4 ms·
Socioeconomic status comes primarily from your family's money.
by danmaz74 7y ago
Socioeconomic status comes primarily from your family's money.
- quotemstr 7y agoNo, it doesn't. There are lots of self-made people. A pure inheritance model is both defeatist and inaccurate.
- chantelles 7y ago"over 60 percent of the Forbes richest 400 Americans grew up in substantial privilege" (wikipedia) and add in race and gender rigging of the system and IQ is a factor among others.
- danmaz74 7y agoPrimarily doesn't mean only. Of course there are self made people, but the number of those who come from money if much higher.
- bayesian_horse 7y agoWealth can only accumulate exponentially, and there are big limitations for the "growth" factor. You have to build on the wealth of your parents. This makes it substantially easier for those with richer parents!
- dash2 7y agoSocioeconomic status (SES) _is_ primarily your family's money. Where it comes from might easily include your family's genetics, e.g. genetics for intelligence. The parent's point, I think, was that controlling for SES in studies of the effect of intelligence on outcomes is likely to be a mistake, because SES itself will be caused by parental intelligence, which correlates with own intelligence via genetic (and other) pathways.
- bayesian_horse 7y agoIn my opinion the link between intelligence and economic success is hugely overestimated... A strong belief in "meritocracy" leads to a lot of cognitive biases.
- quotemstr 7y agoI'm very tired of people demanding that I believe obvious nonsense like this claim that differences in skill don't exist or that differences in skill don't affect material outcomes. I get that you don't like meritocracy, but I'm not going to accept claims that it's some kind of myth. Hard work and talent leads to success.