5 ms·
I am of the strong opinion that governments should have a finger on the scale to a much higher degree than rent control, with the desired effect of making ownin
by colechristensen 7y ago
I am of the strong opinion that governments should have a finger on the scale to a much higher degree than rent control, with the desired effect of making owning real estate somebody else uses a minimally attractive investment.
Control the rent by controlling the price of real estate by removing investors as competition for the purchase of land and buildings for home and business.
- munk-a 7y agoI think this general sort of approach is highly flawed due to the difficulty you'd find in allocating and expecting new property demand. I, personally, would love to see a working command economy and look forward to the day we can actually accomplish one though technology... but we're not quite there yet. In the mean time... I have difficulty pointing out specific reasons this always fails due to the weird involvement of racism in public housing in the US tainting my primary experience of such a system, but I believe it does have flaws even if implemented in a manner that isn't intentionally trying to ghettoize portions of a city.
- colechristensen 7y agoThere really isn't any difficulty in allocating resources. I'm talking about eliminating real estate investors, not property ownership by end-users. There would still be a fine market economy but it would be much less common for someone to be buying real estate they weren't intending to use themselves. Command economies are ridiculous because human nature. They aren't stable because they involve a small number of people being in control of resource allocation and the benefits for "cheating" and making those decisions to benefit yourself and your goals make it far too likely that the power will be abused.
- fzeroracer 7y agoAs a thought exercise, free markets exist on the basis of everyone behaving like a rational actor, working in their own self-interest which results in the market becoming more and more optimized. Mind you, I'm talking pure free market theory. This means if you were to consider renters, land owners etc within a free market, the rational option is to take actions which improve their lot. This may be short term solutions, but it's the result of people behaving in their own rational self-interest. If a city has 50+% of people renting; then they will take action to lower the costs of renting. Similarly, if a city has a large amount of people owning property, then people will take action to increase the value of their property. The only action to stop this would be...government intervention. Which means then the government is responsible for regulating the market against the whims of the people it's supposed to represent. In the case of renting and home ownership, I don't think a free market can ever truly exist.
- nostromo 7y agoYou want to make real estate cheaper by making it less desirable to investors. But if you made it less desirable to investors, they'd build less of it -- and you'd make the housing supply worse.
- colechristensen 7y agoInvestors aren't necessary to build housing. If you remove their drag on the economy (taking much more value than they give) there would be more capital ready and willing to build housing. You start removing investors from the housing economy then the capital flowing from workers pockets to landlords profits slow down and stop. Two effects there 1) The capital that was invested in real estate is going to be invested somewhere else. 2) The capital that was going to real estate returns is going to be invested somewhere else. 1 means more investment in business and R&D. 2 means more people have more discretionary spending, some of which would go to investing in real estate for their own uses.
- darawk 7y agoWho is going to build an apartment building aside from an investor?
- kyruzic 7y agoA group of interested buyers who could afford to find its construction if it weren't for investors driving prices sky high.
- nostromo 7y ago> A group of interested buyers ... so, investors.
- colechristensen 7y agoNo. You are not an investor if you're buying your own home to live in.
- amiga_500 7y agoYou do this by taxing land. Cannot be passed on to the renter as they are already paying the monopoly price. It just takes what was private profit and captures it for public spending.
- colechristensen 7y agoThat does not achieve the goal I had in mind. It keeps rent at the monopoly price and increases the cost to people who own and occupy land themselves.
- amiga_500 7y agoShould land not be priced correctly? The problem we have now is people laying claim to value they did not produce. This "money for nothing" situation increases demand for land a, exacerbating the supply issue. Land value tax would force better land use, and more efficiency means more for those in need.
- colechristensen 7y agoLand should be priced correctly in an environment that heavily penalizes lease revenue.
- amiga_500 7y agoso...land value tax! :-)
- colechristensen 7y agoNo, the key is the bias against investors vs. occupants. Land value tax does not accomplish this.
- malandrew 7y agoThey don't need to have their finger on the scale to a higher degree. They just need to remove the finger on the scale that makes housing an attractive investment.