4 ms·
So what does this mean, we will be able to have drones flying continuously and getting energy from the sun?
by EGreg 7y ago
So what does this mean, we will be able to have drones flying continuously and getting energy from the sun?
- shakna 7y agoThere's been an efficiency break through for solar cells. > ... an achievement that could lead to an ultralight engine that can power drones for days. No such thing exists yet, but that's one of the hype ideas being thrown out there to try and get lay people excited about the breakthrough.
- dvh 7y agoDJI Phantom 3 is 0.3m wide and needs 120W to fly. Solar radiation at surface is 1000W/m2. 0.3m0.3m1000 = 90W at 100% efficiency. They claim 29% eficiency* (compared to regular 23%) which is only 26W out of 120W in ideal circumstances, realistically it would be maybe 1/3 of it. It will not fly. You can safely ignore ALL articles about breakthroughs in solar cell efficiency and look only at what is sold in shops because that's the only thing that matters. For years this has been 21-23% despite 5 or more articles about solar panel efficiency breakthrough every month for the last 20 years.
- Causality1 7y agoIt's the same as the "OMG this new battery will power your phone for years!!!" bullshit articles that come around every six months.
- walrus01 7y agoI essentially second everything that the person above is saying. There are an endless number of press releases and public relations bullshit articles put out by people who have some new "breakthrough" in photovoltaics. Whether it's special weird cells, or flower shaped ground mount things, or whatever. What I believe in, is what I can pull out my visa card and buy right now. And at the moment, here's what that looks like: One pallet load (22 panels), of high quality 156mm monocrystalline silicon cells, assembled into a 1.99 x 0.99 meter sized panel. Rated at 370W STC (standard test conditions) per panel. Under $0.60/watt. STC: https://www.altestore.com/blog/2016/04/how-do-i-read-specifications-of-my-solar-panel/ https://www.altestore.com/blog/2016/04/how-do-i-read-specifi... Everything else is either so high priced that you have to contact a sales person to buy it (weird fresnel lens concentrator and triple junction GaAs cells intended for use on spacecraft), or is not manufactured in sufficient quantity to gain even 1% of market share, and therefore is not stocked by major photovoltaic equipment dealers.
- IanCal 7y agoThe article is not about solar cells though. It's about thermophotovoltalics, where you'd use a high temperature heat source.
- lgats 7y agoQuadcopter "drones" are much less efficient than winged plane "drones". Additionally, they have the large surface area of the wings to collect more solar energy. Though the image does show a consumer quadcopter device...
- Gravityloss 7y agoYeah the Airbus Zephyr solar powered drone was up for 25 days.
- IanCal 7y agoNo, the article is about efficiently converting heat to electricity, it's not about solar panels.
- ajuc 7y agoWe already have drones with wings that are capable of that, or close to it. This would make them more efficient. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8m4_NpTQn0E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8m4_NpTQn0E For quadcopters and similar I doubt it will be enough.
- amirhirsch 7y agoI’ve seen reports of thin film organic solar cells that produce >1 watts per gram of material. A quadcopter motor can generate multiple grams per watt of power. You can today go and buy 100W from a 3.3lb panel, which is like half way there and not even trying. I’m guessing it’s probably possible to make a quadcopter that can hover indefinitely in the sun.
- walrus01 7y agoNo, not really. The math for watts consumed in total just to hover, for a very large quad, hex or octocopter (with 24 to 28 inch size props, so optimal grams/watt thrust efficiency for something you can fit in a van), doesn't work out. The weight and size of a 400W solar panel made from the very best cells you can buy commercially today is considerably more than the wattage you would need to hover a 10+ kilogram coaxial octocopter capable of carrying such a large panel on top of it. For a large octo, a single Tmotor U8 motor with a 28 inch prop requires anywhere from 310W to 850W while in flight, and there's eight motors + eight props on a coaxial medium/heavy lift octo. I showed this article to a few people in the professional arducopter/ardupilot/arduplane community and it has been quite thoroughly chuckled at. For reference, here's the datasheet for a prototypical motor, a tmotor u8 170kv with 28 inch prop. You'll see the table for watts consumed and grams/watt efficiency with motor+prop mounted on a thrust stand. http://store-en.tmotor.com/goods.php?id=324 http://store-en.tmotor.com/goods.php?id=324 If you wanted to put photovoltaics on a quad/hex/octocopter, you have multiple issues with not enough top deck surface area, not being able to introduce a lot of "sail area" (something big and light that will be grabbed by the wind) sticking out of the top, and the weight of the pv itself. There is no PV solution anywhere near small enough to fit on the top deck of a really big commercial coaxial octo that is also capable of producing 2000W. Not even 100W in sunlight. Somewhere from 18 to 30 times less watts than is required just to hover in one place.