2 ms·
The proof shows precisely that a conclusion follows from axioms. That doesn't settle anything though, all it means is that anyone disagreeing with the conclusi
by roenxi 7y ago
The proof shows precisely that a conclusion follows from axioms.
That doesn't settle anything though, all it means is that anyone disagreeing with the conclusion must also disagree with one or more of the axioms. Particularly, if someone believes it is irrational to believe in God they would also believe it is irrational to accept all the axioms of the proof.
My personal complaint is that "for each positive property, either it or its negation must be positive". Assuming that a property is uniquely positive or negative requires the assumption of a universal moral value system, which in turn really would require require something godlike to set the standards. I accept that there are properties that are sometimes positive and sometimes negative, so I don't agree with the argument.