4 ms·
I'll take the First Way of Aristotle/Aquinas: * http://tofspot.blogspot.com/2014/07/first-way-some-background.html http://tofspot.blogspot.com/2014/07/first-wa
by throw0101a 7y ago
I'll take the First Way of Aristotle/Aquinas:
* http://tofspot.blogspot.com/2014/07/first-way-some-background.html http://tofspot.blogspot.com/2014/07/first-way-some-backgroun...
* http://tofspot.blogspot.com/2014/08/first-way-moving-tale.html http://tofspot.blogspot.com/2014/08/first-way-moving-tale.ht...
* http://tofspot.blogspot.com/2014/09/first-way-part-ii-two-lemmas-make-lemma.html http://tofspot.blogspot.com/2014/09/first-way-part-ii-two-le...
> Some things in the world are changing. (Observation)
> Whatever is changing is being changed by another. (Lemma 1) See Part I.
> There cannot be an infinite regress of instrumental changers. (Lemma 2) See Part II.
> Therefore, there must be a changer that is not itself being changed by another.
* http://tofspot.blogspot.com/2014/10/first-way-part-iii-big-kahuna.html http://tofspot.blogspot.com/2014/10/first-way-part-iii-big-k...
- zzo38computer 7y agoI have seen Aquinas's proof written somewhere. It is like what you wrote: Something that is moved is moved by someone else, but there cannot be a infinite regress, therefore God is the unmoved mover. But that is illogical: The conclusion contradicts the premise. Rather, if something that is moved is moved by someone else that is before it (rather than a loop), then it necessarily is a infinite regress (and this infinite regress is like what is God, I suppose).
- throw0101a 7y ago> Rather, if something that is moved is moved by someone else that is before it (rather than a loop), then it necessarily is a infinite regress (and this infinite regress is like what is God, I suppose). Read the series posts. The use of the word "motion" in the day-to-day colloquial sense is not the way "motion" is being used in the technical/philosophical sense in these arguments: > What's in a name? If "motion" is more than the thin concept used in modern physics, that raises the question³ of whether we ought to call it "motion" anymore. Because motion is defined as "the reduction potency to act," we might call it "actualization," but this would earn blank stares [see left]. So would kinesis, although that sounds agreeably scientificalistic. The word change captures the greater scope of kinesis, but comes off as rather bland. It's kinetic change, after all. [...] > 3. "Motion" begins when the many potencies a thing possesses collapse onto a single potency (the "actual" potency). The act of building commences. > 4. "Motion" ceases when the potency has been fully actualized (or the actualizing force has been removed!) The building has been completed (or abandoned). > 5. "Motion" means that a thing is both what it is now and what it is going to be, as of now. > 6. "Motion" is a change to something a thing already possesses. If the thing already possesses motion, then it would be a change in that motion (i.e., an acceleration) [...] > 8. "Inertia" (lit. "laziness") is a principle of resistance to change, not a principle of motion. "Motion" ["Change"] must overcome this resistance. A body does not continue to move because of inertia, but because of momentum. If friction changes the motion, it must overcome resistance to change. > 9. "Motion" that is continuous and unchanging is actually "rest" (equilibrium). This includes orbiting planets, Belousov–Zhabotinsky reactions, etc. * http://tofspot.blogspot.com/2014/08/first-way-moving-tale.html http://tofspot.blogspot.com/2014/08/first-way-moving-tale.ht...
- zzo38computer 7y agoOK, what you write makes sense, although my argument is not about motion, but rather about Aquinas's argument, so the meaning of "motion" is not relevant to my argument (whether that premise is true or false is also not relevant); rather, I am commenting on the form of the argument being illogical.
- hota_mazi 7y ago> Whatever is changing is being changed by another > Therefore, there must be a changer that is not itself being changed by another. A proof that contains its own refutation :-)
- state_less 7y ago> Whatever is changing is being changed by another It started off good :) Makes me wonder about the technical details of what hardware God runs on and how that was created? I got interested in Sethianism, since Seth is my given name, and it has a fun creation mythos. You get a little backstory leading up to the garden of eden. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sethianism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sethianism
- throw0101a 7y ago> Makes me wonder about the technical details of what hardware God runs on and how that was created? If it is created, then it cannot be God by definition. If we are talking about creation and existence (and not change), then we are getting into the Second Way: > 1. Everything which has come to exist has been caused to come to exist. > 2. Nothing which has come to exist can be the cause of its own existence. > 3. Everything which has come to exist is caused to exist by something other than itself. (follows from 1,2) > 4. It is impossible for a chain of causes of this kind to go on to infinity. > C. There must be a first cause, which causes other things to come into existence but did not itself come into existence. (follows from 3,4) * https://www3.nd.edu/~jspeaks/courses/mcgill/201/aquinas-cosmological-argument.html https://www3.nd.edu/~jspeaks/courses/mcgill/201/aquinas-cosm... NB: the argument is not "everything has a cause", which, if it is your starting proposition, tends to leads to problems: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kalam_cosmological_argument https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kalam_cosmological_argument
- state_less 7y agoI'm not really sure about any of these premises. Maybe there is some reflexivity in there. Maybe there are causes as far back as anyone cares to look and we'll never know for sure if there are loops or starting point(s). How is anything caused, what does it mean for a cause to not exist, what hardware does God run on and so on?
- nabla9 7y agoThe weaknesses in these proofs are in the premises. For example: > Whatever is changing is being changed by another Asian philosophers would have pointed out that self causation seems to be true. Most things that appear persistent cause themselves to change state. They even had the concepts of two things changing or creating each other at the same time "dependent co-arising". "conditioned existence". Thing might exist conditionally. When condition arises thing starts to exist, when it goes away it ceases to to exist.
- throw0101a 7y ago> Asian philosophers would have pointed out that self causation seems to be true. This is more along the lines of the Second Way: > 1. Everything which has come to exist has been caused to come to exist. > 2. Nothing which has come to exist can be the cause of its own existence. > 3. Everything which has come to exist is caused to exist by something other than itself. (follows from 1,2) > 4. It is impossible for a chain of causes of this kind to go on to infinity. > C. There must be a first cause, which causes other things to come into existence but did not itself come into existence. (follows from 3,4) * https://www3.nd.edu/~jspeaks/courses/mcgill/201/aquinas-cosmological-argument.html https://www3.nd.edu/~jspeaks/courses/mcgill/201/aquinas-cosm... Note that Aquinas has not (just|necessarily) talking about 'horizontal' causes (going back in time), but 'vertical' causes. Up until the Big Bang Theory was formulated (by a Belgian priest no less)†, the accepted cosmology was that the universe had always existed eternally with no beginning. So Aquinas talking about what caused things (to continue) to exist in the here and now. > A sequence is ordered essentially if each changer in the sequence possesses the power to change another only if a preceding changer is acting concurrently upon it. For example, a clarinet does not have the power to play Mozart's Clarinet Concerto in A in and of itself. It will only play if Sharon Kam is playing upon it concurrently. * http://tofspot.blogspot.com/2014/09/first-way-part-ii-two-lemmas-make-lemma.html http://tofspot.blogspot.com/2014/09/first-way-part-ii-two-le... For a fuller treatment on the subject, I highly recommend the book Aquinas by Edward Feser. † The fact that it was initially put forward by a priest supposedly stunted its spread a bit, because folks thought that he just wanted to give "scientific" grounding to the Biblical account of creation in the book of Genesis.