5 ms·
Entrepreneurs don’t have a gene for risk–they come from families with money
- jcims 7y ago(2015) Not sure what the point of this article is. It seems to take a pretty narrow view of what constitutes entrepreneurship then curses it with privilege.
- antonkm 7y agoI'd say this could probably give some people a way of looking at things, the environment they live in and that privilege is often there even though it's tabu / taken for granted. At the same time, I find this to be true for a small type of entrepreneurship. My barber, the local store, my favorite restaurant is not really connected to privilege and everyone of them has gotten where they are anyways.
- jcims 7y agoYour second paragraph gets at what I meant by ‘narrow view’. Entrepreneurship happens all over the country at just about all layers of the socioeconomic spectrum.
- unimployed 7y ago“Narrow view” seems unqualified without more about how the studies are actually excluding other entrepreneurs from the findings. Point of the article seems obvious just from the headline, and then there is the body of supporting text too that seems to say that entrepreneurs are not all that special in knowledge or biologically. The obvious extension of this point is that entrepreneurs require no special treatment, favoritism, or perks in exchange for exceptional entrepreneurial traits to coax them to your territory of taxation (or whatever). Instead you might consider developing your current population by increasing their access to capital, resources, connections and safety nets to enable new business ventures based on their proposals to meet a real need that turns a sustainable profit and creates jobs at all salary levels (not just the bottom). No need to provide additional support to just any millionaire/billionaire that will do nothing productive except seek to extract rents from those with less means.
- WalterBright 7y agoI personally know many that did not. Including refugees from other countries who arrived with nothing.
- jchw 7y agoAn idea: maybe it's both ways. Maybe there's a gulf between being wealthy and being fairly poor where you are content enough with what you have to be unwilling to take a risk on entrepreneurship. Either you have nothing to lose, or you have so much that the losses wouldn't really impact your way of life. (Sidestepping the question of whether the article is bunk, because it doesn't really seem to be saying much interesting.)
- WalterBright 7y agoThere's even a saying about it: 1. first generation earns the money 2. second generation spends it 3. third generation has no money I don't think having everything handed to one is conducive to being a successful businessman.
- zepto 7y agoOk - but how does this anecdote help if you don’t have data? Using personal anecdotes to refute a binary assertion backed with data is a category error, even though I don’t doubt your experience.
- WalterBright 7y agoI don't have data, but I know scores of people who started up companies, and almost none of them came from money.
- zepto 7y agoDepends what you mean by ‘Coming from money’. That phrase generally implies major wealth in a way that ‘families with money’ does not. This seems like shifting the goalposts.
- 7y ago
- csallen 7y agoBeing a developer really helps. I've interviewed many dozens of self-funded founders who've explained that the reason they felt comfortable "taking the leap" of entrepreneurship was because they knew they could always fall back to working as developers. Getting paid hundreds of thousands of dollars to write code is a pretty solid fallback plan. This was true for me as well, and is why I've never had trouble starting things, even when I didn't have investors or a rich family to rely on. YMMV, etc…
- soneca 7y agoNot only that, but (for tech products) they don't have to invest tens of thousands of dollars paying someone to build the software.
- rolltiide 7y agoExactly, being an entrepreneur has a survivorship bias from having an excess in money or some other resource People that want to make high margin, high growth companies will be making “tech companies” (cloud based ephemeral software services) Developers are rich in “I dont need to pay other developers I cant communicate with to build the initial idea” and are ALSO rich in money Survivorship bias means they can try and fail and try again very quickly, compared to someone that gets one shot before having to save up again for the next 15 years who experiences life changes and loved ones saying “maybe its time to get realistic Roy”
- ct520 7y agoI feel your post sums up my thoughts well. As a developer it easier to be an entrepreneur for sure .
- josefrichter 7y agoA "garage startup" is the silicon valley's symbol of romantic start "from zero". Fun fact though: most people around the world, even middle-class (by local standards), simply can't afford a garage.. So if your family owns one, you indeed come from a family with money.
