5 ms·
I truly believe that spaced repetition is near-magic and it is a tragedy that it's not integrated into our society and educational system at a fundamental leve
by keiferski 7y ago
I truly believe that spaced repetition is near-magic and it is a tragedy that it's not integrated into our society and educational system at a fundamental level. It makes me shudder to think of all the years spent learning things only to forget them weeks or months later.
In any case, I've recently embarked on a long-term educational plan utilizing spaced repetition. My goal is to learn dozens of languages, historical events, philosophical theories, lines of poetry, and various other information.
I'm curious if anyone else has used spaced repetition over a long period of time with a deliberately ambitious plan. Most people seem to just use it for dabbling in language-learning or medical school, and not as a way to embed massive amounts of knowledge in the brain.
- ai_ia 7y agoCan you post your learnings and deck online. Would love to follow your journey.
- insickness 7y agoWhenever I post about spaced repetition, people ask for my decks. You're far better off making your own decks. Read through the material you want to learn and make "notes" on what you want to remember by creating questions for yourself. By using someone else's deck, you are selling yourself short.
- ai_ia 7y agoI like creating my own decks too. But checking out people's deck sometimes reveal interesting and creative ways to remember things. I learnt occlusion, multiple choice questions, sound based anki from looking at other people deck. Its like I don't like to read from other people study notes but I definitely check them out to see what I have missed.
- keiferski 7y agoI should really start a blog and chronicle the whole process. I'll let you know when I do!
- themacguffinman 7y agoThere isn't much value in memorizing vast amounts of facts like that anymore (you already mentioned two key areas where that's still needed: language and medicine). Nowadays it's better to remember where to find facts and learn quickly than to simply remember facts upfront. It's fine for you to have a personal goal of using spaced repetition to learn dozens of languages, historical events, etc, but it's really not a tragedy that it's not integrated into our society. It's good that we've moved on.
- keiferski 7y agoSorry but I disagree completely. The ability to quickly find information online doesn’t negate the fact that intellectual progress and creativity often come from making connections between disparate fields. The only way to make these deeper connections is to truly know and digest the information, not simply to google it. It is probably a consequence of the computer age that we think of information as a singular piece of data that is either known/nor known, and not as something that needs to be learned, dwelt upon, and digested over time.
- kthejoker2 7y agoBut surely that's not true of (for example) learning one's colors in German? Synthesis of ideas and innovation comes in areas of high ambiguity, subjectivity, and risk and no amount of spaced repetition will turn you into a Bucky Fuller or Raymond Loewy or Alfred Sloan. There you must substitute a voracious appetite for discovery and experimentation.
- themacguffinman 7y agoConnecting information is orthogonal to remembering it. Same with digesting information: you don't need to use something like spaced-repetition to commit knowledge to long term memory in order to digest it, you just need to spend some time understanding the info. In fact, I'd argue that spaced-repetition runs somewhat counter to deeply understanding information. It's easy to repetitively memorize and recall info without actually understanding it.
- hestipod 7y agoI've used Pimsleur at length in the past and found it the most suitable way for me to study language. The drawbacks are the limited programs, they develop at a glacial pace, if at all anymore, and each level is very expensive. But the method is wonderful. I had friends offering to help them develop their particular language into a full course 20 years ago and they said "thanks but no thanks" and there is still nothing but a 10 lesson intro program in that language...and those intro courses are a useless waste of money except to learn how to say "I speak a little <language here>" with perfect intonation. For a long time I wished someone would unseat them but it never happened. Even related theory based sites which complimented Pimsleur like Duolingo and Memrise just got worse and worse with time.
- keiferski 7y agoI recommend downloading the audio from this site and creating both text and audio Anki cards for each phrase. It’s a bit like the Pimsleur process except you’ll learn 2,000+ phrases. https://www.goethe-verlag.com/ https://www.goethe-verlag.com/
- maxm091 7y agoIn terms of price, Pimsleur is a lot more affordable these days with their subscription option at $14.95/month for a complete course.
- ignoramous 7y ago> I truly believe that spaced repetition is near-magic and it is a tragedy that it's not integrated into our society and educational system Spaced repetition is absolutely key to memorizing the Qur'an [0]-- Memorizing through space-repetition is taught at almost all Madrasas (institutes of Islamic learning) [1] to students from a very young age (it isn't uncommon for students as young as 15yrs old to memorize the entire Qur'an [2]). Revisions [3] every now and then helps; and so, that is prevalent, as well. [0] https://sfjamaat.org/sf/mtb/hifz/A%20practical%20guide%20for%20Hifz%20ul%20Quran.pdf https://sfjamaat.org/sf/mtb/hifz/A%20practical%20guide%20for... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Madrasa https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Madrasa [2] Two key orthogonal parts to memorizing the Qur'an are the rules of recitation (Tajwid) and reading (Qira'at), which prove difficult for non-Arabs. [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Test_preparation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Test_preparation
- misiti3780 7y agoI have been using spaced repetition for roughly 3 years and have seen some amazing personal growth. I was born in the US, and have now learned 2 languages (Italian B2/C1, French B1/B2, and I just started Spanish but it is so similar to italian its gonna be pretty easy to pick up ). I remember almost every book I have read in the past three years by using kindle highlights and turning them into flash- cards. I use it for Math, Computer Science, papers, new english vocabulary etc. Starting using Polar Bookshelf for IR Some general thoughts: 1. Anki is pretty complicate, it is really important to read the manual 2. Create all cards yourself. If possible, always include sounds and images. 3. Follow these steps when creating cards: https://www.supermemo.com/en/archives1990-2015/articles/20rules https://www.supermemo.com/en/archives1990-2015/articles/20ru... 4. Do your reviews every day I'm actually looking forward to seeing what is possible in say 5-10 years, after i have read 250-700 more books and studied a few more languages. It is the single best learning hack i have ever come across.
- rockdiesel 7y agoCan you give an example or two of how you effectively turn your Kindle highlights into flash cards?
- misiti3780 7y agoHere is an example from The Black Swan (cloze deletion) {{c1::The Platonic fold}} is the explosive boundary where the Platonic mind-set enters in contact with messy reality, where the gap between what you know and what you think you know becomes dangerously wide. It is here that the Black Swan is produced. Here is a basic card I read and decide if this is info I have forgotten or if I knew about this: “We had observed a real-estate transaction that takes place each night when we sleep. Fitting the notion of a long-wave radio signal that carries information across large geographical distances, the slow brainwaves of deep NREM had served as a courier service, transporting memory packets from a temporary storage hold (hippocampus) to a more secure, permanent home (the cortex). In doing so, sleep had helped future-proof those memories.” Excerpt From: Matthew Walker. “Why We Sleep.” iBooks.
- AlchemistCamp 7y ago
- AlchemistCamp 7y agoIt's not a cure-all, especially for language learning. I say this as someone who has done a ton of spaced repetition, language learning and who, in a former life, wrote curriculum for language learners. 95% of the time, if you have the option to choose between ER (extensive reading) and SRS, go with ER. SRS is very useful for certain sub-problems in language learning, though. > I'm curious if anyone else has used spaced repetition over a long period of time with a deliberately ambitious plan. An early pioneer, Piotr Wozniak, did exactly that, even to the detriment of the business success of Super Memo. He lived his life by an algorithm, timed swimming workouts to aid his SRS, put his emails through SRS, lived on a > 24 hour schedule... He basically went all in. If you're interested in SRS and its history, you might enjoy my podcast: https://alchemist.camp/learning-machine/spaced-repetition-systems https://alchemist.camp/learning-machine/spaced-repetition-sy...