonably rational response to a hotbutton claim like that: I think most numerate folks would look at that data and view a "race/IQ correlation" as at least a reasonable hypothesis. But come on, it's weak. The relationship that chart shows clear as day is wealth. Wealth is super correlated. The top of the chart are exlusively industrialized democracies. The bottom are exclusively impoverished (and mostly unstable) backwaters. And within those cohorts, sure, you can kinda/sorta say that east asians sit above europeans, maybe. Or maybe not. Four points of IQ are nothing -- it's like three decades of development per the Flynn effect, or maybe one decade of really focused investment in education. There are counteless other good hypotheses for a weak signal, and this isn't an area amenable to direct experiment, so realistically we're never really going to know. And the same stuff is true of the linked article. It's poking holes in specific statements by finding rigorous numbers that "disprove" it, but only very weakly. Basically, the point to the article isn't that "IQ is solid science", it's that Taleb's paper was too aggressive in its conclusion. Which is sort of a yawner, and not really a good excuse to bring race into the discussion. But yeah. It's possible that darkies are dumber or that the gooks are smarter. It's possible. What drives those of us on the left absolutely bonkers isn't the possibility that you might be right, it's the fact that you look at messy data like this and immediately go to the least tolerable conclusion as if that's what you want to be true. And... yeah, yuck. (Edit: and right on cue three quick responses about "but that doesn't prove race isn't correlated, here's another hypothesis for why race might be correlated!", which sounds to me suspiciously like "I really want race to be correlated with IQ!" The truth is we just don't know, we might never, even if it is it's weak, and I for one would rather live in a world where people don't want this to be true than the one I'm stuck in. )
- sunseb 7y agoGood point, but someone could say that IQ is correlated to Wealth (and not the other way around)?
- ajross 7y agoSomeone could, and the support would be equally ambiguous and we'll all die never really knowing the answer. So... not to be too much of a hippie here, but maybe we could all try to just stick to actual science here and not start flinging around pontification about one of the most deeply offensive and divisive topics of modern society on the basis of what amounts to tarot reading? Just a thought. What's that quote from the Big Lebowski again?
- RobertoG 7y agoThat's not the only available explanations. You can find many alternatives. Specially now that we have discovered the influence of epigenetics. For instance, average height of a population is not a fixed value but changes with the progress of a country. Presumably due to the diet improvement in the mother's generation. Another consideration: parasites, I would be surprised if they don't influence the development of child intelligence.
- openasocket 7y agoTwo counterpoints: First is that there are plenty of environmental factors to consider, especially with regards to 3rd world countries. In rural parts of Africa where people are predominantly subsistence farmers, there is a very high rate of prenatal and neonatal malnutrition. And that can cause mental retardation. And so can getting malaria and a variety of other infectious diseases in infancy. Second point is that you are assuming that race is a well-defined genetic construct. But it isn't, it's largely a social construct. Population genetics for humans is a continuum, and we just arbitrarily draw the lines.
- fastball 7y agoI'm not sure how you can claim race is a largely social construct if black people have black kids, white people have white kids, and asians have asian kids. Seems super genetic to me. There is literally nothing more genetic than race, as far as I'm aware. Two tall people aren't guaranteed to have a tall kid. Two intelligent people aren't guaranteed to have an intelligent kid. Two empathetic people aren't guaranteed to have an empathetic kid. Two white people are pretty much guaranteed to have a white kid.
- openasocket 7y agoThere's a lot of research on this subject: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Race_and_genetics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Race_and_genetics which probably serves as a better rebuttal than the paragraph I'll write. Basically, if you try to divide people up into broad categories of race, you will find individuals in race A that are more genetically similar to some individuals in race B than other individuals in race A. You can define race in terms of the handful of genes controlling skin color, eyes, hair etc, but all the other genetic differences between people won't generally fall into that same pattern
- runarberg 7y agoWhen people talk about race, they are usually talking about a population or a set of traits commonly found within a population. For example, populations with a high degree of Irish descendants have a higher then average set of a few noticeable traits like red hair, pale skin, the O+ blood type, etc. These traits also exist in other populations and someone that has 100% Irish ancestry for the last few dozens of generations is not guaranteed to have all of them. When using the more accurate definition of race, people are usually talking about different but highly related species. For example Chimpanzees and Bonobos are different races. African and Indian elephants are different races. The Neanderthals was a different race of humans. With this understanding there is currently only one race of humans. Claiming the existence of some Irish race (and let alone white race) is at best confusing, but usually wrong.
- bitcurious 7y agoThere’s isn’t anything controversial with admitting that race is correlated with IQ. The controversy is from folks trying to take that correlation, reframe it as causation, and then attribute it to genetic factors. There are tons of non-genetic factors that can affect IQ and are correlated with race: exposure to pollution, economic situation, nutrition, etc. Then there is the test itself. I’m not sure how localization happens, but it’s a pretty hard problem that lends itself to biases.
- kilo_bravo_3 7y agoI assume that IQ is correlated to poverty, educational attainment, the learning styles used in schools, and the presence or lack thereof of "cram" schools. The top 5 highest scoring countries, Hong Kong, Singapore, South Korea, Japan, and China all have a cram school culture that prepares them for the endless rounds of standardized tests they have to take to secure a position in society. I would expect people trained from infancy to excel at standardized tests, to excel at standardized tests. Many of the reasons I listed would explain why, in the US, the states of West Virginia (98.7) and New Hampshire (104.2), despite having very similar demographics have such different average IQs. One state is richer than the other. It would also explain why Hawaii, which demographically is comprised of people (about 1/3rd) who share genetic lineage with people from high IQ nations, has a relatively low average IQ. Hawaii has a pretty bad public school system. Until someone locks two children in an Edu-Pod from birth to adulthood and feeds them the same stream of information and nutrition and measures their IQ when the pod ejects them at the end of the test, we'll never know for sure, but my gut tells me that all of the people who think "genetics is destiny" are losers.
- ohaideredevs 7y ago'but my gut tells me that all of the people who think "genetics is destiny" are losers.' Try doing a sport competitively at a high level, where the whole team is eating the same, working out the same, and some plateau at a 315 deadlift and start getting injured all the time and others keep going to 450 without any problems. And that's ignoring obvious things like deformities, asthma, insulin resistance, etc.
- papln 7y ago> Try doing a [X] competitively at a high level That covers maybe 1% of the population. Meanwhile the other 99% of us have environment effects (nutrition, education and training, role models, weather, exposure to niche opportunities and advantages) that are greater sources of variation than genetics.