- seieste 7y agoOr you live outside the Silicon Valley bubble.
- mrep 7y agoI'm sorry what? Open up zillow and you can find plenty of houses with garages pretty much everywhere in the US that the middle class can afford. Here is one in the suburbs of chicago [0]. [0]: https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/207-Lafayette-Dr-Bolingbrook-IL-60440/5400388_zpid/ https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/207-Lafayette-Dr-Bolingbr...
- josefrichter 7y agoI explicitly wrote "around the world".
- nickjj 7y agoFrom the article: > When you know you have a safety net, you are more willing to take risks. Maybe to a certain degree, but not really. Not having a safety net is what makes you more likely to succeed because there's no "well, if this doesn't work out at least I live in a mansion and my family has enough millions of dollars to live however I want to a realistic degree for the rest of my life". When you have no access to money, you have a special kind of drive. It's the drive that says "look, working a regular job for the next 40+ years is going to drain your soul -- either bust your ass and figure out how to do what you want, or suffer for the rest of your life". The alternative is so awful that you'll do anything to avoid it (assuming you want to be someone who starts their own business). This is coming from the POV of knowing with 100% certainty I was not made out to work a regular job since I was 11 years old and my family has no money.
- cheez 7y ago> When you have no money, you have a special kind of drive. It's the drive that says "look, working a regular job for the next 40+ years is going to drain your soul -- either bust your ass and figure out how to do what you want, or suffer for the rest of your life". The alternative is so awful that you'll do anything to avoid it. Ironically, what you fail to see is that this line of thought is only possible under two circumstances: rock bottom, or born to money. An unemployed 30 year old in between would give their right arm to have a job for 40 years.
- nickjj 7y ago> Ironically, what you fail to see is that this line of thought is only possible under two circumstances: rock bottom, or born to money. An unemployed 30 year old in between would give their right arm to have a job for 40 years. I wasn't born into money and I never hit rock bottom. I worked a few part time non-technical jobs as a teenager before I really got into computers and quickly realized that there's a 0% chance I would be able to exist in a world where I was reporting to someone every day for 40+ years in hopes they keep me employed. That lifestyle just isn't for me. I was lucky enough to find computers in my late teens and programming is something I very much love doing so I made a freelance career out of it for the last ~20 years and still do it today (because I like it). That drive to work for yourself is not tied into having a safety net. It's a mindset and maybe genetic (I have no idea). Most of my related family works for someone else though, so it's not like I'm coming from 10 generations of entrepreneurs here. I think it's more of a mindset because I don't do this for the money. If we lived in a world where you could somehow survive comfortably with no income I would still try to make my own business doing whatever I really enjoyed doing. The primary output of what I do to me isn't money, it's personal enjoyment and the satisfaction of helping others. > An unemployed 30 year old in between would give their right arm to have a job for 40 years. And this is where the problem lies. Unless you're super skilled working at a company that is massive and will never run out of funds then there's practically a 0% chance you'll have a guaranteed steady job for 40 years. You might get a few years or a decade even in some places but it's never guaranteed. The only thing that's mostly guaranteed is you will get paid your salary for a span of a single pay check duration or perhaps any duration you pre-define in a contract. After that, you're hoping that the business you work at stays in business and you are doing your job well enough not to get laid off.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoMany startup founders do not take a salary for some time. The average cost to launch a startup is around $30,000, according to the Kauffman Foundation. Data from the Global Entrepreneurship Monitor show that more than 80% of funding for new businesses comes from personal savings and friends and family. This sounds to me like they really mean big money, high growth enterprises and are out-of-hand dismissing the kind of people who start more traditional small businesses with no goal of ever becoming a Mega Corp. I haven't looked at the data too much recently, but twenty to thirty years ago: Women had trouble getting funding at all, plus typically had ongoing obligations to do the women's work at home, so they typically started smaller ventures with less risk and less growth potential. They were disinclined to borrow any money at all and completely bootstrapped it, paying for any growth out of earnings as they were able to afford it. If your very definition of business de facto excludes the type of businesses typically started by women -- and no doubt other less-privileged groups -- you shouldn't be shocked when they are underrepresented in your data.
