4 ms·
Yes and no. There are __provably correct__ and __provably incorrect__ mathematical works. That strong binary classification is not found in "other art". But
by paulddraper 7y ago
Yes and no.
There are __provably correct__ and __provably incorrect__ mathematical works.
That strong binary classification is not found in "other art".
But otherwise, yes.
You might say mathematical proofs have characteristics of quality that once agreed upon, can be somewhat objectively applied: brevity, clarity, innovation, difficulty, relationships to other works.
While abstract art is famously arbitrary in its judgement, most art (dance, music, painting, sculpture) have similarly objective criteria.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoAbstract art isn't arbitrary in its judgement. This has been researched, and even people who say "My five year old could have done that" can tell the difference between the work of actual five year olds and very abstract smeary work by professional abstract artists. The rest is about form and content. There are certainly aesthetic form rules in most of the arts, but the real point of art is the content - emotional distillation of lived experience, psychological reflection, even social commentary and satire. Even terrible kitsch has some element of this, and the best art is very densely packed with it, A proof cannot be art because it has none of that subjective content. You can maybe - at a reach - apply the results of a proof in a social and political setting, or discover it has some relevance to psychology. But the proof itself is content-free.
- paulddraper 7y ago> the difference between the work of actual five year olds and very abstract smeary work by professional abstract artists. Or the difference between a professional and a monkey? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pierre_Brassau https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pierre_Brassau > the real point of art is the content - emotional distillation of lived experience, psychological reflection, even social commentary and satire. Is Symphony No. 5 really psychological reflection, social commentary, and satire? Or it is more accurately described as deeply, innately beautiful? A pleasurable combination of patterns, rhythms, and tones?