3 ms·
Correct, I am not arguing that. I implied that Wire is a lesser evil of the two, but none of them are ideal. I am not sure what made you believe that I pretend
by johnisgood 7y ago
Correct, I am not arguing that. I implied that Wire is a lesser evil of the two, but none of them are ideal.
I am not sure what made you believe that I pretended e-mail is secure. I said Wire requires an e-mail address (to use), while Signal requires a phone number. No way I was ever trying to imply that e-mail is secure, because it is certainly not.
- tptacek 7y agoIt's possible we just don't have a disagreement. As long as we're not recommending encrypted email, acknowledge that email is a form of messaging, and that messaging demands a particular kind of cryptography (one not present in PGP), we could just be on the same page. I think that you'll find that among the "secure" messengers, all of the reasonable ones use a variant of Signal's constructions --- which is why Moxie and Trevor won the Levchin RWC prize for it --- boiling down to the "Axolotl" double ratchet over curves and AEAD ciphers. I endorse Signal, but when I say "secure messengers that use the Signal protocol", it's that broader cryptographic blueprint to which I refer, not the particular application. It's likely that within the next few years we'll have other reasonable blueprints from which to work; Facebook's cryptographers are hard at work on Message Layer Security, which is a group messaging construction quite different from Signal Protocol, but, again, purpose-built for messaging. For now, though, all the reasonable choices use Signal's underlying design.