- jacques_chester 7y ago> This sounds to me like they really mean big money, high growth enterprises and are out-of-hand dismissing the kind of people who start more traditional small businesses with no goal of ever becoming a Mega Corp. Actually, the original study makes a distinction between unincorporated and incorporated self-employment as a proxy for business type. > Women had trouble getting funding at all, plus typically had ongoing obligations to do the women's work at home, so they typically started smaller ventures with less risk and less growth potential. Well, yes. They cite papers studying that effect, including one by one of the authors (Rubenstein) of the paper being discussed on the other side of the link.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoWe disaggregate the self-employed into incorporated and unincorporated to distinguish between "entrepreneurs" and other business owners. We show that the incorporated self-employed and their businesses engage in activities that demand comparatively strong nonroutine cognitive abilities, while the unincorporated and their firms perform tasks demanding relatively strong manual skills. The incorporated selfemployed have distinct cognitive and noncognitive traits. Besides tending to be white, male, and come from higher-income families, the incorporated—as teenagers—typically scored higher on learning aptitude tests, had greater self-esteem, and engaged in more disruptive, illicit activities. The combination of "smart" and "illicit" tendencies as youths accounts for both entry into entrepreneurship and the comparative earnings of entrepreneurs. In contrast to past research, we find that entrepreneurs earn more per hour and work more hours than their salaried and unincorporated counterparts. So, basically, if you start a local landscaping business, you don't count for purposes of being "an entrepreneur" in their eyes. That's exactly my point. It's not some kind of rebuttal of my point.
- garmaine 7y agoDoes the author even know what genetics are? I was expecting some sort of study of adopted kids and risk taking behavior to control genes vs environments. Instead the author doesn’t seem to realize that entrepreneurs coming from families with means is hardly evidence against the genetic argument, and in fact supports the opposite view.
- orasis 7y agoHow does family background disprove genes?
- lonelappde 7y agoJeff Bezos was adopted.
- plumeria 7y agoHe was adopted by his step dad. However, his (biological) mother came from an educated family: “Bezos is the maternal grandson of Lawrence Preston Gise, a regional director of the U.S. Atomic Energy Commission (AEC) in Albuqurque”. - Wikipedia
- cody3222 7y agoWhat a terrible article. Think of how many would-be founders read this and see it as an excuse not to start. Not to mention it takes credit away from all the founders who don't come from wealth.
- WalterBright 7y ago> Think of how many would-be founders read this and see it as an excuse not to start. None. None of the founders I know were influenced by the endless stream of people telling them they couldn't possibly succeed. The people who aren't founders justify it with an endless stream of excuses.
- jacques_chester 7y agoThe usual argument has broken out that yuh-huh and nuh-uh and there will be salvoes of anecdotes screaming into previously-entrenched opinions. The thing is: some founders come from privileged backgrounds. They have nothing to fear, so they take big chances. Some come from unprivileged backgrounds. They have nothing to lose, so they take big chances. My guess? Both of these types of people will be over-represented, compared to the general population. In any case, after two clicks, it's possible to read the original paper everyone was hanging their blog posts off at the time: https://www.nber.org/papers/w19276.pdf https://www.nber.org/papers/w19276.pdf The same authors have continued to work on the population characteristics of entrepreneurs: http://faculty.haas.berkeley.edu/ross_levine/Papers/SES_FULL_26042019.pdf http://faculty.haas.berkeley.edu/ross_levine/Papers/SES_FULL...
