9 ms·
>> “There is NO MORAL ISSUE with stealing from a store that forces you to use self checkout, period. THEY ARE CHARGING YOU TO WORK AT THEIR STORE.” I find the
by YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago
>> “There is NO MORAL ISSUE with stealing from a store that forces you to use self checkout, period. THEY ARE CHARGING YOU TO WORK AT THEIR STORE.”
I find the twisted reasoning in this comment shocking and I don't really know what to say. It is a kind of twisted reasoning that I've only seen in people who were high on strong narcotics and were carried away by waves of wishful thinking and delusions, or, again, extreme persecution complex.
Yes- it is possible to make this connection: that because you are scanning your own shopping you are being charged to work at the store. However, you are not being charged to scan your items. You are charged to buy the items you scan. There is no extra charge for using the self-checkout (not anywhere I know of anyway). Indeed, the store may be making an extra profit by not having to pay as many cashiers. But, stores are always finding ways to make extra profit, for example by offering you a discount on certain items, on certain days, etc. Are you more morally justified than usual to shoplift because a store has a discount on Swiss cheese this week? They are making you pick up the swiss cheese and take it to the till (automated or not). Are they charging you to move items around the store?
Like I say- this makes no sense. It is quintessential procrustean logic: stretching and reducing the meaning of words until they fit your preconceived reasoning.
P.S. I spent so much time on this crap instead of dismissing it shallowly because dang gets sad when people don't show intellectual cuiriosity.
- mindslight 7y agoAlternatively, it's revealing a deeper truth that had been obscured by a long chain of seemingly logical justifications. Corporations tend to abuse abstractions until they break, and self-checkout is basically at that breaking point. Comedy is especially good at deflating bullshit like this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FxINJzqzn4w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FxINJzqzn4w I for one could never stand the things for their slow and obtuse programming. I cannot get how people just accept slowly following a machine in lockstep, rather than the machine being designed to accommodate a natural human workflow. Back when the things were new, they would give out freebies by deciding to flip out and void the last few items, without the conveyor actually bringing them all back. I certainly wasn't going to go out of my way to correct its error, setting myself back even further. At this point I just skip the frustrating things out of personal policy, and outright avoid stores that punish customers for doing so (Walmart being the worst offender). If I can't stand an extra 5 minutes in line for the professional cashier, I should order online or simply stock up and visit less.
- Mediterraneo10 7y agoI don't share the thinking behind that comedy bit at all. For me, self-service checkouts offer such added utility -- no tiresome social interaction with the cashier, no awkward moments when shopping in a country where you don't speak the language -- that it more than makes up for the burden of ringing up my purchases.
- mindslight 7y agoI'm glad you get personal utility from the new method, but the rant is coming from a place where people are forced to use self checkouts and would rather not - eg stores where they shut all but one staffed register, creating a huge line.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoThat's more of a problem. In Europe the self-check outs are optional. They're also faster, because there isn't much of a queue and the people with carts all go to cashiers. I don't feel oppressed when I use them because I appreciate the speed. If that advantage disappeared, I'd be less pleased.
- nickpsecurity 7y agoI'm in the Mid-South around Tennessee, Mississippi, and Arkansas. They did exactly what parent described to push self-checkouts. Many people down here like a personal touch in their orders. Some percentage prefer to use self-checkouts to get out faster or not have to interact with people as much. The stores with self-checkout tried to cut staff forcing the majority of customers to use them to bypass the artificially-long lines. They tried to justify that with it was better or industry was just too competitive to afford cashiers (except at places that still had them). The recent push is to add even more with Walmart designing theirs to make people move through more like cattle. The other thing with those down here is they have a weight-based security scale with high number of false positives. Combine that with 4-6 machines constantly having them to get some unhappy customers. Also, those at Walmart and Kroger often have coupons or other issues that require attendants. Sometimes customers will argue with them wanting things checked. This might take a lot of time. Now, we have 4-12 or something people all waiting on one person due to one person. Then, some get irritated about what order they're served in when the attendant gets back. Way worse experience than at a register with a few people in line. I'm fine with self-checkouts or registers. I prefer to have options, though, like you said in your comment. I'm good at reading the situation to determine which will be faster. When they force me, I just go somewhere else to spite them unless they got me locked in with an exclusive item or deal(s) worth the time. The oligopolies let them do that here and there.
