2 ms·
At best this is "another" problem, rather than the main problem. And no, Windows Defender "real time protection" is not actually a MITM. For security you rely
by tialaramex 7y ago
At best this is "another" problem, rather than the main problem. And no, Windows Defender "real time protection" is not actually a MITM.
For security you rely on your TLS implementation actually being competently implemented and enforcing all the policy requirements you may have. The MITM proxy hides that, now you're reliant on _their_ implementation, and they get to do whatever enforcement they feel like.
Unless you deliberately run archaic web browser versions there's a good chance your browser does TLS 1.3 with PFS and fast high quality crypto, whereas the MITM proxy lazily downgrades to TLS 1.2 (or earlier) with whatever the programming team could be bothered to get working in, say, 2016 when they last put effort into this. It still works, and they don't actually care about your security, so it's fine, right?
That browser (and possibly your entire OS if you aren't running some DIY Linux setup) manages a CA root trust programme, but if there's a MITM it might... not bother (everything is considered "trusted" hooray) or it might punt and rely on some other trust store, did it tell you which one, who manages it and how often they update?
TLS can also be mutually authenticated, a MITM proxy breaks that because it will need to not only MITM one side, it will need to MITM both sides, and if that's allowed you don't have any meaningful security between the endpoints.
I watched both IETF 105 TLS meetings last week, there are key browser and/or operating system people there actively participating. When you hear people say "ecker" that's Eric Rescorla of Mozilla, and when they say "A G L" that's Adam Langley of Google. You may briefly see Nancy - Nancy Cam-Winget of Cisco but that's the extent of the representation the MITM proxy vendors have, and MITM proxies are only one of many pies Cisco has fingers in.
It may be that the convenience of blocking advertisements is worth the extra security risk, but that would be the correct way to understand this - it's not just a matter of "I consent so this is fine".