- User23 7y agoThere are rather a lot of confounds here. I don't really want to get too much into that because it's a rathole of speculation, but if there were a gene for risk, and if risk taking made people more likely to accumulate wealth, then being descended from parents with money might lead to an inheritance of both financial assets and some polygenic entrepreneurial genotype. Honestly though, that's missing the point. There are plenty of persons with a high appetite for risk who end up as burglars, robbers, embezzlers, fraudsters, or some other unsavory and largely unsuccessful or net destructive career. In my observation there are two essential traits for a successful entrepreneur: persistence and creativity. Everyone knows what persistence is, but I mean creativity in a broader sense than just art. Anyone who has read Julian May's marvelous Saga of Pliocene Exile will know what I mean. For those who haven't, creativity is essentially the ability to create. Every successful entrepreneur has by definition created something of value. Since as far as we know all traits are heritable, creativity must be heritable as well. However it's an even more subtle and ephemeral quality than intelligence, so I doubt we'll be able to identify the genetic basis of creativity within our lifetimes. By this I mean that while it is at least somewhat possible to synthetically test intelligence, there is no test for creativity other than reality itself. I actually believe that for the sufficiently creative individual, risk is a non-factor. I have had the privilege of knowing a few people of this type, and they literally can't really fail. Sure, one enterprise might not work out, but these folks are just a wellspring of ideas plus execution. They could be dead broke and they'd still succeed in building things.
- lonelappde 7y ago> burglars, robbers, embezzlers, fraudsters, or some other unsavory is compatible with being a successful entrepreneur. Common wisdom says it's essential, even.
- refurb 7y agoIf having a fall back plan is what drives entrepreneurship, you’d expect the firm safety net countries in the EU to have far more of it than a country like the US. Yet we don’t.
- tpush 7y agoIt's probably not just the existence of a fall back plan, but the magnitude of it. Wealthy families in the US provide a far greater safety net than the legal minimum one faces in European countries.
- coldtea 7y agoActually we do. Several European countries have as many or more entrepreneurs than the US. It's just that in Europe it's small self-owned/family businesses, not Facebooks and Theranoses. "In 2016, about 5.6 million small business employers and 24.8 million non-employers were counted in the United States" compared to: "There were estimated to be approximately 24.5 million small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) in the European Union in 2017, with the vast majority of these enterprises micro-sized firms which only employed fewer than nine people. A further 1.42 million enterprises were small firms with between 10 and 49 employees and 231 thousand were medium-sized firms that had 50 to 249 employers."
- bwb 7y agoJust want to back this up, entrepreneurship has been falling since the 1970s in the USA, it is actually pretty scary to see the graphs and data around this, some good studies below showing some of these trends (EIG has some great data on that + the ramifications for the American workforce): https://eig.org/dynamism https://eig.org/dynamism (great report) https://www.hamiltonproject.org/charts/the_entrepreneurship_rate_has_fallen_by_almost_half_for_workers_with_a_bach https://www.hamiltonproject.org/charts/the_entrepreneurship_...
- tanzbaer 7y agoKeep in mind that Europe has roughly double the population of the US. That means according too your source the per capita rate is half of the US.
- alexmlamb2 7y agoAs predicted, the article doesn't contain any genome wide association study to back up its claim in the title that entrepreneurs "don't have a gene for risk". Instead they present another causal factor for creating startups and just implicitly deny that other factors exist. I think Quartz is basically the archetype of fake news at this point.
- godelski 7y agoOkay, but so what? Do we do something about it? Or is this just complaining. I feel like this is analogous to something many people here are used to. We all know people that have been programing since they were a child. Those people had money for a computer (I'm under 30 and this was still a thing). Most of those people had a parent or two that were more highly educated and even more likely that one did STEM (and probably knew some programming or someone that did). Is that privilege? Yes. Do I wish I had those opportunities as a kid? Kinda Am I going to do anything about it? No. Why would I? If this article is only about the myth of the self made millionaire/billionaire then okay. But that doesn't come across. We all already knew that these people came from high places of privilege. But complaining about how they had opportunities that we don't is useless. The problem is lack of opportunities and resources for the less privileged. You don't even need to take away the opportunities from those already privileged. This isn't a zero sum game. If you want to present solutions I am happy to read more articles and do my part. But this just came off as complaining.
