6 ms·
Why simply deride electronic voting as a solution in search a problem? There are many problems it solves. 1. How about low voter turnout, so elections aren’t r
by EGreg 7y ago
Why simply deride electronic voting as a solution in search a problem? There are many problems it solves.
1. How about low voter turnout, so elections aren’t representative of what the people want. An app would increase voter turnout by a lot, especially the younger vote.
2. How about letting less mobile people to vote. Or people who are not able to take off work that day. (https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/zm9j85/i-couldnt-vote-because-i-had-to-work https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/zm9j85/i-couldnt-vote-bec...)
3. How about being able to count elections in time to call them, instead of things where Bush gets elected because some guys ran out of time, and then it turns put Gore would have won?
Aren’t these important enough problems for a democracy to solve?
Instead of simply downvoting, why not actually address what I am saying! I am going to go point by point.
Sure, absentee ballots are a thing, but guess what. People like apps. If it’s secure enough for everyone’s banking needs, why not for a vote?
You can make the same argument about money — that banking apps are a honeypot for thieves etc. And yet we have made banking apps so so secure that you’d use them to move thousands of dollars.
If everyone voted from their phone, it could be anonymous and cryptographically secure. And a Merkle tree would record all results.
What is the issue? Every problem you point out with electronics can be done with paper ballots, too.
The interface can lie to you? Has been done with butterfly ballots and others.
The vote counting process is rigged? Have different groups audit the process.
In fact, having cryptographically secure receipts makes it extra easy and fast to verify votes. Al Gore would have won, because they wouldn’t have has to take so much time for a recount:
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=qcz6NSyxrfQ https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=qcz6NSyxrfQ
Instead of throwing our hands up and saying “oh, X is an issue!” why not simply work on fixing the issue?
So let’s run down the issues:
1. Not enough access to phones and computers
Fine, people without phones can still vote the old fashioned way.
2. Stealing a phone
A very inefficient way to fake a vote
3. Interfaces that lie to you
Ignoring the fact that machines already do this (https://youtu.be/EV_c1-YTk8M https://youtu.be/EV_c1-YTk8M) the interfaces would need to be audited by different groups using each other’s interfaces in an anonymous manner (not like when Uber’s greyball https://amp.theguardian.com/technology/2017/mar/03/uber-secret-program-greyball-resignation-ed-baker https://amp.theguardian.com/technology/2017/mar/03/uber-secr... ). This is the general problem of the Trusted Computing Base.
4. Anonymity
Listen, should we know how every person voted?? We do now! Thanks Government. Best Voting System Ever (https://www.forbes.com/sites/leemathews/2018/10/16/millions-of-voter-records-are-for-sale-on-hacker-forums/amp/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/leemathews/2018/10/16/millions-...)
Erm sorry. The solution. Token mixing. You get one token per person, but then they go through a cryptographically securd mixer before being used to sign your vote. Kind of like with Monero rings.
5. Accountability
How can we prove the votes happened the way you wanted them to?
Well, YOU still have your token on YOUR phone (no one else does) so your app can audit the Merkle tree.
Zero-Knowledge Proofs would be overkill here because proving how you voted to someone else is important (See #3, above). In addition, ZK proofs are a bit ivory-tower idealistic since most people don’t have the knowhow to “produce a fake alternative vote”.
The Merkle Tree can consist of smaller branches, one for each district. The results can be tallied in near real time, and verified by anyone. Results would be known in real-time.
6. But realtime reporting will affect voters!
Yes, and it currently already does, with Ohio, Michigan, and so on. The current system makes some states way more important than others:
https://www.nationalpopularvote.com/campaign-events-2016 https://www.nationalpopularvote.com/campaign-events-2016
Why not require all states to have primaries at the same time and not reveal the results til the end? This is a political, not technological, solution.
The only one major problem I see with electronic voting is #3, the trusted computing base. I listed the main solution above, but I am sure there will be many improvements on it.
- the_snooze 7y ago> 1. How about low voter turnout, so elections aren’t representative of what the people want. An app would increase voter turnout by a lot, especially the younger vote. Improved accessibility from the status quo has minimal marginal effect on turnout. https://www.eac.gov/documents/2017/02/23/will-vote-by-mail-elections-increase-turnout/ https://www.eac.gov/documents/2017/02/23/will-vote-by-mail-e... > 2. How about letting less mobile people to vote. Or people who are not able to take off work that day. Paper mail-in ballots are a well-established way to accomplish this, though they do have their own risks---specifically vote-buying and coercion. My county in California also allows curbside voting by appointment, which is pretty great for elderly voters. >3. How about being able to count elections in time to call them, instead of things where Bush gets elected because some guys ran out of time, and then it turns put Gore would have won? This is already a solved problem with precinct-counted optical scanned ballots. I highly recommend you volunteer to be a poll worker the next time there's an election in your state. You'll learn a lot about the real problems on the ground. For example, in my precinct during the 2018 midterms, we encountered an issue with the voter rolls: the city had recently renamed a street but a lot of people's registrations still reflected the previous name, which slowed things down significantly.
- specialist 7y agoOnly two things have been proven to increase voter participation (in the USA): Peer pressure, culture of voting (your neighbors noticing they didn't see you at the poll site). Competitive races. On the flip, there are many things which counteract vote suppression: Universal, automatic voter registration (just like all other mature democracies). Reenfranchise felons. Fair redistricting. Adequate funding for election administration. -- I've not seen any data suggesting that digital voting schemes have or may boost voter participation. And there's numerous cases where such systems disenfranchised voters.
- DrScientist 7y agoHere's the problems such a system would create. - Voting in private on a phone app. The opportunity for coercion is huge. The brilliant thing about putting a cross on paper in a booth on your own and dropping into a box, is no-one knows how you voted - so no comeback. - Anything in software has the opportunity for a large scale attack. The incentive for doing such attacks is large. Look at all the energy put into gerrymandering etc today - Why risk it? - the ability to do a sensible audit is beyond most people - auditing a pile of paper is easy - anyone can participate. Software you'd need to trust a small priesthood - that's not democracy, and it's totally dangerous ( forget algorithms, the weak points are people ). I'd also question your premise that low voter turn out is largely due to inconvenience. Sure for some, but I'd argue lack of participation is largely riven by other factors - like nobody worth voting for.... Finally paper system is easily adaptable - want a box for write ins? Move to single transferable vote? Just print different paper and people doing the counting can adjust - no software re-writes.