- matz1 7y agoI'm more supportive if they say no moral issue because they deemed stealing is morally right. Moral is subjective so if they said that then to me there is no issue with the reasoning.
- mc32 7y agoObviously they’d rather the company hire more workers and charge them s little extra. At least in some parts of the countryside it’s nice to see farmers’ stands with produce and a pay jar where people “self checkout”. I ack that companies take advantage of people but that does not grant people a right to be dishonest themselves and become that which they bemoan. If you think they’re ripping you off, go to the the market that offers full service.
- mb_72 7y ago> Obviously they’d rather the company hire more workers and charge them s little extra. It's happened the other way around - self checkout didn't exist, and when it was introduced prices didn't drop even though employment expenses are now lower. There isn't even an incentivising discount for using the self-checkout. I've seen people have no end of problems with self-checkout systems, and would rather I have an experienced and 'expert' human dealing with the scanning and check-out part that I can also interact with.
- lozenge 7y agoGroceries are the most low margin retail business at 1-2 percent. So the cost savings have definitely been passed on to the customer, unless you can find figures to the contrary.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoBy "the cost savings have been passed on to the customer", do you mean that a) self-checkout has caused the customer to pay more for groceries, or that b) the cost of groceries has remained the same (or decreased), but now the store makes extra profits from it because they don't have to pay as many clerks? If b) then we're back to where I started: you might as well complain about the discount on Swiss cheese. You don't pay more for youg goods, you may even pay less- but the store is making more money anyway. I won't say "where is the harm in that" because there is certainly harm to the clerks- but that is a separate issue from the extreme stretching of reason to justify shoplifting in the passage I commented on.
- nickpsecurity 7y ago"It is a kind of twisted reasoning " Although I disagree with it, I do understand the logic behind it. The companies doing this are usually capitalist, not virtue-driven. They don't care about morals, laws, etc. They screw over their customers in any way they can get away with. They also do things that cause their customers problems but lie to them about the reasons. Self-checkouts make the customer experience worse for most (not all) customers. When they add them, they usually do a staff cut followed by telling self-checkout workers to push customers to check themselves out. Nothing is given in return for the extra hardship. It's just a middle finger to the customers that made them the money to buy the machines (or invest in better customer experience) in the first place. So, some are following that "do whatever I can get away with that's in my self interest" mentality giving them the middle finger back. Funny enough, in my area, most of these companies with poor security in their self-checkouts are nickle and diming the people that run them on top of increasing the number of machines they watch or side jobs they have to do on top of self-checkout. I had to wait a few minutes earlier today for my self-checkout clerk to stop bagging at a register to fix a problem on my self-checkout. Needless to say, that kind of crap just adds to opportunities for people stealing or just walking out to buy their stuff somewhere with fast-moving people at registers. I've done the latter many times since a trip to convenience store was faster than the lines at similar prices. I'd be more outraged if it was someone ripping off Publix, Costco, or Aldi.
- SantalBlush 7y agoI don't shoplift, but I'm appalled at the double standards that are often applied to consumers and workers compared with large companies. Amazon is selling counterfeit products to unwitting shoppers across the United States. Large firms like this do not subject themselves to any code of ethics like we do; there is only the risk of getting penalized. Yet their business models are reliant on us acting ethically. It is one big scam that preys on human decency, so I really don't blame someone for taking extra fruit at the self-checkout after doing a cost-benefit analysis and making the profitable choice.
- optimiz3 7y agoTwo wrongs don't make a right. Trying to not leave the world a worse place at the end of the day means not taking extra fruit at the self-checkout.
- aey 7y agoIf you believe a corporation to be evil, then every possible act against them might be justifiable. This is a question of ethics. What is the right behavior to resist evil? For example, you could follow our own governments guide :) https://www.cia.gov/news-information/featured-story-archive/2012-featured-story-archive/simple-sabotage.html https://www.cia.gov/news-information/featured-story-archive/...
- koolba 7y agoSo Amazon profiting from knockoffs means you can steal bananas from Kroger’s?
