8 ms·
Fannie Mae Unix Engineer Gets 41 Months for Planting Logic Bomb
- jarin 16y agoWhile it will probably always be hard to stop inside-man attacks, it will probably always be easy to do backups :)
- shashank261 16y agoJust imagine if that guy had been successful. Americans would have been debt free!!
- endtime 16y agoYou think that debt wasn't leveraged? You think people can just not pay back loans and no one gets hurt?
- cabalamat 16y agoThe way the US economic/legal system works is that banks can just not pay their debts and the banks' owners don't get hurt. If debts owed by banks aren't legally enforceable, debts owed to banks shouldn't be either. To put it another way, limited liability, if it exists, should go both ways.
- mdp 16y agoYeah it's easy, just convince everyone you're too big to fail and have the American taxpayer pay it off.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- InclinedPlane 16y agoNope. There are plenty of backup records for all of the debts. Physical records of deeds, contracts, etc. And it's possible much of the data could have been restored through backups and data retrieval methods. What this would have caused would be delays and difficulties in handling existing mortgages but the biggest impact would have likely been an inability of people to apply for new mortgages using fanny mae, which is hardly a win for anybody.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoIn retrospect, it probably would have been a good thing.
- zitterbewegung 16y agoActually what would happen is taxpayers would have to pay more to recover the data and go through the physical copies. So in reality we would be in more debt. Life isn't Fight club. (Movie not book)
- thenbrent 16y agoAnd as Fannie Mae provided the inside-man with root access to all the main systems, it was apparently just as easy to destroy the backups. Edit: also in reference to this comment: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2054679 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2054679
- InclinedPlane 16y agoIf root access to systems lets you destroy backups then they cannot rightly be considered backups.
- amackera 16y agoThe Tao of Backup: http://www.taobackup.com/ http://www.taobackup.com/
- stcredzero 16y agoAlso, while it will probably always be easy to accomplish inside-man attacks, it will also be generally harder to get away with them than you might think. (Especially if real money is involved!)
- grantbachman 16y agoMost of my student loans were issued by them, if only the logic bomb had executed and destroyed my loan data...
- mahmud 16y agoYou would be debt-free for the 48 minutes it takes to restore from backups.
- jser 16y agosallie mae = student loans. fannie mae and freddie mac are home mortgage only.
- amackera 16y agoDid all the financial institutions in the States get together to come up with the most ridiculous sounding names?
- portman 16y agoThey're attempts to phonetically sound out the acronym. FNMA = Federal National Mortgage Association = "Fannie Mae" SLMA = Student Loan Marketing Association = "Sallie Mae"
- miniatureape 16y agoAttempts that gives them "folksy" small-bank sounding names.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- patio11 16y agoThose taxpayer subsidized loans to get you an engineering degree are such shackles...
- deleted 16y ago
- bugsy 16y ago"the malware was designed to spread throughout the Fannie Mae network of computers and destroy all data, including financial, securities and mortgage information" Not really malware though, that sounds like a good thing.
- michaelty 16y ago"the malware was designed to spread throughout the Fannie Mae network of computers and destroy all data, including financial, securities and mortgage information" Sounds like a prototype for the toxic mortgage derivatives spreading throughout the banking system.
- catshirt 16y agoWhat would the actual consequences have been had it worked?
- blinkingled 16y ago5000 Servers. A "Senior Engineer" discovered this script. Probably it was a cron job or something which they review regularly? Would be useful to know how exactly they got to that one script. Must have real good review practices , audits and logging in place if they were able to find it before it did the damage and then collect evidence to trace it back to the perpetrator.
- btn 16y agoAccording to an article about the indictment, it was discovered by chance: "It was only by chance that [the Fannie Mae engineer] scrolled down to the bottom of the legitimate script to discover the malicious script" http://www.computerworld.com/s/article/9127040/Fannie_Mae_engineer_indicted_for_planting_server_bomb http://www.computerworld.com/s/article/9127040/Fannie_Mae_en...
- pedanticfreak 16y agoMore detail from the above article: [quote] If the malicious script had gone undiscovered, it would have disabled monitoring alerts and all log-ins, deleted the root passwords to the approximately 4,000 Fannie Mae servers, then erased all data and backup data on those servers by overwriting with zeros. "Finally, this script would power off all servers, disabling the ability to remotely turn on a server," said the government's complaint. "Subsequently, the only way to turn the servers back on was physically getting to a data center." [/quote]
- blantonl 16y agoDoes anyone know what the actual "logic bomb" consisted of? My money is on a crontab that executed a simple set of ssh command attacks on the specified date. As per the article, to destroy "all data, including financial, securities and mortgage information," it would be as simple as an "rm -rf" across multiple servers. Except for one critical item, he would have to have root access on all those servers. Either the scope of his potential damage was very small, or Fannie Mae had some terrible security and change management policies in place. I cannot decide which to pick.
