3 ms·
Two related stories. At one point way back in the day, eBay wanted to change the background color of the main page from yellow to white. They didn't just make
by jedberg 7y ago
Two related stories. At one point way back in the day, eBay wanted to change the background color of the main page from yellow to white. They didn't just make the change one day, instead they slowly changed the hex code every couple of days so the change was gradual. When it was complete, some people would say stuff like, "Hey, didn't the background used to be yellow, when did that change?".
When I worked at reddit I told this story, and we ended up using the same technique to move from a two line display to a three line display. Each day we slight changed the spacing to make it larger, until we had enough room for the three lines, and then we switched to three lines. Some people even responded to people's complaints by saying, "but it doesn't take up any more space than the old two line display!". Of course this was reddit, and at the time the code was totally open source, so someone found the daily checkins to change the spacing and outed us, forcing us to put the "compress the link display" checkbox into the preferences, which is still there to this day.
- mynameishere 7y agocompress the link display To save people from checking, this seems to turn off the preview images and the link scores. Not sure what 2- vs 3-line is referring to.
- jedberg 7y agoIf you go to old.reddit.com, each link takes three lines (the title, the metadata, and the buttons). If you check that box, it goes back to the old two line display (the title, and then metadata and buttons on one line).
- shawndrost 7y agoWow. From where I'm sitting it seems like Reddit went to the ends of the earth to make users happy during periods of change, and wound up with a prevailingly negative reputation (in its own community) for its efforts. Was that the impression internally as well?
- jedberg 7y agoHah. Yes, we felt the same. We would make every effort to make change painless, and people would complain violently. It didn't help that our website was the perfect platform for complaining about change to your favorite website. But at the end of the day we knew it was usually just a vocal minority, and when that wasn't the case, we would roll the changes back or make further changes to address feedback. Over time we learned it was better to release new stuff as beta and let people self select if they want to use it (hence the continued existence of old.reddit.com).
- opportune 7y agoReddit's UX was perfect from a (my) user point of view in like 2011. Everything added or changed since then has been either unnecessary stuff that nobody asked for, adding social network features that aren't what reddit was originally meant for, or a way to better serve ads. The only thing reddit needed was to improve the mobile experience, which they kinda did, except they have tons of annoying dark patterns in it to push you towards the app.