4 ms·
Should probably add a (2013) to this title. But yeah, I'm running the iOS13 beta, and one of the things it does it warn you if an app is trying to use bluetoot
by jedberg 7y ago
Should probably add a (2013) to this title.
But yeah, I'm running the iOS13 beta, and one of the things it does it warn you if an app is trying to use bluetooth (other than audio). It's crazy how many apps request bluetooth access. Apps that definitely don't need it, other than to leak your location.
- RL_Quine 7y agoJust wait until apple adds a “recently accessed photos” list or better permissions. So many apps are going to be found to snarf photos due to the lax permissions.
- nexuist 7y agoI'm not sure what you mean by this. Uploading a user's entire photo album to some private cloud would be cost and time prohibitive. If I give an app access to my photos, it's generally because it's some kind of photo editing or social media app, and I would expect it to access my entire library since that's what I'm using it for. Apple already provides an alternative to the default photos permission: the photo picker UI. No app needs to request photos permission for that because it only returns the picture the user picked (or null if they canceled the dialog). I think that's a reasonable compromise.
- lxgr 7y agoA sufficiently malicious and well-funded app might perform on-device face recognition (which is getting hardware support on newer devices) and only upload the hashes.
- RL_Quine 7y agoI can imagine it’s very easy to scan the users photos for anything potentially of value and just steal that. Looking for skin tones would allow the theft of potentially sensitive images with low bandwidth and time budgets. Yahoo and others already have pornography detection suites for things like public forums. It should really be the only option for 99% of apps. The picker upload isn’t used much because app developers want to add their own chrome to image selection.
- BinaryIdiot 7y agoRight? I don't even understand when I should or shouldn't allow bluetooth access. Does this mean things won't work with my headphones? Almost all of my apps have requested it! I wish Apple did a little more user training as to _what_ this means instead of a generic "let app use bluetooth?"
- nexuist 7y agoJust default to saying no. If you find that something actually does break as a result, you can always switch permissions back on in the Privacy tab in settings. For certain permissions (i.e. location), Apple actually does require apps to provide a string indicating what the permission is needed for. I'm not sure if it's required for the Bluetooth permission, but my guess is that since it's a beta nobody has updated their binaries to include that string.
- jdnenej 7y agoOn android you have to request location access to scan for Bluetooth devices.
- unkleTohmCobley 7y agoThat is not true. I always disable location settings from all apps. yet I can pair BT devices without issue.
- JadeNB 7y ago> For certain permissions (i.e. location), Apple actually does require apps to provide a string indicating what the permission is needed for. Is the string in practice any more useful than update messages? (I wonder sometimes if anyone feels shame over 20 consecutive fixes with public-facing summary saying just "Stability and bug fixes." Apple itself is, of course, far from exempt.)
- nexuist 7y agoThe permission strings are moderated with far more scrutiny. If an App Store reviewer can't understand what the point of the permission is, they will reject your app.