- blinkingled 16y agoMore info here - http://news.softpedia.com/news/Rogue-IT-admin-Close-to-Shutting-Down-Mortgage-Giant-103292.shtml http://news.softpedia.com/news/Rogue-IT-admin-Close-to-Shutt...
- pyre 16y agoThe choice bits: > During this time Makwana had root access to all of the main > systems, credentials which the company failed to revoke until > the evening of the day of his layoff. > His intention was nothing short of replacing the entire financial > data, including the backups, from all of the company's production > servers, with zeroes. > the admin appended malicious code to a legitimate script, leaving > a page-worth of blank lines between the two in order to avoid > detection. > Had this malicious script executed, engineers expect it would > have caused millions of dollars of damage and reduced if not > shutdown operations at Fannie Mae for at least one week.
- blantonl 16y agoDuring this time Makwana had root access to all of the main systems This quote above, and the entire article boggles the mind. I've worked with big and small organizations that protected root on <10 machines like it was the key to preventing aging.
- jrockway 16y agoNot sure this matters much. Most places I've worked have considered local root exploits not worth patching. So if you have a user account, you have root.
- cuppster 16y agoI'll take a mortgage-reduction bomb any day...
- mhansen 16y agoWe had a mortgage reduction bomb a while ago. It didn't work out well for very many people. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Financial_crisis_of_2007%E2%80%932010 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Financial_crisis_of_2007%E2%80%...
- shashank261 16y agoHow in the world can you stop that and why did the company have only 1 person handle such an important task?
- ja27 16y ago41 months seems exceptionally high given that it was discovered before execution. It would take me an hour to dig it all up, but there are federal sentencing guidelines based on the dollar amount of damages. I don't think they take potential damages into account.
- bobz 16y agoFunny, I came here looking for the exact opposite post to upvote. Seems exceptionally low to me, given the obvious malicious intent and potential damages. But I'm mostly ignorant about the relevant law.
- martincmartin 16y agoI assume you mean relative to other sentences/crimes you're aware of? It may be low compared to those, but in general, American sentences seem exceptionally high to me, and this is a good example. I don't think a stronger sentence would have deterred him. I doubt he sat down and thought "If I get caught, I'll only get 3 1/2 years, which isn't too bad. Now, if I would get 10 years, that's another story..." I doubt he even knew the specific penalties for doing this. It seems to me he assumed he'd never get caught. I think others reading this article will be deterred by the thought of losing 3 1/2 years of their life, and having their life after prison ruined in many ways. For example, try to explain a 3 1/2 year gap in your employment history during a job interview. And for the ones who aren't, I don't think a 10 year sentence would somehow deter them. I don't think this guy is likely to commit another such crime after his release. I doubt he figures that 3 1/2 years in jail and putting his life back together isn't that big a deal and planting another logic bomb feels so good that it's worth it to do it again. The only other motivation for punishing a crime is vengeance, an emotional feeling of hurting someone who tried to hurt us. That seems a poor motivation for taking away even more of someone's life. He did something malicious that could have caused a lot of problems. He needs to be punished. But the punishment seems way out of proportion to what's needed to reduce crime.
- troels 16y agoFor completeness' sake, there is a third reason for incarceration - The prisoner can't commit new crimes while detained. Not that it matters in this case. I otherwise fully agree with your sentiments.
- known 16y agoActually it s very easy to plant a logic bomb using http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bit_twiddler http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bit_twiddler
- alanh 16y agoHe added malicious scripts to the bottom of a legitimate one? I have seen Wordpress hacks obfuscate themselves ten times as cleverly. For example, by eval()ing rot13(), gzipped, and base64()'d code included from a file with a legitimate-looking name.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- Aegean 16y agoWe don't know the whole story but if you hold that much grudge in yourself this is how you end up. Bad karma brought him bad karma.
- hermanthegerman 16y agoHow did they prove in court that it was planted there by him ? After he gave his laptop away, everything could have happened to it. Maybe just a cheap trick to punish him for something they couldnt 'prove'.
- manche 16y agoRemind me again, how many months did the Fannie Mae executives get for bombing the economy?