- jmpman 7y agoMaybe determine how much money the families need to have in order to spawn entrepreneurs? I suspect that number isn’t $100M, but more like $10M. Then, change the tax policy to create 10 families with $10M instead of 1 family with $100M.
- thenaturalist 7y agoHow would you come up with that number? As noted by others in this thread, starting with entrepreneurship is a combination of knowledge, skills and somewhat being financially independent enough to commit significant amounts of time to creating something from scratch and - most significantly - having a network to achieve the latter. Creating opportunity is a systemic, complex and long term challenge that you can't simply put a $ amount to. Your surroundings and upbringing shape you massively and there is no money which can make up for that and time. When you're 25 coming from a dirt poor community and are the first to study in your family there is such a slim chance you have seized dozens of opportunities correctly so that they stack up to put you in a spot where you are not only able to (aka resources present) but capable of achieving successes comparable to privileged peers. Network and skills are essential. Highly recommend reading "Cities and Ambition" (http://www.paulgraham.com/cities.html http://www.paulgraham.com/cities.html) for more context. I guess what I'm trying to say is that the old Chinese proverb "Give a man a fish and you feed him for a day; teach a man to fish and you feed him for a lifetime." is true when it comes to creating opportunity. It's not a "point in time", but a continuous problem.
- MickerNews 7y agoThis won't go down well with the temporarily embarrassed Donald Trumps on this website.
- dang 7y agoWould you please stop posting unsubstantive comments and/or flamebait here? https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- 18pfsmt 7y agoCan you explain why this comment is flagged? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20545221 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20545221 I feel like I'm taking crazy pills of late. I understand you all may be dealing with unprecedented volume, but I hope you can address egregious ridiculousness when it occurs. I'm willing to acknowledge my shortcomings (I have many), but I would like to understand the fundamental errors of my ways.
- iamleppert 7y agoIt’s 100% true. At this point in my tech career, I could start a company, but how am I going to support myself while that company is getting off the ground? I’ve worked for startups most of my career and all the founders are the same: rich and/or came from Stanford or MIT. Most have been mediocre at tech at best (that’s why they hire me) and have been poor business people and poor managers. There’s nothing special about them except they have all come from money. Not a single one was the bootstrap rags to riches story. I know those are out there but don’t let them fool you: at least in the Bay Area tech startups (if you want to be a founder) is a rich man’s game. This is based on my experience working for about 10 startups over about 15 years.
- csallen 7y ago> At this point in my tech career, I could start a company, but how am I going to support myself while that company is getting off the ground? You're a developer working at Bay Area tech companies? Move somewhere cheaper (or don't!) and take contract jobs. Set your own schedule, work 15 or 20 hours a week, and you'll be able to afford rent, even in expensive SF. Spend your free time starting your company. Alternatively, save up your money and take a year or two off. Source: I've successfully taken both approaches.
- iamleppert 7y agoIt’s not the point, the point is risk and opportunity cost. In order to “save up money” like you said means I need to make a lot of sacrifices in the here and now for a future risk. People with money don’t have to sacrifice. If the business fails, I’ll be out all that money and time that I can never get back. People with money may just have to trade in their Tesla for a Range Rover.
- csallen 7y agoOf course entrepreneurship requires risk-taking and sacrifices. I don't think anyone is surprised or upset by that. In fact, it'd be bizarre if there were any alternative to working full-time that we couldn't say the same about. It's not so different than, say, going back to college. But the fact is that many millions of average people can afford to make these sacrifices and take these risks. Your initial comment heavily implied that this is only something the rich can afford to do.
