3 ms·
They lied about their plans to raise prices, and raising prices has caused a problem. The lie, combined with their error in judging price elasticity, is enough
by ineedasername 7y ago
They lied about their plans to raise prices, and raising prices has caused a problem. The lie, combined with their error in judging price elasticity, is enough to represent a material harm to shareholders who could not act with accurate information. Perhaps given knowledge of a price hike they would have sold, anticipating subscriber loss. Or maybe not. The fact is they were lied to, and denied the opportunity to act on accurate information. There's enough meat in that for an activist investors lawsuit on grounds of securities fraud. Even without a material loss, lying to investors is fertile ground for a suit.
- ddingus 7y agoSolid. I wish someone would take this path.
- vijayr02 7y agoSurely their legal argument would be: we intended at that time to cut prices. Events in the market since then have forced us (unwillingly and with great regret; tears in our eyes even) to revisit this decision and raise prices?
- ineedasername 7y agoIt doesn't natter. At some point, they changed their mind and didn't disclose it to investors. The investor suit would point out that when plans changed, investors were not notified and therefore were denied the opportunity to act on information that represented a risk to their investment. Public corporations are required to disclose risks. This is partly where Matt Levine's "everything is securities fraud" line of thinking comes from. The argument is that they knew, or should have known, that there was a risk, and risks must be disclosed.