3 ms·
> No neighborhood should be exempt from change. > No neighborhood should be subjected to radical change. Is there any dynamic evolutionary system that actuall
by nostrademons 7y ago
> No neighborhood should be exempt from change.
> No neighborhood should be subjected to radical change.
Is there any dynamic evolutionary system that actually follows these rules? The tech industry is famous for lumbering behemoths that are constitutionally incapable of innovation and then get replaced wholesale by nimble startups. National borders change all at once, in wars or revolutions, rather than incrementally as demographics change. Human beings don't change much after early adulthood; instead they make new humans who replace them when they die. Evolution itself seems to have periods of equilibrium when resources are abundant and nearly every individual survives, followed by abrupt speciation when resources get tight, individuals die off, and populations get isolated from one another.
The only positive example I can think of is democracy, which is specifically designed to enable gradual change so that radical change doesn't happen, and yet still frequently gets party realignments, charismatic strongmen, and the occasional revolution.
I worry that this philosophy sounds great precisely because it's not how the world works. Human beings are really bad at noticing or reacting to gradual change; it tends to pile up until it becomes too big to ignore, and then rapidly reaches a tipping point and crisis where the newly strong force out the weak. This is undesirable, but also seems largely unavoidable.
- ketzo 7y agoI mean, if we're being cynical, you say the second so that people feel comfortable with the first. If you can convince suburbanites that you won't put up a skyscraper next door, you'll have an easier time putting up a 5-story apartment building. Or so my thinking goes, anyway.
- cgriswald 7y agoPeople in my neighborhood object to every change even if it doesn’t seem to affect them. They’re mortified when a 5-story building (commercial OR residential) is built downtown when we are ten minutes away and not on a major traffic corridor.
- casefields 7y agoThat's because every time you give an inch they'll take a little bit more. So you out up a huge front and the only thing that can be approved are small nimble changes. Plus it's wildly beneficial economically to keep the status quo when it comes to owning a home in the California.
- cgriswald 7y ago> Plus it's wildly beneficial economically to keep the status quo when it comes to owning a home in the California. Commercial development of the downtown space will only increase the value of homes in my neighborhood.
- taylorlapeyre 7y agoBanks, healthcare, police forces, and many other municipal services could fit into this criteria. All of these need to change and evolve over time, but a very sudden radical shift is scary, unpredictable, and unpopular.
- dredmorbius 7y agoIs there any dynamic evolutionary system that actually follows these rules? Arguably, not really. Bernhardt J. Stern's 1930s-40s explorations into resistance of technological innovation has been revelatory to me: "Resistances to the Adoption of Technological Innovations" (1937) https://archive.org/details/technologicaltre1937unitrich/page/39 https://archive.org/details/technologicaltre1937unitrich/pag... Markdown: https://pastebin.com/raw/fZajYSGa https://pastebin.com/raw/fZajYSGa Having some item, totem, or mechanism for producing, securing, or controlling wealth, the cheapest way to grow power further is often to defend that against new advances or competition. Stern describes both technology and housing in his article.
- skunkpocalypse 7y agoDemocracy is not designed to avoid radical changes. Plenty of examples (recent ones too) of elections leading to those. Democracy is designed to avoid violent change.