3 ms·
A library is loaning you property, usually collateral-free. A corporation is just a placeholder essentially for the activities it will perform, each of which wi
by bdcravens 7y ago
A library is loaning you property, usually collateral-free. A corporation is just a placeholder essentially for the activities it will perform, each of which will likely have far more stringent requirements than a library card.
- lurquer 7y agoMoreover, the State collects a filing fee... That is, a library card grants you permission to borrow something from the State, while the Corp application entails you giving the State your money.
- GuiA 7y agoThis feels like post hoc rationalization. Read page 4 for an actual side by side comparison. You’ll see that all you really need to get a library card is present a form of identification, and perhaps a utility bill to prove your current address. Whereas for registering a corporation: ” No state requires any information about the person(s) who directly or indirectly own or control the company (often referred to as a beneficial owner)” ... along with many other similarly surprising statements that establish not even a low bar, but the absence of a bar at all. How does that make any sense when, as the report highlights, those shell corporations - that is corporations whose placeholder status is used in itself to realize some gain, and thus never have to meet “more stringent requirements” - can then be used for “tax evasion, shady campaign contributions, cigarette smuggling, and weapons dealing”?
- objectivetruth 7y agoAs the parent said, just setting up a Delaware corporation isn't going to be much protection for most criminal enterprises. If they want to, the ATF will get you for tobacco or gun smuggling whether you have Articles of Corporation or not. And in the US, to continue that example, there are multiple agencies and thousands of pages of regulations overseeing tax accounting and campaign finance. Sure, tons of shady shit still happens... but not because the criminals happened to file as an LLC instead of as sole proprietors.
- giancarlostoro 7y agoAlso why having a Library Card for certain IRS forms like an I-9 is a valid form of identity. Which at first I thought was crazy, but given this article, I suppose it's valid. I just hope all states make getting a Library Card complicated enough.
- Stratoscope 7y agoI don't see where a library card is valid for any of the three columns of the I-9: https://www.uscis.gov/i-9-central/acceptable-documents https://www.uscis.gov/i-9-central/acceptable-documents If I missed something, can you point me to it?
- giancarlostoro 7y agoAh I think I misread the form, I didn't use that as a proof but maybe I got confused with the School ID as a proof.
- anigbrowl 7y agoA library is not loaning you property, it is a public good which you already paid for and have a right to use, the administrative overhead is for the convenience of all library users. A corporation's activities are unknowable but not being a real person it is not entitled to an assumption of good faith and there is no particular right to create new legal entities. We should definitely know who the beneficial owners of any corporation are to reduce the potential for fraud.
- darkerside 7y ago> which you already paid for Unknowable without knowing who you actually are
- ghettoimp 7y agoCare to elaborate? Are you referring to taxpayers versus non-taxpayers, perhaps?
- freehunter 7y agoNot just taxpayers vs non-taxpayers, but WHERE you pay taxes. My taxes don’t pay for public libraries in other states or even other areas of my own state.
- ghettoimp 7y agoAha, that's a good point.
- optimiz3 7y agoOther people also have a right to use. How do you prevent the tragedy of the commons without knowing who has what?
- anigbrowl 7y agoI'm not arguing against library cards. I'm showing how any rhetorical argument can be deployed with equal facility in the opposite direction.
- Spooky23 7y agoA corporation creates a fictitious person. Allowing the beneficial interests to be hidden is disgusting and not compatible with a free market. Long ago, a corporate charter required an act of the state legislature to authorize it. Obviously that’s a heavy handed approach, but the idea that any agent of any person or other entity can anonymously create a company is ridiculous.
- jlawson 7y agoA corporation is not a fictitious person. You can't get a corporation a passport, or a welfare cheque, or enroll it in school. You can own and freely erase a corporation, you can't own or erase a person. A corporation is a legal entity which can engage in some of the same contracts as people can, because its entire purpose is to serve as a legal framework for organizing economic activity. In primitive societies, economic activities must be organized around flesh and blood people, like nobility. Corporations are much more flexible and efficient in achieving these aims. This legal structure, like many others, has massively improved human welfare since its invention by allowing people to pool and deploy resources and power in flexible ways. It beats depending on a rich guy to finance and organize everything himself. If having this legal status makes a corporation a person, a country would also have to be a fictitious person. So would the UN, and the EU, and the AU. So would every government agency and every province and state in every country. A whole world of fictitious people! Except they're not, any more than my dog is a child because she has a birth certificate and an immunization record, just like a child. Please, let's let this 'corporations are people' myth die.
- Spooky23 7y agoThe notion of an enterprise as a fictitious person is a well established idea that has existed since at least the Roman Empire. Many government entities are fictitious persons. All public authorities are, and many agencies. I’m unsure of how a sovereign state compares to a corporation legally. Your dog is entirely different. It is a chattel, or your personal property. Your dog has no agency, ownership of anything, etc.
- 7y ago
- yspeak 7y agoArticle is filled with misinformation. And to rail against the US as a whole displays either lack of knowledge or intent to push a political agenda which this clearly is. Corporate formation is state governed so each state law is different though usually similar. Corporate Directors and LLC managers are usually publicly disclosed. Ownership should never have to be disclosed as corporations by their nature are designed to allow ownership to be sold easily to raise capital so may change frequently. None of this has anything to do with taxes or legal compliance which is easily enforced as corporations have to have publicly disclosed registered agents to receive papers and theu lose in court if they don't show up. Most are one or two person companies organized to protect individual liability. Many set up for real estate to serve as vehicles for investment. Those that are public corporations are extremely transparent through SEC filings and shareholder rights. The agenda in this article is clearly to name, shame, tax,politicize, demonize, and socialize small and private businesses that drive the economy and employ the vast majority of the people in this country.