4 ms·
Reading through some of the comments here, it occurs to me that there's a moral trilemma at play here: you can have power, you can have righteousness, or you ca
by nostrademons 7y ago
Reading through some of the comments here, it occurs to me that there's a moral trilemma at play here: you can have power, you can have righteousness, or you can have impartiality, but you must pick 2 out of 3. If you bring something new into the world that gives new voice or new capabilities to previously disenfranchised groups, then you have a choice between explicitly selecting who you bestow this power on (in which case you can preserve your righteousness, but sacrifice impartiality), or giving this gift away free to everyone who can make use of it (in which case you remain impartial, but will inevitably end up empowering people you find morally abhorrent). Or you can choose to do nothing and never bring anything useful into the world, which is also valid, but means you're eclipsed by people who do.
Silicon Valley (and science/tech in general) has traditionally selected power & impartiality, while nation-states and religions have traditionally selected power & righteousness. Many of the commenters here would seemingly select righteousness & impartiality, which perhaps speaks to why we're discussing this on a message board rather than bringing startups into the world.
- krajzeg 7y ago"Choose two out of three" triangles are sexy, but I fail to see how this applies here. Doing nothing doesn't really mean choosing to be impartial and righteous at the same time, and there is no way to both moderate and be impartial if you actually run a platform. I see it as every platform being able to choose a point on a sliding scale between enforcing its morality and being impartial. The more moderation you do, the less impartial you are, sure - but nobody actually wants the extremes of this scale.
- Zak 7y agoI don't think that argument applies here. The article isn't advocating censorship or legal restrictions on social media. Instead, it's saying that reducing friction from a very specific content-sharing workflow and giving it a prominent position in the UI of social media sites may not have been a good design decision. Edit: I intended this as a reply to a different comment, but it has a reply now so I'll leave it as-is.
- krajzeg 7y agoIt does apply a little if you extend the definition of "moderation" to include choosing the right set of features in order to direct your users' behavior. That said, I was mostly replying to the parent comment, not discussing the main thesis of the article.
- vinceguidry 7y agoYou can choose one or none if you want to. You just can't choose all three, because then you're doing what the article's subject described as 'handing a loaded weapon to 4 year olds'.
- Reedx 7y agoOften it just comes down to pure metrics for them. If it increases engagement metrics, keep it. If it decreases those numbers, drop or revise. Local maxima optimization.
- slowmovintarget 7y agoInteresting that only one of those three qualities is subjective. I also think you are incorrect about this being a pick-two situation. Righteousness, in addition to being subjective, is mutually exclusive with impartiality.
- nostrademons 7y agoThe way you remain both righteous and impartial is to never do anything consequential. That way, you can have the same effect for all parties while never doing anything you would find morally objectionable. It's essentially the trivial solution (magnitude of impact = 0), but is often implicitly advocated for in many debates here. It occurred to me after writing this that there's a fourth variable: integrity, defined as your willingness to have principles and critically evaluate them against others' moral conduct. You could conceivably satisfy all of power, righteousness, and impartiality by assuming, in your value system, that everyone's values are morally acceptable and mutually compatible and hence there is no conflict between your values and everyone else's values. This is a position actually advocated by some philosophers, venture capitalists, and scientists! (There's a Tom Lehrer song in there somewhere: "Once zee rockets go up who cares where they come down / that's not my department / says Werner von Braun!") It's not a mainstream one within the general population, though; most people do actually have some feelings and pass some moral judgment on other people. And yes, I was very deliberately trying to highlight the tension between objectivity and subjectivity here. (There's a lot of complexity over whether power is objective or subjective, too - power is your ability to enforce your will [subjective] over reality [objective], so it has elements of both.)
- slowmovintarget 7y agoWhat you will may be subjective, but your ability to bend others to your choices is not. Thus I'd argue power is objective. Righteousness occurs as a value assessment within a moral framework. When all values, including opposing values, are of equal worth, we have a framework of amorality, which cannot ever produce a judgement of righteousness or wickedness. In other words, the term itself reduces the frameworks which fit. All of the remaining frameworks require active choice (as far as I understand).
- leereeves 7y agoIt's absurd to describe groups whose concerns have been primary focus of American politics for 50 years, who benefit from numerous policies granting preferential treatment and have whole departments in universities devoted to their interests as "disenfranchised". And that's where most attempts to be "righteous" fail: either through shallow thinking or the desire to be popular, they favor those groups that are already politically powerful and ignore the truly disenfranchised.