- ratsmack 7y agoThe problem seems to be a general lack of morals... regardless of some perceived justification.
- SantalBlush 7y agoIf Amazon is not held accountable for fraudulent business practices, is it ethical to hold a shoplifter accountable? The answer, in my mind, is that it is not only not ethical to do so, but it is grossly unethical to do so.
- Sojuwa 7y ago>stealing is immoral Can we chill with the lowkey racism? It's real privilege to not need to steal, to not have theft be a right of passage, to have the impulse control/foresight to not steal. It's kind of sick to say you're better than that, ignoring DNA privileges.
- kranner 7y ago> It is a kind of twisted reasoning that I've only seen in people who were high on strong narcotics and were carried away by waves of wishful thinking and delusions, or, again, extreme persecution complex I really don't see the relation between delusional thinking and consuming narcotics. Can you explain what you mean? I've seen people high on narcotics; they seem loopy and sleepy, but not particularly susceptible to fallacious reasoning.
- mcherm 7y agoI believe the connection is that people addicted to narcotics are famously insistent about self justification, even when it is obviously baseless.
- kranner 7y agoMore so than for other forms of addiction? And this doesn't even seem related to their addiction.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoMy experience with people on drugs is that their ability to make a correct judgement in any situation diminishes drastically. For example, many of my friends would see cops everywhere after smoking weed (edit: secret cops, in civilian clothes. See how well they hide among us?). Another friend would always misplace her stuff, then start suspecting whoever was with her of stealing them (e.g. she would think I stole her baccy, though I don't smoke, etc). A friend of mine who was a heroin addict (and died of it at the ripe old age of 34) used to tell me how heroine makes you sociable and friendly, but my experience was that when he shot, he would just fall asleep and then be too smashed to be anything like sociable. But in his head he was the soul of the party. I've also known a fair few people who developed some kind of paranoid delusion most likely as a result of doing too many drugs. For example, I had a friend who thought one of his pals' brother was a hitman sent by the secret services to kill him. When he was sober, he was OK, most of the time, but when he was under- you couldn't make sense of him. I mean, let's face it. You don't take drugs because they make you smarter.
- conception 7y agoI wonder if this person siphons gas or steals candy from self serve gas stations as well. People are tremendously bad at change.
- sfthrower89 7y ago> I find the twisted reasoning in this comment shocking and I don't really know what to say. It is a kind of twisted reasoning that I've only seen in people who were high on strong narcotics and were carried away by waves of wishful thinking and delusions, or, again, extreme persecution complex. I'm curious how something that is entirely a flamewar gets so many upvotes? Where's @dang with their admonishments?
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoI can see your point. After all, the original comment has BLOCK CAPITALS screaming- always a tell-tale sign of a rant on the internets. Maybe I should have refrained from commenting on it at all. But, I'm actually really interested in the ways that we delude ourselves, particularly on issues of morality (but not only). It's an itch I can only resist scratching with great difficulty. If I ever manage to get my PhD I might even throw some papers at the problem (of figuring out when we are taking bad decisions based on bad reasoning). Sorry if all this makes you unhappy.
- tinus_hn 7y agoSounds like a comment from the Shoplifting reddit which was full of people proudly showing the things they stole and posting excuses why them being a thief is someone else’s fault. It’s since been closed.
- kalleboo 7y ago> They are making you pick up the swiss cheese and take it to the till (automated or not). Are they charging you to move items around the store? Until the Piggly Wiggly supermarket introduced the self-serve concept in 1916, you would go up to a counter and tell a clerk what food items you wanted, and they would get them for you. So your analogy really is the 1920's version of the self-checkout!
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoThanks- I had no idea. Another comment under this post made a similar point and I was wondering about it.
