4 ms·
How difficult is it to build transmission lines in the US? In Germany we have enormous problems building a transmission line from the offshore windparks in the
by adrianN 7y ago
How difficult is it to build transmission lines in the US? In Germany we have enormous problems building a transmission line from the offshore windparks in the north to the industrial centers in the south. NIMBYs are opposing it fiercly.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoSame problem in the states, although it’s improving with buried HVDC (much smaller right of way required, no need to lay concrete conduit, etc).
- tracker1 7y agoSimilar in the US.. but will vary greatly depending on where you're going to/from. Of course, the NIMBYs are really against expansion of nuclear power, which by all means should be much more common than coal at this point. Especially in relatively stable locations like inland Texas, for example (and most of the non-coastal southwest us). A little NIMBY/FUD goes a long way.
- favorited 7y agoOh I've seen NIMBYs lose their minds over wind turbines too...
- zamalek 7y agoYep, it's "the noise."
- grumpydba 7y agoProbably the ugliness. I've seen great landscapes being heavily damaged by wind turbines.
- Spare_account 7y agoWhich is a subjective notion, of course. I look at a landscape full of wind turbines and I see the beauty of a species recognising it needed to change.
- hyperbovine 7y agoDitto, they make me feel like I’m living in a near-future sci-fi film. And let’s be honest, whatever natural beauty once existed in the UK was largely destroyed over the course of millennia.
- grumpydba 7y agoYeah so let's destroy pristine nature landscapes with ugly turbines (which kill a lot of birds and cost an arm to decommission). I've seen wild landscapes in Brittany completely ruined by still wind turbines. It's a disgrace. I'd rather go nuclear in select ugly places. What is beautiful is good. He who creates ugliness is evil.
- krapp 7y ago>What is beautiful is good. He who creates ugliness is evil. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder.
- grumpydba 7y agoIndeed and I do not think Anglo Saxon protestants make correct beholders in this regard. Totally subjective I admit. However I stand for my views on aestetics. I think it's an important matter and that it is open for discussion. Also, I have a deep aversion for relativism.
- hyperbovine 7y agoThere is no wilderness in Brittany that I am aware of. Very little anywhere in Europe actually. My point being, man have altered the landscape in that part of the world on a continual basis for thousands of years. Heck, people have been building windmills, the very object you object to, on this land for that long. It seems a bit rich to suddenly stand on principle and proclaim No! This should be banned! What is there left to despoil? Virgin Amazon or Boreal forest? Sure. Brittany? C’mon.
- radicalbyte 7y agoThat's why inland wind is basically banned in the UK. I totally understand the argument and if it wasn't for the fact that the climate disaster will end us I would agree. However what 2+ degrees of warming will do will dwarf anything that the turbines will do. There are also arguments about birds dying and the such. Only that's a BS argument considering that glass buildings kill 10x as many birds and are ubiquitous.
- briandear 7y agoSo why not do nuclear?
- radicalbyte 7y agoIt's too expensive to do now and has been killed in the past by the same NIMBY. Given the impact of failure I actually understand the NIMBY in relation to nuclear.
- CydeWeys 7y agoWhy not both? Also, nuclear has the whole radioactive waste and potential meltdown thing, which wind does not.
- tracker1 7y agoI'm in favor of both. There are lots of very stable locations in the US. Far from flooding and earthquakes that are suitable. Similar for wind. I think solar should be limited to existing rooftops for now though.
- nate_meurer 7y agoReally? Hinkley Point C, that's why not. In the U.S., Vogtle. These are the only nuclear power plants under construction in the UK and US. They each cost over 20 billion dollars, are heavily subsidized, and are badly behind schedule and over budget. If and when they are ever completed, the energy they produce will be more expensive than unsubsidized wind and solar in their respective regions.
- Broken_Hippo 7y agoI don't find them ugly, though, and opinions from folks I know differ.
- benj111 7y agoIt can be the light, it can cause flickering. A wind farm near us is curtailed at certain times. I don't know if it's a health thing (epilepsy), or just annoyance.
- Brakenshire 7y agoFunnily enough, Rick “dismantle the DOE” Perry championed the building of interconnectors to allow the development of wind in Western Texas, he even paid for it as a public infrastructure project!
- philwelch 7y agoIt’s entirely self-consistent for a state governor to favor state government involvement in energy while opposing federal government involvement.
- huffmsa 7y agoThe Federal Government and it's capacity to meddle should be minimized whenever possible. State and local governments are better suited for addressing the issues of their constituents.
- 6thaccount2 7y agoIt depends on the region, but most of the US doesn't have too much of a problem. There is always pushback from locals (understandable), but there has been billions in transmission built in the Oklahoma, Kansas, Nebraska, and West Texas regions to name a few areas. A lot of this is to help with the existing (ageing) infrastructure as well as helping make sure the ~22GW of currently built wind capacity can actually serve load and not be curtailed 24/7. In fact, a lot of that wind wouldn't have been built without the necessary transmission. Keep in mind that there is greater than a ~2:1 return on investment from these projects (difference in production cost in a year with the projects there and then not there) if I recall correctly. The Western Interconnect of the US seems to favor using RAS and phase-shifting transformers in order to avoid as many transmission projects. A Remedial Action Scheme is basically an automated system that keeps certain catastrophic events from happening when a certain triggering event happens. Phase shifting transformers can help push back on certain interregional flows. I think this makes more sense in the Western Interconnect as it isn't as much of a dense network as the Eastern Interconnect. You have dense load centers in Denver, California, and Oregon/Washington with a dessert and mountain range in the middle (forms a donut). It is very rural over the vast majority of the distance, so I imagine transmission is pretty expensive and harder to justify. They do have interregional planning groups in the West though.
- temp-dude-87844 7y agoIt can be difficult. NIMBYs are expected, but PACs running ads and lobbying against it and complex regulatory maneuvering happens too. For intriguing stories, read about opposition to the Plains & Eastern Clean Line through Arkansas, the Grain Belt Express Clean Line through Missouri, and the story of the Wind Catcher in Arkansas. Compare and contrast this with otherwise generous laws concerning utility easements in Arkansas.
- H8crilA 7y agoThe US has much lower population concentration, for example Texas: 40/km2, Germany: 230/km2. It makes it so much easier to build pipelines and power lines. It also makes it much less profitable to have inter-city ground level public transportation - compare American trains (low quality) with European trains (very nice and popular). Both American continents still have a lot of land that's completely unutilized, not even by any nature worth preserving.
- vkou 7y agoThe East coast of the US has a similar population density to Europe, but much worse train service.
- stevenwoo 7y agoTexas might be kind of unique in the USA for the way utility and pipeline companies can use eminent domain liberally against homeowners in order to secure property for right of way for power lines or pipelines. https://www.texasmonthly.com/politics/permian-highway-pipeline-oil-industry-landowners/ https://www.texasmonthly.com/politics/permian-highway-pipeli...