4 ms·
> Safety regulations are a completely different beast. Only they're not. If you impose a billion dollars in fixed regulatory burden then you can no longer have
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
> Safety regulations are a completely different beast.
Only they're not. If you impose a billion dollars in fixed regulatory burden then you can no longer have sub-billion dollar companies.
But lack of competition erodes everything -- even the safety rules, because bigger companies are more capable of capturing regulators.
Any regulation which is the direct cause of a lack of effective competition is doing more harm than good.
> That doesn’t mean safety regulation is necessarily good or that deregulation couldn’t be helpful sometimes. But the actual track record in recent decades is completely contrary to this idea of decreasing regulation providing better results.
That's kind of the point. The entire frame of "regulation bad / deregulation bad" is a farce. What you actually need is regulation that maximizes the ratio of benefits to regulatory burdens. That means removing burdensome and ineffective regulations and having efficient and effective ones.
But evaluating regulatory efficiency and effectiveness is dry and non-partisan. Framing it as "we need more regulation" is failing before you even begin.
This 737 MAX debacle is a case in point. It came about because Boeing was trying to avoid the high costs of recertification, so they didn't change things that could have made the plane safer because changing them would have required recertification.
So we have "safety regulations" negatively impacting safety by making it move expensive to improve safety than not. That's not a case of needing more overall regulation or less overall regulation, it's a case of needing to replace worse rules with better rules. The ideal outcome is that the net regulatory burden becomes lower and as a result it becomes less expensive to make changes that improve safety.
- mikeash 7y agoIn theory, all regulations need to be carefully considered and walk a fine line in order to do more good than harm. But I was replying to a pair of comments talking about the practical history of regulations over the past few decades. That history diverges wildly for the two types of regulation. Economic regulation was massively lightened, resulting in huge benefits. At the same time, safety regulations for airplanes and cars were massively increased, also resulting in huge benefits. So, yes, the whole point is that “regulations good/bad/anything” is nonsense, as the recent history of economic and safety regulations illustrates.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoWhat I'm getting at is that the types of regulation don't really have anything to do with it. It's not that all safety regulation is good and all economic regulation is bad (though if you wanted someone to disprove "all economic regulation is bad" you might be in for a wait). You can screw up safety regulations just as bad if you're not careful. It's also difficult to evaluate these things based on statistical trends, because it's easy to pass a safety regulation that e.g. mandates a specific safety method, and then you get an immediate safety improvement by making that state of the art method universal, but as time passes that ossified requirement becomes stale and prevents newer, better methods from replacing it. And all you see in the numbers is the improvement from the original mandate spreading through the installed base over time, not the comparison to what would have happened when something even better was invented a year later but was prohibited by the rule from being deployed. (As evidence for this, the original 737 was introduced prior to the moon landing.) It's also problematic to look only at the one target. If we improve aircraft safety per mile but only by making aircraft more expensive (or destroying competition, which does the same thing), that makes flying less competitive against alternatives that are much more dangerous, like driving. So you can get a safety improvement on paper even though the result is more people are killed. That doesn't mean you can't make a rule that actually improves safety, but it's harder than it seems to get it right.
- mikeash 7y agoSure. I’m just saying that the actual history of the past few decades in the US shows a stark contrast with these two types of regulations in terms of how they worked and the consequences they had. Regarding measures that appear to improve safety but are actually a net loss because it encourages driving instead, the FAA does evaluate regulations this way. For example, this is why infants aren’t required to be in a child seat and are allowed to just be held by a parent. They determined that this requirement would cause more families to drive due to the extra cost, and the result would be a net loss of life.
- jaclaz 7y ago>In theory, all regulations need to be carefully considered and walk a fine line in order to do more good than harm. Yes, and one of the possible definitions of a (technical, safety related) regulation is "the added cost that the society is reasonably willing (or capable) to pay for a reasonable increase in safety" The issues always revolve around how much the "reasonably willing to pay" is and what is the corresponding "reasonable" increase in safety (and how exactly to measure the latter).
- danmaz74 7y agoAirlines are forced to certificate their pilots for the plane they're going to fly. How many lives have been saved by this regulation, in comparison with those which were lost because Boeing tried to cheat at said regulation? Ignoring that is the same as pointing to people killed by airbags, without considering those saved by them.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoThat's the false dichotomy again. One example of a third way would be that when a plane is 97% the same as one you're certified on, have something between no and full recertification which is only 3% as time consuming because it only covers the differences between the planes instead of going back to square one.
- danmaz74 7y agoI'm all for having good regulations. The dichotomy comes from those which say that all deregulation is good (which implies that all regulation is bad). In this specific case, though, I suspect that measuring the "X% the same", and what the new training should be, is much more difficult than it looks at a first glance.
- breatheoften 7y agoI think you are also guilty of over constraining the solution space ... airlines want a new more fuel efficient plane with a certain size and passenger carrying capacity. Building a new plane for this need either involves training pilots on this new plane type or inherently unsafe engineering to deliver the new product without requiring the pilot retraining expense. You suggest that we should sacrifice the rigor of pilot training to allow delivering planes without safety compromises ... I think there’s absolutely no justification for safety compromise in this scenario - the new plane will pay for retraining costs in a slightly longer amount of time than it would’ve had retraining not been required — oh well. That’s the cost of doing business and it’s absolutely without doubt that in this case - designing a plane that wasn’t inherently flawed would’ve been a better strategy for Boeing and for all of their 737 Max customers ... The real question to learn from this tragedy is not how can we make it slightly less expensive to produce a new air frame — it’s how can we ensure that safety is not allowed to be compromised during the design phase of new passenger aircraft in service of _truly_ minor cost savings ... if we had a real regulator that was not captured - they should’ve had the flexibility to say no to the 737 Max very very early in the proposal process — and if necessary they should’ve been allowed to offer a tax incentive to offset some of the pilot retraining cost required by them not budging on safety requirements. Building and deploying safe airplanes into real world use is more expensive than building unsafe airplanes — but that doesn’t mean it’s not worth the cost to society...
