2 ms·
This feels like such a straw man. First, people on the left who are resisting carbon taxes are mostly because they believe cap and trade is a better solution,
by crazygringo 7y ago
This feels like such a straw man.
First, people on the left who are resisting carbon taxes are mostly because they believe cap and trade is a better solution, which many economists agree with.
Second, what has some notion of "climate justice" got to do with anything? I don't see any evidence politicians on the left are somehow getting distracted by "value-signaling".
Third, where does the idea come from that a carbon tax must be matched with less regulation elsewhere? That's a pure right-wing dream to try to match the two together, there is no connection.
What this essentially sounds like is a Republican talking point that it's all Democrats' fault because Democrats aren't succeeding, despite Republicans refusing to help and therefore making it impossible to succeed. The doublespeak and hypocrisy makes your head spin...
- peacetreefrog 7y agoI don't think it's a straw man. Look at the two examples I cited. This is the first thing that comes up when you google 'green new deal': "A Green New Deal is a big, bold transformation of the economy to tackle the twin crises of inequality and climate change. It would mobilize vast public resources to help us transition from an economy built on exploitation and fossil fuels to one driven by dignified work and clean energy." https://www.sierraclub.org/trade/what-green-new-deal https://www.sierraclub.org/trade/what-green-new-deal And here's AOC's chief of staff on the green new deal: "“Do you guys think of it as a climate thing?” Chakrabarti continued. “Because we really think of it as a how-do-you-change-the-entire-economy thing.” " Second is Jay Inslee, the democratic running for president who has made fighting climate change the centerpiece of his campaign. https://www.jayinslee.com/climate-mission https://www.jayinslee.com/climate-mission Look at his four points. Point three is "fighting for environmental justice & economic inclusion". Two of the other points are subsidies, one for clean energy, the other for a jobs program. The last one -- getting rid of subsidies for fossil fuel industries -- is a good idea. Control f'ing for the word tax (as in carbon tax) gives no results. Neither does cap, nor trade.
- crazygringo 7y agoI guess I just don't see how this is "worthless value signaling". There's more to the environment and economy than just carbon reduction -- these are real, positive things. Jay Inslee's page states "net-zero greenhouse gas pollution" and "transitioning off fossil fuels". I think it's clear these could be accomplished via tax or cap and trade, and most voters probably don't care much about the specific details of which. The main point is, I don't see any evidence that if Republicans offered up a carbon tax bill, that Democrats would vote against it because they wanted something bigger. It's beyond ridiculous to suggest this is Democrats' fault because they want to do even more. Responsibility here lies 100% with Republican obstruction, and it's just disingenuous to suggest otherwise.