6 ms·
I've never used Hypercard and I just can't fathom the love for it. If nothing matches Hypercard, why don't people use it (or some opensource copy) of it? So m
by jayd16 7y ago
I've never used Hypercard and I just can't fathom the love for it.
If nothing matches Hypercard, why don't people use it (or some opensource copy) of it? So many seem enthralled by it but the reality is no one seems to want to bring it back.
- tyingq 7y agoThey do, it's just fragmented. Things like Excel/VB, Quickbase, Airtable, Tableux, etc.
- hjk05 7y agoBecause newer copies don’t include the nostalgia that’s one of the primary drivers for people’s admiration.
- danaris 7y agoWell, the main reason no one uses Hypercard itself is because emulating classic MacOS is a pain and a half. I haven't explored all the copies, but the ones I have seen tend to be less featureful and/or less user-friendly than the original. Furthermore, probably the best modern software that's similar to Hypercard in its overall flexibility and power is...the web. Back in the day, Hypercard was it; there wasn't really anything else in that space. Nowadays, there's still nothing that's quite as awesome or matches all its features, but there are things that are much closer and do a lot of the same things that are much more accessible than emulating or reimplementing Hypercard.
- cortesoft 7y agoEmulating Mac OS classic isn't particularly difficult these days. I use sheepshaver with great success. I actually DO use it to run my old hypercard games I wrote in elementary school.
- danaris 7y agoLast time I tried using Basilisk II, I managed to get it to be stable (running System 7 in an emulated...IIsi, I think?), but if I ever tried to change anything beyond adding and removing disks, it just wouldn't run. I haven't tried SheepShaver much, I admit, because most of the stuff I want to run was written for 68k and runs poorly or not at all on PPC.
- jhbadger 7y agoThe existence of the Web is indeed a big reason. While everybody seems to compare Hypercard to things like Visual Basic, and yes, you could use it that way to make applications, most people used it to create stacks on a topic (a particular band, or Shakespeare's plays, or Japanese swords) that were basically Web sites before the Web.
- D-Coder 7y agoLiveCode (renamed from "Runtime Revolution"). Free for personal use: https://livecode.com/products/community-edition/ https://livecode.com/products/community-edition/.
- irrational 7y agoI guess DreamWeaver might be the modern equivalent (though definitely not as easy to use as Hypercard). Can DreamWeaver set up client-side storage easily? With Hypercard it was dead simple to save stuff to local storage.
- misterdata 7y agoProject I am working on that may be close: https://diasli.de https://diasli.de
- reeeeee 7y agoLooks nice! But why is it in dutch? Does it load language settings based on location? Why can't I change it?
- misterdata 7y agoIt selects the language based on browser locale - what is yours set to? Should definitively improve this... From Dutch you can switch to English using the menu in the top right corner (click "Engels")
- reeeeee 7y agoGreat, thanks! I checked the menu but probably missed the language settings.
- Angostura 7y agoIts power was partly in its ubiquity - people who weren't programmers stumbled across it, had a play and suddenly realised 'this is a bit handy'. There was never really a killer app for Hypercard, it had so many bizarre use-case cases. But its flexibility and ability welcome unlikely users in is where it did so well.
- lochlan 7y agoI might consider Myst a “killer app,” especially for its time.
- kls 7y agoIt was a different time, the world moved on to web enabled / multi-user applications. Hypercard and MS Access where decidedly built around single users with the latter having multi-user capabilities but not great support for it. They where both designed in a time where a constant network connection was a luxury and not a commodity. They where awesome for their time, but it was also a simpler time, as of yet no one has come up with a stupid simple app builder for present day computing realities as complexity has exploded, its a interesting problem and if a person could make creating simple apps for web/mobile/multi-user as easy as Hypercard was, they would certainly be rolling in fortunes.
- asciilifeform 7y agoOne of the attractions of Hypercard was that a "stack" (document) was entirely self-contained; and would always behave exactly the same on any machine where HC could run. Notably, would run without any need for servers (or, worse, the subscription-and-lock-in "services" ubiquitous today -- arguably the 1980s "computer revolution" was strangled in the cradle, and we've gone most of the way back to 1970s-style time-sharing now: how many phone apps etc. will run usefully without a net connection? The "smartphone" is essentially a small "glass TTY", rather than personal computer in the '80s sense.) I've run HC stacks written 30+ years ago. How many current-day "web app" documents will be readable as-found 30 years from now? For that matter, I've paid for iOS apps that would no longer execute after half a year (on account of Apple's "API changes", or in some cases -- author's "call home" server fell down and did not get up, etc.) Permanence (in the most basic "I paid for this and it ought to be usable for so long as any compatible iron remains functional" sense) is no longer part of the software commercial culture, and one is likely to be laughed at for merely raising the question.
- scroot 7y ago> The "smartphone" is essentially a small "glass TTY", rather than personal computer in the '80s sense. We now have a generation or two that completely missed this era, and, worse, might be uninterested in the history. The idea that you would have a ubiquitous, portable, always-on personal computing device and that -- at least from the perspective of people who are knowledgeable of about this history -- you would put a Unix on it is completely crazy. It is, as you say, an expensive and sleek teletype emulator