4 ms·
Many startup founders do not take a salary for some time. The average cost to launch a startup is around $30,000, according to the Kauffman Foundation. Data fro
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
Many startup founders do not take a salary for some time. The average cost to launch a startup is around $30,000, according to the Kauffman Foundation. Data from the Global Entrepreneurship Monitor show that more than 80% of funding for new businesses comes from personal savings and friends and family.
This sounds to me like they really mean big money, high growth enterprises and are out-of-hand dismissing the kind of people who start more traditional small businesses with no goal of ever becoming a Mega Corp.
I haven't looked at the data too much recently, but twenty to thirty years ago:
Women had trouble getting funding at all, plus typically had ongoing obligations to do the women's work at home, so they typically started smaller ventures with less risk and less growth potential. They were disinclined to borrow any money at all and completely bootstrapped it, paying for any growth out of earnings as they were able to afford it.
If your very definition of business de facto excludes the type of businesses typically started by women -- and no doubt other less-privileged groups -- you shouldn't be shocked when they are underrepresented in your data.
- jacques_chester 7y ago> This sounds to me like they really mean big money, high growth enterprises and are out-of-hand dismissing the kind of people who start more traditional small businesses with no goal of ever becoming a Mega Corp. Actually, the original study makes a distinction between unincorporated and incorporated self-employment as a proxy for business type. > Women had trouble getting funding at all, plus typically had ongoing obligations to do the women's work at home, so they typically started smaller ventures with less risk and less growth potential. Well, yes. They cite papers studying that effect, including one by one of the authors (Rubenstein) of the paper being discussed on the other side of the link.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoWe disaggregate the self-employed into incorporated and unincorporated to distinguish between "entrepreneurs" and other business owners. We show that the incorporated self-employed and their businesses engage in activities that demand comparatively strong nonroutine cognitive abilities, while the unincorporated and their firms perform tasks demanding relatively strong manual skills. The incorporated selfemployed have distinct cognitive and noncognitive traits. Besides tending to be white, male, and come from higher-income families, the incorporated—as teenagers—typically scored higher on learning aptitude tests, had greater self-esteem, and engaged in more disruptive, illicit activities. The combination of "smart" and "illicit" tendencies as youths accounts for both entry into entrepreneurship and the comparative earnings of entrepreneurs. In contrast to past research, we find that entrepreneurs earn more per hour and work more hours than their salaried and unincorporated counterparts. So, basically, if you start a local landscaping business, you don't count for purposes of being "an entrepreneur" in their eyes. That's exactly my point. It's not some kind of rebuttal of my point.
- jacques_chester 7y agoThey're following a long line starting with Schumpeter (of "creative destruction" fame). The reason for this distinction is that if you only divide the population into other-employed and self-employed, they have similar profiles in almost every way, except that the self-employed earn less. That doesn't square with the theory that entrepreneurs are somehow different from the general population -- smarter, more charming, whatever it might be. They use data to show that the population of unincorporated and incorporated businesses closely tracks two groups in the underlying population of job titles, those which are more manual and those which are less. They also note that business types rarely change, so what you start with is usually what you wind up with. When you make that distinction, the paradox of entrepreneurship disappears. The populations have distinct characteristics. If you want entrepreneurs to include folks with small businesses (fine by me, regular small business is much harder than being handed millions of dollars by a VC) then the conflict with Schumpeter's notion reappears. If you go with the narrower definition, this paper has useful contributions. An argument over the exact scope of "entrepreneur" as a word doesn't really change the shape of the data.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoIt boils down to "Them that has, gets." which is hardly groundbreaking news. All this does is very, very politely tell us in extremely PC terms what we already know: Rich white people have more opportunities in the US than people outside that group. I'm interested in figuring out how we break down some of those barriers. I'm a woman. I've been on HN a decade. Virtual hobnobbing with all the right people has so far failed to open any doors for me. As best I can tell, my gender has played a large role in that. My efforts to understand that, resolve that, or even just discuss it tend to be met with open hostility. So color me unimpressed with this extremely PC way of saying "The Old Boy's Club is alive and well. No girls or brown people are really welcome." I live with that reality every single day.
- jacques_chester 7y agoIt's common in science to research an "obvious" thing, because sometimes it leads to nonobvious results. The Michelson-Morley experiment is probably the most famous example. Your experiences are upheld by the literature that I've seen (eg [0]). I don't think anyone intends to reinforce the current state of the world by studying it closely, quite the contrary. [0] https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2846047 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2846047
- WalterBright 7y agoMy great-aunt borrowed money from a bank to start her own beauty salon. In the 1920s. Of course, she also had a reputation for ignoring what other people said she couldn't do, and hugely enjoyed her life. I wish I'd met her.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoYour great-aunt sounds great. My parents had a small business for a time back before the internet and all that. It failed. I knew a lot of small business people growing up. I was surrounded by people who worked from home, etc. Most small businesses are not incorporated. If they have to be incorporated to be part of your study, it's practically a dog whistle that "We're actually only studying businesses created by rich people."
- WalterBright 7y agoI started many businesses as a kid. One was when I lived in Germany for a time. I ordered American candy from a friend back in the states, and would sell it at school to the other American kids who missed it. I'd pay for the candy by sending my friend gummi bears, which were not available at the time in the US. I probably could have made decent money at it if I wasn't so lazy.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- aristophenes 7y agoThe paper that is cited, https://www.nber.org/papers/w19276.pdf https://www.nber.org/papers/w19276.pdf divides entrepreneurs into two groups, those with incorporated businesses and those with unincorporated businesses. Then says those with unincorporated businesses don't count. And then draws conclusions about entrepreneurs based on only the incorporated ones.
- unimployed 7y agoWithout having yet read the paper, is there an explanation given for the exclusion? Like perhaps sole proprietorships don’t scale as large and are not typically the focus of government incentives (funding, sweetheart tax deals, immigration, or otherwise).