- kjar 7y agoIf I interpreted this argument correctly - regulation is bad, costs money. How much is a human life worth? Clear to me is that Boeing did that sick math and rolled the dice and F’d up royally and fatally. FAA was gamed, but If you think Boeing would self regulate, I think you are on a different timeline where stockholder dividends are not the prime directive.
- wbl 7y agoDo you think Boeing owners would like it if no one bought Boeing planes because of safety concerns? Of course not.
- PeterStuer 7y agoThey might not 'like' it but they might not care enough as long as the stock goes up and the dividends keep flowing. The regulation should be there to prevent the erosion of certain boundaries, the eternalization of certain costs and the eventual public recovery of the profits. Like most of the neoliberale 'economic theoretical models', the idea that the regulation is fully separated from the arena of the competition and thus cannot be captured and coopted is so ludicrous it begs the question how it ever became more than a joke in a b-list standup comedian's backup repertoire.
- wbl 7y agoThe dividends would not flow if no one ordered the plane.
- PeterStuer 7y agoPlanes are ordered because companies hope they can make a profit operating them (the hope is important, it does not necessarily mean they can). Which planes they order depends on many factors other than safety. Costs and risks of accidents are externalized through insurance, executive and shareholder indemnification and. as a last resort. bankruptcy. Then again, if they are seen as 'strategically relevant', or have the right connections, they can rest assured they will not have to pull in the 'last resort and will be bailed out of any troubles. A German automaker was caught gassing the world population. They're still around, even having the audacity not to even change the brand name.
- qarlow 7y agoSafety regulation might be a burden for aircraft manufacturers, but it is what enables competition among airlines. The reason we can have low cost airlines are because safety isn't really in question. Of course you want to "optimize" regulation, but deregulation as in leaving it up to the participants frequently can't support a competitive market.
- phs318u 7y ago> So we have "safety regulations" negatively impacting safety No we don’t. Other companies have followed the regulations. Boeing chose to value cost avoidance over risk to human life. The owners and management of Boeing are culpable.
- markdown 7y ago> That means removing burdensome and ineffective regulations and having efficient and effective ones. When we're talking about human lives, there is no regulation too burdensome or inefficient. And your argument about there being too little competition is a little odd since hundred have been killed in two crashes because of competition. > It came about because Boeing was trying to avoid the high costs of recertification, so they didn't change things that could have made the plane safer because changing them would have required recertification. So we have "safety regulations" negatively impacting safety by making it move expensive to improve safety than not. That's absurd! The safety regulations were good, and the reason they didn't work is because the FAA hired Boeing to enforce them and Boeing didn't do so. Boeing only managed to flout the regulations because they fraudulently signed off their own planes as being airworthy. And the only reason Boeing got away with this is because they controlled the people in the FAA. Your argument appears to be that Boeing cheated to get around the regulations, so it would be better if there were no regulations, because then Boeing wouldn't have to cheat. American capitalists are truly a special breed of human.
- mikeash 7y ago“When we're talking about human lives, there is no regulation too burdensome or inefficient.” I recommend we ban all travel over five miles. This will eliminate all danger from air travel and substantially reduce traffic fatalities.
- pfdietz 7y ago"When we're talking about human lives, there is no regulation too burdensome or inefficient." This is not only not true, it directly contradicts how regulations are evaluated. Regulations are judged at the cost per life saved (or similar metrics), and are rejected if that cost is above some threshold. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_of_life#Policy_applications_of_the_VSL https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_of_life#Policy_applicati...
- cmurf 7y agoIt came about through short shortsightedness. The path they chose was in fact more expensive than the recertification cost. But even Boeing had come to dislike the regulatory paradigm they helped to create. I think most people are framing the regulatory paradigm as needing to revert to what we had, because clearly less regulation resulted in multiple bad outcomes. Based on available reporting, Boeing chose this path not to avoid higher cost, but reduced time to market to compete with Airbus because, again, shortsightedness, lack of innovation and planning, and even lack of imagination that their competitor would do exactly what they did, and had no contingency and no response for ~9 months after the Airbus 320neo announcement. I also can't take seriously any complaints about lack of competition in the U.S. market when it's so docile about competition law. The 1960's merger of McDonnell and Douglas is questionable, but the 1990's merger of McDonnel Douglas and Boeing directly lead to the loss of any remaining domestic competition in transport category aircraft. U.S. regulators are tacitly saying this is a natural monopoly, and yet should be regulated as if it's a competitive market.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoYeah, Boeing have made real clowns of themselves here. > I also can't take seriously any complaints about lack of competition in the U.S. market when it's so docile about competition law. The 1960's merger of McDonnell and Douglas is questionable, but the 1990's merger of McDonnel Douglas and Boeing directly lead to the loss of any remaining domestic competition in transport category aircraft. U.S. regulators are tacitly saying this is a natural monopoly, and yet should be regulated as if it's a competitive market. You're discounting the competition between Boeing and Airbus. They're clearly not a monopoly. That said, it's possible to have two sets of bad rules at once, and it's even worse in that case. Then you get antitrust regulators approving mergers while industry regulators impose high barriers to entry, so that you get high consolidation with no way to break it because no one new will ever enter the industry. Sadly that seems to be the status quo in multiple industries now. You have antitrust approving any merger that doesn't result in a literal monopoly even if there are only two or three companies left, meanwhile those companies practically ask the government for regulations that make sure nobody else can ever come up behind them because it takes a nation-scale company to survive the compliance costs.