3 ms·
I think this is more of a cultural shift than anything. Americans in particular used to be tinkerers and makers to a much greater degree. While admittedly many
by philwelch 7y ago
I think this is more of a cultural shift than anything. Americans in particular used to be tinkerers and makers to a much greater degree. While admittedly many of these examples are influenced by gender roles, it was much more common than today for a mid-century American man to be a tinkerer and handyman who might work on his car in his own garage, do his own home maintenance, and stuff like that. HyperCard and the early days of personal computers arrived at the tail end of this era, where it seemed perfectly natural for "owning a computer" to naturally entail "doing basic computer programming" in much the same way as owning a house, car, or motorcycle entailed doing basic work that entailed having some understanding of the thing. (One complaint you hear about cars these days is that you can't just work on them in your own garage anymore!)
America today is a mass consumer culture where people by and large don't really do that kind of work. Contra Heinlein, Americans today are increasingly specialized insects, less likely to even cook their own meals let alone write a HyperCard stack to manage their recipes. It's in the culture even more broadly than anything Apple might do.
It's not hard to see Apple as making the problem worse instead of better. Apple loves hardware designs that make it impossible to take the machine apart, for instance. Steve Jobs always had that bias--compare the original Macintosh 128K to the Macintosh II, for instance. Even HyperCard itself only came out after Steve left and the hackers briefly took over. And I get it, because a platform that allows for tinkerers and dilettantes is never going to be as beautiful and elegant as a something that was thoughtfully designed from a single perspective; just think back to MySpace or Geocities. But it also makes people dumber in the practical sense of being less capable of changing, repairing, and fully comprehending the world around them.