4 ms·
This article was surprisingly OK. About all it omits is that people at the bottom of the scale generally didn't even understand the questions they were asked,
by ncmncm 7y ago
This article was surprisingly OK.
About all it omits is that people at the bottom of the scale generally didn't even understand the questions they were asked, so their answers were really all over the place.
But the key takeaway -- the D-K effect is about you, much of the time, even if you are expert about some things -- is usually neglected. D-K is about everyone: The more certain you are, the less likely it is you have reason to be.
- smitty1e 7y agoCloud computing has been a DK bulldozer. Time and again the symptoms of the problem I'm troubleshooting have correlated with some prior experience, triggering a prediction, which has been wrong. And I've actually passed multiple cloud certifications, too. IT is just complicated.
- jdsully 7y agoMy initial hypothesis on bug fixes are normally wrong. However proving/disproving them tends to help immensely in finding the real problem.
- alasdair_ 7y agoMy DK assumption/bias is that people who tout their “multiple cloud certifications” are likely more wrong than average engineers. Would be interesting to find out how wrong I actually here...
- smitty1e 7y agoWell, those AWS Associate certs ain't beanbag. However, if you haven't had the service blow up in your face a few times, you'd better have a photographic memory to pass those certs.
- smsm42 7y agoBut, judging from the graph in the article, the top quartile actually under-estimates their ability? Only lower 3 quartiles overestimate it, so for experts it doesn't seem to be true? Unless, of course, I misunderstand DK effect completely and am not aware of it...
- jeremyjh 7y agoIt’s true for experts outside of their field of expertise.
- dragonwriter 7y agoIt's true for experts (above ~70th percentile) in their area of expertise, too, just in the opposite way as it is true for people below that level.
- ChrisSD 7y agoYes, the point is that in your area of expertise you are likely to be more humble relative to your actual ability (but not too far off, on average). However outside of your specific area(s) of expertise your confidence in your ability is likely to far exceed your actual ability (on average). So experts are still susceptible to DK effect for areas that lie outside their expertise. Even (or perhaps especially) if they think their expertise gives them special insight into another field.
- jacobmoe 7y agoThis makes sense to me. If you're an expert you are comparing yourself to other experts in your field. On the other hand, if you know anything about a topic but only interact with people who know nothing at all about it, you would rate yourself highly. For example, I read a lot about modern physics but am not a physicist. I would give myself an above average understanding but would likely fail an exam.
- rjvs 7y agoThe more you know, the more you know that you don't know...
- dragonwriter 7y ago> the D-K effect is about you, much of the time, even if you are expert about some things It's as much about you and the things you are an expert about as anything else; D-K isn't just a low-ability effect.
- ncmncm 7y agoNo, people under-rating their expertise is a garden-variety variation on reversion to the mean. D-K, if it means anything, is an effect on top of that.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> No, people under-rating their expertise is a garden-variety variation on reversion to the mean. Reversion to the mean would be underperforming past elite performance, not underestimating actual performance. And it would draw toward the mean, not the ~70th percentile.