5 ms·
> If you think their work is in error, show how. That's now how it works. If they put together a big, complicated cost model, it's up to them to provide evide
by pfdietz 7y ago
> If you think their work is in error, show how.
That's now how it works. If they put together a big, complicated cost model, it's up to them to provide evidence it's valid. Otherwise, it's just an exercise in "believe us, we're honest". For example, they could apply the same model to fission reactors and show it accurately predicts what they end up costing. Oddly, I don't recall fusion cost modelers ever doing that. Hell, I don't recall fission cost models being terribly accurate.
You like this result because it's telling you what you want to hear, not because it's intrisically believable. More motivated reasoning.
- T-A 7y ago> That's now how it works. Yes it is. They presented their work, their sources and conclusions. If you believe it's wrong, but can not explain why, all you have is a prejudice. If you want anyone to take you seriously, you need to provide a rational argument explaining exactly how they are wrong, not just why you want to believe that they are.