- WheelsAtLarge 7y agoI don't think people can really understand how risk-averse poverty can make a person. When you don't have a safety net or you've always had to struggle to get by it's very hard to take chances with money. Of course, there are exceptions but given poor vs rich, I would bet that entrepreneurs are more likely to appear in the population that never had to struggle to get by.
- augstein 7y agoI often think about this. If my parents (solid middle class) hadn‘t paid for my studies and if they wouldn’t have had the means to support me for the time after that, when I started a company which took about two years to sustain itself (and me), I would probably still crunch out code somewhere as a low level dev. Thanks mom and dad!
- MRD85 7y agoNeither of my parents finished high school and didn't value education but they did value hard work and they encouraged me to get a trade. I joined the military, got a trade there, and now in my early/mid 30's I'm completing a CS degree. Working for others isn't such a bad life if you have the drive to establish a life that you want for yourself.
- buboard 7y ago> in a 2013 paper, and found that most were white, male, and highly educated. > Research (paywall) looked at risk-taking in the stock market and found that environmental factors (not genetic) most influenced behavior how does one reach the conclusion of the title from these 2 very distinct data points? It's nonsense. Plus there is a very wrong causation argument being made for the first one. This is worse than clickbait
- aristophenes 7y agoThis article seems to be a "no true Scotsman" argument. The paper that it is based on, https://www.nber.org/papers/w19276.pdf https://www.nber.org/papers/w19276.pdf , divides entrepreneurs into two groups, those with incorporated businesses and those with unincorporated businesses. Then says those with unincorporated businesses don't count. And then draws conclusions about entrepreneurs based on only the incorporated ones. Of course unincorporated businesses are limited in size and complexity. Incorporated businesses are going to be made by people familiar with lawyers, business practices, etc. Businesses that require large amounts of capital are more likely to be incorporated. People who actually incorporate their business I suspect are more likely to have had a good education. So yes, if you exclude all the people who are just hustling along with all the mom and pop businesses, then it seems to be that richer people are what is left. The article also mentions that both incorporated and unincorporated entrepreneurs were more likely to engage in illicit activities in their youth. So it seems the lede of the article is not supported at all.
- bamboozled 7y agoI feel said type of founders having much less chance of becoming strong leaders. Anecdotally, I've worked with founders who have their parents wealth to fall back on take their position a lot less seriously than those who have nothing to go back to. The situation I mentioned creates a high friction situation sometimes, in which those who work under rich founder (without many prospects outside the company) start to actually take the potential for success seriously, while rich founder is oblivious to poor management and bad decisions having any serious implications for themselves longer term. It would be interesting to see a survey done on this actually, even more interesting would be to work for a company where consequences of action matter more.
- garchee 7y agoThe MANY entrepreneurs with broke immigrant parents (me included) would probably disagree. It doesn't hurt to come from money, and get a small loan of a million dollars, sure. But more important than that luck is being resilient and having stoic ideals, and that's something most Americans including the author of this article lack nowadays. It's very easy to constantly put yourself in a victim position and complain about how your life is harder than that of others, but that's mostly just self destructive as it wastes intellectual and mental energy you could instead spend on something more productive.
- BuckRogers 7y agoThis is mostly true but not always. I was given nothing from anyone, and had an extremely hands off manner of being raised. Meaning I was taught nothing and given no encouragement. I definitely would've been in a gang if I had been born in a big city as I was very aggressive and a tough kid. Thankfully I was from a small town, and my excellent community saved me. That said it took me until I was 36 to have the money to take any entrepreneurial leaps. It took me that long to save up enough money. Working in bad conditions that most kids with money would never put up with. I'm not special in any way except my character is rare, resilient. I wouldn't join in being resentful towards rich kids but I do recognize the need to force the wealthy to pay a lot more in taxes to give others like me and the worse off, a chance to succeed. That's what we all owe to the society that enabled our wealth. Some owe more than others, as their wealth increases.