3 ms·
I had this weird and strong question the other day: how come evolution didn't manage to wipe out suicidal gestures. Why don't we just fall into a partial coma w
by agumonkey 7y ago
I had this weird and strong question the other day: how come evolution didn't manage to wipe out suicidal gestures. Why don't we just fall into a partial coma when our mind is overwhelmed by events. It's a bit odd.. alas evolution is no silver bullet (sic):
- arrrg 7y agoWe do have mechanisms that deter us from committing suicide like fear and pain. The good thing about fear and pain is that they are universally useful, e.g. both when we are on the verge of being reckless and suicidal.
- agumonkey 7y agoThere are other levels of emotional pain where you may harm yourself without any fear at all (no external setup required, road, cliff or else). Your mind will still generate aggressive thoughts aimed at yourself, to the point of suicide. This brain aspect seems very .. hard to understand.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoIt isn't necessarily crazy to want your suffering to end and to believe death is the only solution. This is why we have the right to die movement.
- agumonkey 7y agoI meant at the biological/neurological level, not social/moral.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoThe right to die movement is generally about people with terrible medical conditions for which we have no cure. So I don't see the distinction you are trying to make.
- agumonkey 7y agoMy original question was unrelated to that issue also.
- bayesian_horse 7y agoThe susceptibility for depressive episodes (and suicidal tendencies) is probably the result of other more beneficial "features" rather than evolutional neglect. For example when you have a serious infection, especially with fever, the immune systems triggers quite a few mental symptoms similar to depression, in an attempt to conserve energy, lessen the impact of the infection and maybe even limit your ability to infect others.
- alexashka 7y agoThe same reason we have babies born that get cancer. Why do babies get cancer? How come evolution didn't wipe out cancerous gestures in babies?
- agumonkey 7y agoask complex as cancer can be, it doesn't cross the whole system's layers
- emiliobumachar 7y agoI assume that suicide was a lot harder in the ancestral environment. Also, there was almost no way to get any information about it.
- gingabriska 7y agoI don't know what partial comma is. But depression exists for evolutionary reason to conserve energy when we are sick, to limit the risky behaviours like movements (jumping from rock to rock, running after a wild buffalo) etc... But the problem is that the mechanism which can set us into depression can be tricked by our perception of the reality. What your eyes see and what you sense does not only depend on your eyes or your senses but also on how your brain interprets those. If your brain interprets a perfectly sunny day as warning for really long winter, your system can be tricked into sending yourself into depressive state. Now this can happen for variety of reasons like family problems, where you see your mom and dad hating each other while you were still developing at age 5, your brain development is affected and you sense more danger and pessimism than what a normal person would sense.