- tempguy9999 7y agoI didn't know this, thanks! However it reminds me of something similar that happened ~25 years ago in a UK town where I lived. We had a long power cut that went on for many days. The supermarkets shut at first because, why not. As things went on they had customers to serve so they had to sell, I remember that tesco set up a table at the store entrance with the shop manager and a few assistants. You told them what you wanted, the assistants got it. They took cash only [0]. It worked. Tangential to the article, what would happen today? People are carrying much(?) less cash, card only point of sales terminals are blooming, I just 2 days ago went to top up a spare mobile phone and the vodaphone store told me they'd no longer take cash. Notes & coins don't need electricity to be acceptable. We may be creating a very fragile alternative because things like comms and power look increasingly reliable so why lean on them ever harder, but they will go down someday, that I guarantee, and the harder we lean on these things, they harder they will drop us when they vanish. And we may have short power cuts due to human nature but there are things like solar storms. We know they are coming but aren't prepared for them. So what then? [0] which they must have got from somewhere. I don't remember how the banks were operating.
- mindslight 7y agoFor quite some time, stores did retain the ability to run offline carbon-copy based credit card transactions. I've definitely seen this occur more recently than one would imagine, at least within the past decade. I don't know if this is still a thing, as cards are no longer coming with the raised characters required to take an imprint. But perhaps the imprint is no longer necessary, and simply writing the information suffices. There are (obviously) more avenues for fraud without online verification, but the techniques of fraudsters are no longer optimized for running physical cards either. The more significant thing that we've lost is a cashier/manager being able to exercise some level of intelligent oversight to judge whether a transaction is likely to be fraudulent. But then again, perhaps a store being cleaned out of its entire inventory of eg Tide because of a long term power outage isn't that big of a deal either.
- southerntofu 7y ago> I find the twisted reasoning in this comment shocking and I don't really know what to say. You don't know what to say because saying shoplifting is moral (under some conditions) goes against the central belief you were raised with all your life: private property. But following an ethics based on social equality, you realize that in many situations self-discouting (autoréduction) is the just thing to do. We live in a world of money and private property. These ever-invasive tools of injustice are actually based on institutionalized theft. The land you work you don't "own". The house you live in you don't "own". The programs/websites you build you don't "own". So usage-based property (the oldest and only "natural" form of property) is out of the equation because society's belief in a piece of paper (a property title) dispossessed you from what you need/use. So in this equation, we realize what we need (that has no price) was taken away from us by private property. When we take a look at the production/supply chain, we can follow the money to see who benefits from this worldwide scam. Take food: food costs little-to-nothing to grow (unless you do it with chemicals, which you should never), so it's a good sample of how a capitalist system behaves. Food you find in supermarkets is grown by farmers. Their production is bought by logistics giants who will take it to supermarkets, or to logistics hubs run by supermarket chains. For supermarket chains (not small shops), it is rare to have more intermediates than this. Yet, even with so few middlepersons, retail prices can be 5 times or even 10 times what the farmer was paid for the product. Here in France, we typically pay 2-6€/kg of vegetables in supermarkets (farmers markets are cheaper), while the farm gets paid typically less than a euro (with some exceptions for luxury produce). So where does the money go? The middlepersons are an obvious answer. But supermarket owners are also responsible for the high prices of food. So in the end, supermarkets are just the place where common people come to spend all their money to survive, while the person making the food can't pay their bills and is pushed slowly towards suicide (very common among farmers working for the industry). Can we call this "moral"? To me it sounds a lot like any other definition of slavery: working a lot to just earn your right to live and help other people be exploited. Coming from this economic analysis, i believe anything you need you should steal from the rich and the powerful. We need to dismantle these people and their systems of oppression before they complete the destruction of our planet (they will never stop until then). That's not to say that stealing is a moral way of life under every circumstance. But before i steal something, i ask myself these two questions: - Is it a necessity or a nicety? (niceties-stealing is just another form of consumptionism) - Am i stealing from a rich person or from a poor/working person? (in a supermarket, you're stealing from rich shareholders; in a smallshop, you're stealing from your neighbor's work, who themselves get ripped off by surrounding capitalist structures) I know many people among you will not understand or approve my way of thinking. I'm not here to try and convince you. But you should understand that commerce and private property are not inherent aspects of humanity and that stealing is most times a necessity. Therefore stealing from the rich does not come from a delusion, but from the realization that the rules of the game are rigged and we need direct action to bring justice to the table. P.S. I spent so much time on this crap instead of dismissing it shallowly because dang gets sad when people don't show intellectual cuiriosity ;)